Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

Posts

Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

This from NPR's Morning Edition show today:


CPSC Tablesaw Regulations Pending

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#2

We know better. We will control the vertizontal

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#3

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thanks Ellis...interesting. I am not opposed to it but I do hope that the CPSC finds a generic name for the technology instead of "Saw Stop Techology". That way there would be no manufacturer bias in the marketplace.

Tom

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#4

Steve Strickland

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

Steve Strickland

Thanks, Ellis.

I strongly agree that a stop technology should be required.

They added a stop technology to printing presses in the 1970's that saved countless thousands of fingers and hands. Everyone complained about OSHA interference at the time. Prior to that just about every printer had missing fingers, joints or skin grafts and a few had an entire hand or arm ripped off. Those injuries became much more rare as the technology matured.

It came a couple of years too late for one of my fingertips (messed up my F chords). One pressman lost his right index finger on the last press in our shop without the upgrade. The last injury we had was when a press helper bypassed the safety and crushed his arm up to his shoulder. It took 2 hours to disassemble the press to rescue him while they were giving him blood transfusions to keep him alive.

Play it safe, ya'll. Use the stop technology. Never can tell when ya might need a good F chord!

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#5

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

Howard Norman

What an example of the federal government overreaching! I believe that the do-gooders of this country will bring the US to the ground in another 10-20 years if we don't find a way to stop them.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#6

How Dare They

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

mess with our Constitutional rights to mutilate ourselves and then use our sick days to take off work! Another liberal pinko plot, no doubt.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: How Dare They

Moses Yoder

While they are at it, why not just change the constitution so we no longer have the right to keep and bear arms? More people are killed and maimed by guns every year than on tablesaws. How many times have you read of a terminal accident on a tablesaw? In most states I believe they have made it illegal to shoot yourself, which really makes sense to me. After all, if the government is going to mandate safety, why not really go for it? Outlaw drinking and driving while you are at it, that way we won't have any more deaths caused by drunks.

In a capitalist democracy, it seems like people should have the right to choose what table saw they want. In a socialist government, they should be told what tablesaw to buy by their government. I guess the constitution so far protects our right to have a gun, but not a tablesaw.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#8

Re: How Dare They

John Lucas

don't want to get a gun thing going but if you've ever looked at all the safety things required on guns it's mind boggling. Our legislatures obviously have too many people offering them money to pass up a chance to pass another bill we don't need.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#9

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

George, Oxford, NC

Attached is link to the CPSC Survey of Stationary Saw injuries.

A couple of excerpts:

88% were due to contacting the blade (of those 56.9% were when the blade was above the top of the work surface).

Saw was running in 94.5% of the cases.

George


http://www.cpsc.gov/library/foia/foia11/os/statsaws.pdf

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#10

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

del schisler

If i invented it and payed all that money . I would do what is being done right now. Personaly i don't belive it should be law. If you want it than have the option to buy it. Don't make it a law and raise the price of the saw's. That will only make the old saw's say around longer and make them more $$$$'s Look around the shop and see what else can take off a finger?? I guess every body can stop the home shop thing. Just one more crap thing the gov. need's to stay out of and let the people buy if they want. my 3 cent's inflation

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#11

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, John.

Ellis Walentine

This isn't about guns, even as metaphors for something else. We've proven many times that gun discussions are poison.

Ellis

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#12

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

Brian From Monument

I don't believe that the government should pass "safety" rules that require the possession of a sole sourced patented item. I have heard that the saw-stop technology has problems with PT and wetter than normal wood. Can anybody substantiate that?

If they want to mandate it then they should break the patent or require a minor (read as less than 1$ royalty).

I personally have cut the end of my finger with my jointer.

Yet I will continue to use my jointer.

I have never had a saw blade contact with a table saw.

(let alone radial arm saw, chop saw or band saw.)

A question for the readers of this thread and this site might be have any of you had a table saw blade injury?

For the regulators I have one question; When do we get safer aviation fuel and materials for aircraft?

Why take your incompetence out on woodworkers (I know FAA vs CPSC)?

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#13

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings

John Lucas

I have a question. How many times do you use a table saw and not have the blade protrude above the work. DAdo's and Rabbits are about the only time. So it would make sense that most of the accidents happen when the blade is above the work.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#14

In a socialist government . . .

steve mackay

. . . they're still useing pit saws and WWII hand saws (made in evil capitalist states) if not adzes. No need for tool regulation THERE ! :D

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#15

Re: Thanks, John.

Chuck Lenz

Yeah, from what I've seen, around the internet is that a SawStop discussion can become very heated as well. And on that note I will add that I can't stand the subject. I would luv to say more, but I won't just to keep the peace.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#16

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As happened to my thumb, after the workpiece had passed the leading edge of the blade. Of course, there's also the scenario where an operator leaves the machine running and contact is made with no wood present.

m

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: In a socialist government . . .

Moses Yoder

I guess I won't say too much, but it amused me to look up the word "socialism" at dictionary.com and read the 3rd definition. I thought the word fit our government like a glove.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#18

Re: How Dare They

Yonak

The actions of the US government are so inconsistent it leaves me scratching my head. It reminds me of that old English saying about "...penny wise and pound foolish...." They want to institute regulations to protect a few people's fingers while they send thousands of citizens overseas to get maimed or killed as they maim and kill thousands of other people of the world. Instead of the Saw-Stop they should be instituting the War-Stop.

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#19

Sounds Like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Two Plans.

How's about if we do both? :)

Re: Update on Tablesaw CPSC Hearings *LINK*

#20

ROFL ! . . .

steve mackay

You KNOW you're right ! Our "to each"s almost out number our "from each"s. ;)