Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

Posts

Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

#1

Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

Mark

My son is finishing up his first year WW'g in High School, and as a closing project wants to turn a small bowl.

The approach he is taking ( not sure if this is the teachers suggestion or not) is to make 5 separate 8"square x 3/4 thick panels that are made by edge gluing up 2 4" wide by 8" long pieces to make each panel.

Then his plan is to face glue these 5 panels together to get a blank that is about 4 inches thick.

I have limited turning expoerience with bowls as I use my lathe mostly for spindle work and I am concerned that this bowl blank glue up procedure with both face and edge glue joints throughout will make the blank unstable and dangerous to turn?

Looking for some input here as to whether this is safe to do.

I am going to look for a nice 4-5" thick solid piece of stock he can turn to avoid the gluing, but would still be interested in whether this approach is safe?

thanks

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

#2

Ellis Walentine

Laminations *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Laminated wood is a proven technology, and modern glues are more than able to hold a bowl blank such as you described together safely. When glued, such a blank shouldn't turn any differently than a piece of solid wood that size, except that the fuzz patterns from your lathe tools on the surface of the bowl will be less uniform depending on the individual boards you're gluing.

Laminations like this are all what we call "long-grain" joints, essentially gluing the sides of the wood fibers together. Long-grain joints, when glued properly, are routinely shown to be significantly stronger than the wood tissue itself. The joints you want to avoid are the "end-grain" joints, where the end of one board is glued to the end or side grain of another piece of wood. Since wood in cross section resembles a bundle of soda straws at the microscopic level, glue gets wicked up into this end grain and starves the joint of glue, resulting in a weak bond. As long as you avoid end-grain joints and use adequate amounts of fresh glue -- white or yellow carpenter's glue or hide glue are most commonly used -- and clamp everything together with enough pressure to bring the surfaces into tight contact, you should be fine. Be sure your son flattens each of the layers before gluing the whole stack together, as misaligned or warped layers will interfere with good contact with adjacent layers.

Ellis Walentine, Host

PS For turning questions, you ought to post on our Turning forum.


WoodCentral Turning Forum

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

#3

Re: Laminations

Mark

Thanks

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

#4

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

John Lucas

Mark I did exactly that for all my first big turning projects. It was the only way I knew to get big wood. The wood won't come apart as long as the joints are good tight glue joints.

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

#5

Re: Glued up Bowl Blank Safety Question

John McGaw

The way you describe the proposed lamination technique it seems as though there could either be all long-grain joints or alternating layers of cross-grain joints in the final blank. Either one, if prepared and glued properly will yield a blank which will be plenty strong and safe for turning but the latter might make something which may suffer joint opening and failure down the road. As for durability, I have in my possession a walnut/maple lamp which I turned in shop class some 45+ years back and it survived both my clumsy turning efforts and the intervening years and everything is intact. I'd be hard pressed to describe the pattern in which I glued up the wood in words but all of the joints are long-grain and run the height/length of the lamp and despite being made with plain wood glue everything is tight.

I've attached a quick snapshop of a multi-jointed bowl made by the talented professional turner Rollin Loewenstein in Fairbanks, Alaska. It is made up of more pieces of cocobolo than I care to count and in every joint there is glued a layer of pear veneer. I have two of his gallery turnings in my collection , both done of glued pieces of these species which are none too easy to join, and they are all as solid as anything you'd ever get from a single hunk of wood.