Cement
Marty
Last week we had our home inspected for Escrow. The Inspector said" I need to replace the cement cap around the chiminey top with fire proof cement" Would this be the same as mortor that is used in building a Chiminey?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Cement
Marty
Last week we had our home inspected for Escrow. The Inspector said" I need to replace the cement cap around the chiminey top with fire proof cement" Would this be the same as mortor that is used in building a Chiminey?
Re: Cement
Bill Tindall
The two masons I have worked with both had the same view of chimney caps. They were to be capped with portland cement because it wasn't permeable to water while brick mortar isn't. But we live in a less government intrusive land and there are no rules covering what caps a chimney so this cement use could just be their regional notions. As far as I know portland cement is fireproof.
Re: Cement
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Your double negative there Bill, is a little confusing. My question is what kind of cement is flammable? Surely they didn't use contact cement!
How old is this house, is it new?
Re: Cement
Marty
The house was built in the 70's. I thought all cement was fire proof, but this inspector (full of himself) was specific in stating. I was just a wondering.
Re: Cement
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Maybe what is there is just falling apart, and needs to be replaces anyway. You should be able to google to find the product you need, and where to find it locally. If it is not falling apart, you may be able to find a coating, if that meets their standards.
Re: Cement
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Not knowing what you have up there, of course, we don't know what his issue was.
Firebrick and refractory mortar, used in the actual firebox part of a fireplace (or wood stove that uses brick), doesn't spall and fail when exposed to the high temperatures of a fire. But by the time the smoke hits the top of the chimney, it's nowhere near those temperatures. Around here, "cement" chimney caps are common; I think most of them are probably common mortar (can't remember the type) - portland cement, hydrated lime, sand. I've never heard of any of them catching on fire.
I'd be more concerned about a chimney cap that didn't crack to let water in.
Refractory cement or mortar
John in NM
Refractory materials are usually somewhat more insulating than regular cements and mortars. They have materials like fiberglass and perlite in them with a portland cement binder.
If you go look at the chimney top, there should be a liner, either a ceramic material or metal, depending on age and the codes when it was built. A lot of new ones are fancy double insulated metal chimneys with framed up and brick veneered faux masonry chimneys.
The only place that refractory cements or mortar are typically used (as far as I know) is in bonding the brick lining of an open hearth and in bonding the ceramic chimney liner sections together.
So I'd say your inspector is full of it, but you might want to check that with a chimney builder, or check the local codes for yourself. I suppose if there were a liner joint right at the mortar cap, you might want to use refractory mortar, but I still think it's overkill.
Re: Cement
FredD
Marty, a couple of things about Portland Cement, one, it is not fireproof and given enough heat will explode, even a section of Highway 81 exploded one hot Summer North of Salina , Kansas.
If you ever made the mistake of cutting a bolt or rebar flush with the concrete with a Acetylene Torch , you would experience flying concrete.
Firebrick is laid using a heavy cream like grout mixed with a little Fire Clay rather then a Mortar to keep the expansion from heat down enough so that the brick won't fall out.
A Chimney top typically found in a residence doesn't suffer from that high of heat, regular mortar does the trick and you only need to replace it if it needs it and if the Inspector is not a Building Inspector, get one.
House Inspectors are often like Termite Inspectors, if they don't a fault in the House , then they get creative.
Present company exempted of course.
FredD
Re: Cement
Barry Irby
As a Home Inspector I never heard of anyone capping a chimney with anything other than Portland cement or mortar. the top of the chimney is called the cap or coping and is there to seal the top and shed water. It might be better Ir it were made of and and portland cement, but I am willing to bet that the vast majority of them are mortar and sand. Mortar is basically a mix of portland cement and lime. The more lime, the easier the mortar is to handle and the stickier it is. (More Plastic) If it is rich in lime it is not as durable as if it were richer in cement. Straight cement mortar is more brittle when set and more difficult to handle when wet, less plastic.
The coping or cap is important but is considered sacrificial or short lived. About every ten years it may have to be replaced. Its considered ordinary maintenance to replace it. Lately I have been seeing them coated with some non-flammable sealer if the cement is cracked but still firmly attached. Its sealed to keep the water out.
As Bill said, this is not the application for refractory cement. Its for heat, not weather resistance.
A reputable mason or chimney sweep should be able to tell you what your local best practice is.
Re: Cement
Marty
Gentlemen, Thank you all for the input. I will go to Paso Robles tomorrow, and get some Portland Cement, Mortar Mix, and let it fly. The interior of the chimney appears to be Red Clay Pipe. The portion I was "told" needs fixing is that which slopes away from the red clay pipe, which protrudes about 7 or 8 inches above the cap. I will fix the sloping portion and see if that meets with his approvial. Thanks again.
Re: Cement
Barry Irby
Marty, Here they weather and come loose from heating and cooling and from freeze thaw activity. When its time to change them, removing the old one is RELATIVELY easy. With a little care, break up the old one and chisel it off the top. It may be very loose. Mix up a rich mix of sand and mortar or cement and recreate the sloping top.
Be careful not to break the red clay liner.
Re: Cement
Bill Tindall
Both masons I have worked with insisted on portland cement for the cap. They claimed mortar mix was permeable to water which could lead to water permeating the chimney and creating the white mineral deposits one sees on the sides of some chimneys. They just mixed the portland cement with sand and used it like mortar on the cap. Don't forget to add your initials and date; they always did.
Re: Careful with your fix
Kneale Brownson
Be aware you don't want the cement to adhere to the red clay. The chimney liner expands and contracts as it heats and cools.
Re: Cement
Galen Vetterick
Bill's comments seem right to me. Mortar is also not intended to be used in creating a thick cap. It's expansion rate in changing weather will crack in a thick layer. Portland cement is less permeable to water and can be used to create a thick layer.
I thought many of these chimneys now were updated to a chimney cap that covered the whole crown and included a spark arresting screen and cap to keep water from going down the flue. Eliminates the eventual replacement of a cement crown again some time in the future too.