Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Posts

OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#1

OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

JohnT in MD

About time to have the roof replaced.

Wife got an estimate from a local roofing company, and they were pushing GAF Timberline shingles, with a big part of the selling being their supposed lifetime warranty.

never heard of a lifetime warranty on shingles - I figured 20 or 25 years was about all asphalt shingles could last.

But, the salesman implied that the GAF warranty covered materials and workmanship. If the shingles need to be replaced, they'll do it, including labor. The GAF website also implies the lifetime warranty.

Sounds too good to be true. Anyone have experience with roofing warranties? Suggestions on what to look for in a shingle, and in a roofing contractor?

TIA,

-John-

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Moses Yoder

We replaced the shingles on my parent's house about 2 months ago. They were laminated shingles, not the cheap three tab shingles like my grandparents used. These shingles had a written lifetime warranty, and we kept the reciept. Any re-nigging on the warranty will be taken to court. 100 mph wind rating. I think they figure the shingles will last about 50 years and most people either die or sell their house or don't keep the warranty paper. On the other hand, for a really nice roof, install steel.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#3

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Joe Pack

Implies or states? If it is not in writing, it doesn't exist. If it is not in writing from the manufacturer, it doesn't exist. Even if it is in writing from the manufacturer, how many "outs" for the manufacturer are included in the warranty?

If it is in writing from the salesperson only, it essentially doesn't exist. If it is in writing and signed by the owner of the installing company, it might exist if you can get it honored or enforced if needed. My bet is "NOT." Will the installing company be in business for the "lifetime" of the shingle coverage?

Exactly what does the warranty cover? READ THE FINE PRINT! You might find an excellent warranty that covers you, or you might find an excellent warranty that covers the manufacturer. If the list of exclusions from warranty is more than a couple of words, it probably protects the company more than it does you.

Your lifetime of ownership only or transferrable to the next owner?

Sorry to be so pessimistic, but "once burned..." definitely applies to most warranty claims. They are only as good as the company providing the warranty service, and only when written in detail.

Not saying not to consider the warranty, but I would want iron-clad, in-writing guarantees, not just general statements or implied coverage.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#4

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Craftsman offers a lifetime warranty on its hand tools, and has for years - but take your broken rabbet plane (made up into the 1970s - I used to see them on the shelves) in for warranty replacement, and see what that means.

I concur: read the fine print, very, very carefully. Anything that's at all unclear, ask for the company - preferably GAF - to clarify it in writing.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#5

Roof pitch

Al Goldstein

John

The life of roof shingles depends on the pitch of the roof. Shingles last longer on a steep roof and have a shorter life on a flatter roof. So I agree with the others that you should look at carefully at any document. Good luck.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#6

Thanks all

JohnT in MD

Thanks for the replies.

I'll definitely be reviewing a copy of the full warranty before I commit.

I guess I was really asking is if its feasible for shingles to last more than 20 years.

These aren't the usual 3 tab ones I'm used to - are the new fangled versions that much more durable?

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#7

Clint Searl

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Clint Searl

Any of the name brand mid-grade-plus shingles will last for 30-40+ years if installed according to the manufacturer's instructions, so for practical purposes, any warranty is superfluous. Don't sweat it or make that the final decision factor.

Clint

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#8

Re: Thanks all

Barry Irby

You have gotten good advice.

Yes shingles can last more than 20 years. In fact the cheapo three tab ones carry a 25 year warranty now. The Multi- dimensional or laminated ones can last thirty or forty years or more.

The warranty is probably worthless unless you carefully read and follow the fine print. For one thing, the work has to be done by a certified installer, not just any roofer. The installer must sign the warranty and he/they must attest to proper ventilation and pitch. and you must get a written warranty, not just a label that says Lifetime. Be certain the warranty is from the manufacturer, not the installer. Unlikely the installer will be around when you need work.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#9

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty *LINK*

Gary Smyth

On my old house I had GAF Timberline heavy asphalt shingles. They had a 30 year warranty. The new ones are (limited) lifetime. See link. Press the arrow for screen message.


http://www.gaf.com/upgrade/

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#10

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Tom Minehan

I'm sitting here right now with a GAF "Smart Choice Warranty" in hand. If I understand the coverage correctly, it will pay the "reasonable" cost to replace the defective roof for a period of 10 years. After that the the amount paid will be reduced by prorating to reflect the "use you have recieved from your roof". This is calculated by "dividing the number of months that have elapsed since installation by the number of months in the warranty period".

I have had this roof for only 11 years and the shingles on the dormer part are crumbling and I have a leak. The company that did the installation is ignoring my calls. I plan on contacting GAF directly to find out how to get the warranty enforced. Just my luck that this happened in year 11 and not 10.

I will post what GAF replies.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#11

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Tom Minehan

I forgot to include the words "System Plus" in my warranty name.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#12

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

FredD

Clint is correct about the life of a good quality three tab shingle.

I recommend Heritage Shingles with the forty year life weight , I have them on every roof I own at present.

The shingles of any brand will not survive a large hail storm , so keep your Home Owners insurance current.

Last week on Wednesday in Abilene a hail storm hit at 8:30PM and then returned at 11:00 PM and destroyed over six hundred roofs in Abilene including a rental of ours and the Shingles were six years old.

State Farm estimated 4,300.00 dollars to replace, took off 920.00 dollar Wind and Hail deductible, cut us a check on the spot , my roofer will get to it in about a month.

We were at a committee meeting for my 55th class reunion this fall at the Farm House restaurant on the West edge of Abilene when the storm roared through the first time.

My Pickup sustained 3,700.00 damages and it was the least damaged of about ten classmates vehicles there.

Hail ranged from Golf ball to Softball size and the next day State Farm had a Catastrophic Event team set up in a tent on the High school parking lot , two days later they called us and I went in , took about thirty minutes and they cut the check right there.

I can't say enough about the efficiency of State Farm in that storm event.

I heard two days ago that they totaled all vehicles from year 2000 and older and reimbursed the owner for the value of the vehicle.

Last week was a dandy.

Back to the posters roofing, I can say from many years of contracting that you can save some money by buying the shingles from a Roofing Supply , rather then the Roofer, the Supply will deliver and run the shingles up on a elevator when the Roofer calls for them.

I only deal with workmen and suppliers, the salesmen will tell you what he thinks you want to hear.

Have the Roofer in his contract, include new roof jacks and vent caps and Chimney flashing if you have one and specify 30 Lb. felt underlayment , rather then usual 15 Lb. The cost is only few bucks more and well worth the investment.

Also inspect the gutters , if they need replacing , that is the time to do it.

Use a local Roofer with a long history of good work in your area and that should give you all that you need.

FredD

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#13

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

JMOHNIKE

Forget most of the above. Check with your homeowners insurance carrier. Here in California, most insurance carriers want a roof replaced at 20-25 yrs. with the exception to tile, slate and some metal roofs. It makes no difference what guarantee the shingles have. There are a few companies that will write a house with a roof over 20 yrs, but they exclude roof damage and any related damage and the policy costs 45-55% more. Talk to your insurance company or agent first then decide.

Joe M.

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

Moses Yoder

That sounds pretty typical for California. There, they probably can't tell the difference between a standard 3 tab shingle that lasts about 25 years or a laminated shingle that easily lasts 50 years or a steel roof that will last a hundred years. Let's not mention slate or tile. I mean really, who is going to replace a shingle that is gauranteed to last a lifetime every 25 years?

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#15

Clint Searl

Huh?

Clint Searl

So this means that a roof should be replaced every 20 years at a cost of $Thousands even if it has another 20 years of normal life just to retain some prorated insurance coverage? Gimme a break.

Clint

Re: OT: Roofing Shingles/Warranty

#16

Re: OT:  Roofing Shingles/Warranty

FredD

Well that's certainly helpful John , which part of the above should he forget or better still which part should he remember.

I lived in CA for forty years , contracted there for a long time, nothing in your response is new about insurance companies and depreciation , they all do it .

The Spanish tile roofs in Abilene all had holes the size of softballs and larger and the few steel roofs were bent all to hell and looked like a herd of Cattle had a hoedown on them and they all leaked.

The roofer I use and have used for the last 14 years , had not found a Asphalt Mineral coated shingle roof that leaked from hail damage though over six hundred roofs of all types have to be replaced.

About insurance companies, they all exist to collect premiums , some are much better consumer oriented then others.

Some like I just heard on the news (AllState) are refusing to pay claims in the Joplin , Mo. disaster and that probably will not be allowed, if their insurance Commissioner stands for the consumer.

FredD