Long
Gary Smyth
I was in a situation similar to yours starting in February. My solution was to hit the house sales. Perhaps here�s a case for buying the best tool you can afford.
Maybe not.
I�m sure you will find compelling arguments here for Tim the Tool Man Jet Engines or expensive alternatives but not so fast. Here are my findings.
Buy a wet dry vac, and use washable wet/dry filters.
Use a 1 �� hose with as smooth inside as possible. For a dedicated home shop tool that will be plenty. It draws better than larger diameter hoses and the connections to portable and other stationary tools will be easier.
Get a non-metal tub. Five gallon will be fine for dedicated tool use, you won�t have to empty it too often, and it can be lifted full without a problem when it is emptied.
Forget HEPA filters for a shop. They will clog in five minutes and the filters are expensive. Even for dust collection for a band saw you may think that you won�t collect fines, but you would be mistaken. See photo taken today. Detritus is off of my band saw and nearby floor.
Make sure the exhaust from the unit goes other that straight up
Get something that is not top heavy with motor and attachments and hose (more later).
Less noise is better � none of the pictured can be used w/o hearing protection even for a short time. According to the net the sound level for an interior vac at 3 feet average 70dB but shop vacs in a "hard" room get loud and vary greatly.
Get casters that do not rust and are as close to the tub as possible.
2.5 HP is all you will ever need with a 4 ft. hose. Find a unit that will hold the hose when not running. Loose, flopping hoses are a huge pain
6 amps will draw nicely through a 12 foot 1�� hose, if shorter the better it draws. I have a small tub 2.5 amp vac that works better than most I own.
Make sure that the top can be locked down tightly and that the air seal gasket is heavy duty. These get gritty early and are hardly ever sold separately
I bought all of the units in the picture except for the gray tubbed large Craftsman in the rear for $14 or less, and sometimes as low as $2-$3. All they required was a GOOD cleaning, a new filter ($12), perhaps a hose ($1- $1.50/ft) (go to a swimming pool supplier), and occasionally new casters ($2 for a set at flea markets). For me they work fine and at around $25 and an evening cleaning them/to get them operating saved me a bunch. The Craftsman gray tub 25 gallon at rear I paid full price, $79, in 1970. It�s a bear to handle, is unstable, noisy, can build up a nasty static electrical shock, and bulky. Most parts are long unavailable. I�ve been waiting for it to die, but it hasn�t for over 40 years. It gets the truly dirty work. Back then I wanted a big tub so I wouldn�t have to empty it so often, but it�s never had more than three inches of sawdust in it or 2� of liquid in the bottom before the filter had to be changed because the efficiency drops substantially. It also gets suprisingly heavy. So with the filter change I empty it then. I also reuse the filter if only dust. I blow it out with air from the rear, then wash it with a water hose, and three days later when it�s dry it�s good to go...
Some units are unstable with the motor at the top. I drop in a vinyl covered (no rust) 10 lb free weight in the tub bottom to keep it upright when pulling it around. Outrigger casters catch everything and you pull it from the top so keep it bottom heavy.
I would love to have an industrial cyclone unit with the power unit outside, but what I have works, they are portable, I can use more than one in multiple locations without schlepping one unit around. I use em for litter, tractor foost, shop work, car, and I don�t worry about my investment in any of them..
