Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

Posts

Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#1

Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

Stuart Johnson

I use a pencil (Rockler) to mark measuring and set up lines, faces, edges etc. These are normally very temporary and a wipe with a bit of acetone will take them right off. The other day I marked four Red Oak face frames for biscuits, cut the slots and cleaned up the marks on three. The next morning the acetone wouldn't remove the marks from the fourth. A little light sanding did the job but that got me to wondering about the marks. I don't see how a pencil mark could set or dry like ink but it sure seemed to.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#2

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

John McGaw

Well, a 'regular' pencil lead is made from graphite and clay and a few trace materials and is literally fired like a ceramic as it is being made so I doubt that it could be drying after application. It might be that the microscopic particles in the mark are settling into the pores of the wood with time or that it is reacting with the wood's moisture and setting that way. Given that you are dealing with oak I guess it could even be that one of the trace ingredients in the pencil mark is iron and that it is reacting with time with the tannic acid in the wood leaving a black reaction product.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#3

JL

Agreed

JL

Though I vote more for the graphite getting into the pores and crevices of the wood.

As an "aside" - I often use Artist's colored ink pencils to mark green lumber - it will "set" a bit - but you can't use graphite pencils on wet wood.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#4

Re: Agreed

John Lucas

There's also the possibility that you pressed harder and left a dent in the wood that contains the graphite. I know I've had that happen. I switched to softer led pencil when I have to do extensive marking on pieces.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#5

Re: Agreed

AZ in Colorado Springs

I use a carpernter's pencil to label parts or note the time of a glue up, for just that reason. Wider piece of lead, rounded over -- and I write lightly and the mark is just on the surface.

I would not use that pencil to mark for cutting -- I usually use a marking knife for that.

The carpenter pencil does not leave a dent or put the lead "into" the wood.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#6

Re: Agreed

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

I slap on a 2" square of masking tap and write on all sorts of needed information with a Sharpie. At least I can see that. It goes where it won't interfere with milling and joinery. It removes easily and a quick pass with a scraper removes any residue.

Getting older is hard on the eyes.

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#7

Re: Agreed

FredD

A"hard grade" Carpenters pencil will definitely make a groove or indent inwood, that's why I use a medium grade, better mark then a hard one and easier to remove.

When I am marking lumber for a panel glue up , plain old white chalk seems to be the easiest to read and remove.

FredD

Re: Does Pencil Lead Set or Dry?

#8

Re: Agreed

Ron in Sterling, CT

Fred,

I'm with you. White chalk is my friend in the shop. Easy to use, and even easier to remove when I get to the final scraping, or sanding.

Ron