Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Red (brown) oak variance?

Posts

Red (brown) oak variance?

#1

JL

Red (brown) oak variance?

JL

I usually use whatever red oak comes from the lumber yard.

A while back, I picked up some fat 8/4 "red" oak that was really quite "brown" in cast from an auction. It is really nice wood to work with. The question is, where can I find out more about the wood and what are the possibilities of getting more. It has a nice coloration without any staining. Just a little finish (oil, varnish, whatever) is all that is necessary for a reasonable color.

I've examined the pores and the grain - it is a "red" oak type of species.

There are what - maybe 500+ species of oak. I'm sure not all of them are commercially viable.

So - how can I find out the particular species of this lumber beyond "generic red oak"?

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#2

Re: Red (brown) oak variance? *LINK*

del schisler

i did a google search and their are 600 different oak's. The wood may have came from a dead tree?? the wood from a dead tree even from walnut will have a different color than from a live tree. I have sawed some dead tree's and like that wood. Here is a link that you can go and read about oak tree's


http://forestry.about.com/cs/treeid/a/the_oak.htm

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#3

JL

Not a dead tree - too much and looks too healthy

JL

I bought ~5 12' x 10" x fat 8/4 boards a while back (about 168 board feet). It was sold to me as red oak.

I've never worked with any black oak (that I know about) - so I don't know what that wood looks like.

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#4

I've seen it too.

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Where I buy my red oak, It comes in shades from pink to brown and it is all the same species. I don't think it has anything to do with whether the tree was alive or dead. I have noted that when you stain it, it all comes out the same color. I try not to mix pink and brown in the same panel if I can help it.

Lee

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#5

red oak color

Bill Tindall

The vast majority of the red oak sawed will be from the Northern or Southern Red Oak species. Some trees will saw a very red lumber, while others will saw tan. The color of the wood may be genetic or growing conditions, I don't know. It is definitely not species related. The southern oaks from Alabama and other places really south yield a more coarse grained lumber with a yellowish cast to it.

That said, leave the lumber in the sun for a bit and it all looks the same.

One is more apt to get a nice brown color from slow growth true white oak- Quercus Alba (my spelling may be off a bit here). If that is the color you want check out white oak.

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#6

JL

I can send you a small sample (or anyone else)

JL

I REALLY like the color. If I can find out for sure which sub species it is, I'll try to get some more. It does not appear to fade with exposure to light. It remains tan/brown.

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#7

Dale Lenz

Sorry, JL

Dale Lenz

Once the oak is sawn up all you can tell is it is either red or white oak. All the oaks are lump into to groups, white or red. The black oak is part of the red oak group. If you looked at your oak boards and don't see tyloses, then it's probably red oak. I'd suggest if you like the color of these oak boards, go buy some more before that "load" is sold. Some of the nicest brown color from oak I've seen has been from heartwood of the white oak.

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#8

yes indeed!

Bill Tindall

"Some of the nicest brown color from oak I've seen has been from heartwood of the white oak."

When I want brown that is where I go too. If it looks like the best brown "red oak" even seen it is probably white oak.

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

#9

McKinneyMike

Re: Red (brown) oak variance?

McKinneyMike

Red Oak variations in color are never ending, even among same species. I always prefer the "wheat" colored Northern Red Oak and request it when I order from my supplier in northern Indiana. For me the Northern Red Oak has this "wheat color" more often than the Southern Red Oak's and most cabinet shops seem to prefer the "wheat color" overall.

White Oak is almost always "a shade of a light brown, sometimes to a little darker brown. I don't mind the color variations, as long as the pack of lumber is consistent in its color.