Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

On the color of walnut

Posts

On the color of walnut

#1

On the color of walnut

Bill Tindall

There was some interest in the recent discussion of walnut stain, walnut color, etc. Here is some more information:

Walnut will change color with age. The purples of a freshly milled surface of walnut that is not steamed are fleeting in sunlight. Similarly, the sooty dark shades of steamed walnut are similarly fleeting in sunlight. No matter what one starts with, walnut's color will bleach in sunlight first to a warm brown and then to a much lighter yellowish brown, a color I don't find attractive.

Similarly, the finish one puts over walnut will also change, but in this case finishes darken and tend to become more yellow. An exception are the water based acrylics that tend to stay more water-white and shellac that more or less preserves its color.


This photograph shows a jewelry box , a chest of drawers and a drawer from a new chest of drawers. All these pieces are stained with a mineral pigment stain that should show no color change with age. The drawers are finished with an alkyd varnish and the jewelry box with garnet shellac. Note that the reds in the new drawer(1 month old) are faded in the old drawer(2 years old) to a more yellow brown because the finish has darkened and yellowed as well as what ever bleaching of the walnut that has occurred. The jewelry box (several years old) is still reddish because the garnet shellac is reddish and tends to stay that color.


In the second picture neither the gun stock nor the speaker cabinet were stained. The stock was finished almost 50 years ago with linseed oil and the speaker cabinet was finished 35 years ago with lacquer. The speaker cabinet illustrates why I stain walnut. The walnut color is largely faded from this surface and the current color is dominated by the yellowing of the nitrocellulose lacquer. In contrast, the linseed oil has darkened considerably, preserving some of the original color of the wood. The linseed oil may even retard bleaching, I don't know.

Re: On the color of walnut

#2

Ellis Walentine

Interesting, Bill. Thanks.

Ellis Walentine

Your explanation is a good one. I wonder what that gunstock would look like if it had been in bright light for all that time -- whether the linseed oil would have prevented it from yellowing and lightening -- or, for that matter, if another oil or varnish instead of linseed oil would have resulted in similar richness of color over time?

Another variable not covered in your post is the use of dyes versus pigment stains. Dyes are not as lightfast as pigments, but they stain the harder wood tissues better, and some, particularly the water-soluble varieties have fairly good resistance to UV. I often use both dyes and pigments in a stain regime to get a depth and complexity of color and shading that neither provides when used by itself.

Ellis

Re: On the color of walnut

#3

Re: On the color of walnut

Gary Bindel

I am currently building a crib out of walnut. My daughter was due July 3, but because the baby is in the breach position, they are going to do a C-section on June 27th. So, I'm down to less than two weeks. I really like the look of the jewelry chest. I would appreciate it if you tell me what brand/tint you used and what finish would be appropriate for on the crib?

Re: On the color of walnut

#4

Re: On the color of walnut

Bill Tindall

The stain is simply "burnt umber" oil pigment. I buy burnt umber "Japan Color" available from most woodworking suppliers and mix 10-15% by weight of this pigment with either "clear" General Finishes oil stain or thinned varnish. Instead of General Finishes clear I think one could use any of the "prestain" conditioners.

The top coat is garnet shellac.

I don't have any opinion on what would be a good crib finish.

We were building, and living in, a house upon arrival of our first and she slept in the bath tub for a while. They arrive tiny so they will fit anywhere to sleep. Will remove pressure from premature completion of crib.

Re: On the color of walnut

#5

I was thinking the same...

John in NM

Rifles often spend most of their time in cases or safes, or at least in the back of the coat closet, where UV is a bit scarce. I've always assumed that this is why you don't see lots of faded stocks around, but it would be interesting to know the correct answer rather than my assumption.

I remember kidding my sister, who's an art conservator, that if she and her colleagues had their way, museums would be dark, have no doors or windows, and be filled with nitrogen :D

Re: On the color of walnut

#6

Re: Interesting, Bill. Thanks.

Hikmet C. Sakman Victoria, BC CDN

Hi Ellis, Bill,

In my experience, nothing else darkens wood and adds depth like linseed oil. I don't know what it does chemically, but linseed oil provides the deepest, richest color to the wood, especially in darker woods. Some hard maple varieties would be an exception, but still works on figured Western maple very well despite the lighter color of maple.

Of course, what I said above is limited to "natural color look".

Chico...

Re: On the color of walnut

#7

darkening by oil

Bill Tindall

The difference between the lacquered walnut and the oiled walnut is the oil, not sun exposure. The speaker cabinet has always lived in a very subdued light environment. The gun has been many hours in sun and other times in similar subdued light as the speaker walnut.

Re: On the color of walnut

#10

That is interesting, but it begs a question...

John in NM

The clear inference to draw here is that linseed oil therefore has made the walnut gunstock more color stable when exposed to UV.

I don't think you meant to imply that, more likely that though the color still fades in sunlight, the oil has darkened it more than say, lacquer, to start with, so over the years it appears to remain dark?

So why go to all the trouble of staining and such when you can just wipe on some linseed oil :D (I don't really expect an answer to that, just poking a bit :D )

Re: On the color of walnut

#11

I don't know......

Bill Tindall

I don't know why lacquered walnut and oiled is so vastly different. I would have expected the oil to simply yellow and the wood beneath to bleach, yet the gun stock as well as other things I have "oiled" are reddish, not hugely unlike the freshly burnt umber-stained walnut. There might be chemistry going on between the oil and wood to make the reddish, or light blocking to preserve it.