Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

need small shop-vac suggestion

Posts

need small shop-vac suggestion

#1

need small shop-vac suggestion

Bill Tindall

I need a shop-vac that will be used primarily for a band saw. Band saws don't generate exceptionally fine dust so it doesn't need an exceptionally fine filter. Presuming this vac would be relatively small I would also likely use it for occasional shop tidy-up, or the once every few years vacuuming of the truck, etc.

Because it was available, I am currently using a vac that mounts on a 55 gal drum and it is just too large for the task- unhandy to more around and it takes up too much space. So I am willing to set aside some of my frugality and buy something more suited.

While I have never needed it, would a wet/dry be a good idea in case I need it?

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#2

PS

Bill Tindall

If you don't have a specific suggestion...what features should I look for. I know nothing about shop-vacs.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#3

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

Janice Manuel

I have several Ridgid shop vacs and they work fine. I have one that the motor can be lifted off the base and used as a blower, another medium sized one that gets hooked to various belt/spindle sanders as dust collection, and one small one I hook to Random Orbit sanders....

None were expensive, all are wet/dry type...they will be replaced if/when they wear out....

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#4

JL

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

JL

I have two Ridgids - one of which is a "Door-buster" special.

The Ridgids work well and haven't given me any problems. I would not suggest the "Door-buster" special as the hoses for that one are a bit light-weight (1 7/8") and thin gauge. The other 14 gallon Ridgid has good hoses, good accessories and works well.

I would not recommend Shop Vacs (brand) - I bought one of those for the playhouse a couple of years ago and I don't like the really small diameter hose or the noise it makes.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#5

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

Joseph Mulherin

Janice... names of the vacs, please....so others can also buy them

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#6

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion *LINK*

Dave Paine

There are a number of small shop vac's which would work for a dedicated band saw use.

Link is one of them. Happens to be Shop Vac brand. Another poster does not like this brand. My first vac was a Shop Vac brand. Very noisy. I do not know how long it lasted.

It was replaced by a Sears, which was replaced by a Rigid (still in part time use) which was replaced by a Fein.

The Fein is quiet for a shop vac, as are the Festtool models. Both brands are expensive, but I would not want to give up my Fein. It is too expensive for a dedicated machine use.

Most brands other than Fein and Festtool use a universal motor which provides the vacuum and cooling for the motor. High speed results in high noise. Fien and Festtool use two motors.

The blurb for the one in the link claims quiet. I have no idea whether true or not.

Wet/dry can be useful, but it you use for wet, remember to empty the drum and allow the filter to dry or else you will get serious mold.

Shop vacs are relatively high suction and low flow. By comparison a dust collector is relatively high flow at low suction.


http://www.google.com/products/catalog?hl=en&sugexp=ldymls&pq=shop+vac+sears&xhr=t&q=shop+vac+hang+up&cp=11&safe=active&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&biw=1100&bih=816&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbm=shop&cid=5657454384861620547&sa=X&ei=E3DzTfmoE4TogQf2oL3UCw&sqi=2&ved=0C

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#7

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

John McGaw

I don't think that you could go wrong with a Fein. I certainly wouldn't want to dedicate something so useful to merely sucking up a bit of bandsaw dust but I guess you could. Oh, and with the micron cartridge filter it can suck up even the finest dust. This feature along with the automatic on/off switch triggered by a sander plugged into the vac allows the closest thing to dustless sanding I've seen.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#8

Some suggestions

Al Goldstein

Bill,

I have a Fein and I love it, but I wouldn't recommend it as a machine dedicated vac. Any less expensive small vac will work for you.

I would recommend that you also get replacement paper filters that fit like a bag over the main cartridge filter. They are much less expensive, increase the life of the cartridge filter and are disposable. I presently use Multifit Replacement Filters #VF2002 (3 for $5.58 at your local borg).

Also, build a plywood box around the vac and line it with any available foam. This will cut down the noise considerably. Just be sure to include baffled air vents for its exhaust.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#9

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

Nick Tuzzolino

The mid-size Fein would do everything you want to do and it is the QUIETEST of all (that I know of). I have two Feins in addition to my full size dust collection system. Works for me.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#10

Long

Gary Smyth

I was in a situation similar to yours starting in February. My solution was to hit the house sales. Perhaps here�s a case for buying the best tool you can afford.

Maybe not.

I�m sure you will find compelling arguments here for Tim the Tool Man Jet Engines or expensive alternatives but not so fast. Here are my findings.

Buy a wet dry vac, and use washable wet/dry filters.

Use a 1 �� hose with as smooth inside as possible. For a dedicated home shop tool that will be plenty. It draws better than larger diameter hoses and the connections to portable and other stationary tools will be easier.

Get a non-metal tub. Five gallon will be fine for dedicated tool use, you won�t have to empty it too often, and it can be lifted full without a problem when it is emptied.

Forget HEPA filters for a shop. They will clog in five minutes and the filters are expensive. Even for dust collection for a band saw you may think that you won�t collect fines, but you would be mistaken. See photo taken today. Detritus is off of my band saw and nearby floor.

Make sure the exhaust from the unit goes other that straight up

Get something that is not top heavy with motor and attachments and hose (more later).

Less noise is better � none of the pictured can be used w/o hearing protection even for a short time. According to the net the sound level for an interior vac at 3 feet average 70dB but shop vacs in a "hard" room get loud and vary greatly.

Get casters that do not rust and are as close to the tub as possible.

2.5 HP is all you will ever need with a 4 ft. hose. Find a unit that will hold the hose when not running. Loose, flopping hoses are a huge pain

6 amps will draw nicely through a 12 foot 1�� hose, if shorter the better it draws. I have a small tub 2.5 amp vac that works better than most I own.

Make sure that the top can be locked down tightly and that the air seal gasket is heavy duty. These get gritty early and are hardly ever sold separately

I bought all of the units in the picture except for the gray tubbed large Craftsman in the rear for $14 or less, and sometimes as low as $2-$3. All they required was a GOOD cleaning, a new filter ($12), perhaps a hose ($1- $1.50/ft) (go to a swimming pool supplier), and occasionally new casters ($2 for a set at flea markets). For me they work fine and at around $25 and an evening cleaning them/to get them operating saved me a bunch. The Craftsman gray tub 25 gallon at rear I paid full price, $79, in 1970. It�s a bear to handle, is unstable, noisy, can build up a nasty static electrical shock, and bulky. Most parts are long unavailable. I�ve been waiting for it to die, but it hasn�t for over 40 years. It gets the truly dirty work. Back then I wanted a big tub so I wouldn�t have to empty it so often, but it�s never had more than three inches of sawdust in it or 2� of liquid in the bottom before the filter had to be changed because the efficiency drops substantially. It also gets suprisingly heavy. So with the filter change I empty it then. I also reuse the filter if only dust. I blow it out with air from the rear, then wash it with a water hose, and three days later when it�s dry it�s good to go...

Some units are unstable with the motor at the top. I drop in a vinyl covered (no rust) 10 lb free weight in the tub bottom to keep it upright when pulling it around. Outrigger casters catch everything and you pull it from the top so keep it bottom heavy.

I would love to have an industrial cyclone unit with the power unit outside, but what I have works, they are portable, I can use more than one in multiple locations without schlepping one unit around. I use em for litter, tractor foost, shop work, car, and I don�t worry about my investment in any of them..

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#11

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

Barry Irby

Bill, I have an old (close to forty years) Sears vac. It refuses to die and keeps on suckin. Recently I left it on a job and a family member borrowed it. I needed it, but decided it would be simpler to buy one than go rescue the old beast. I bought on of the door buster special Shop Vacs at Lowe's. It was cheap. Less than $30. The shoe was small, so I bought a larger one (2 1/4"?) and that helped, but it still a piece of crap and the hose and wands cost almost as much as the vac. The switch barely works. Not much suction. Filter clogs quickly. Its not nearly as powerful as the old Sears Vac. Both of them are noisy, really noisy. Some of the Lowe's Shop Vac's may be better and more powerful, but I could not recommend the 14 Gal (?) one I have.

How about mounting the one you have on a smaller drum?

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#12

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

David Yoho

Bill, I've got a Festool vac but only use it with my Festool sanders. They're too expensive to buy just for the purpose you stated, I believe.

For years I've been using a Craftsman 16 gallon wet/dry vac for dust control at my RAS. It's also used to clean the shop, and dust control for the spindle sander, the stationary belt/disc sander, and my smaller (14-inch) band saw when needed.

I'm on my second one in twenty-plus years. It rolls around nicely and picks up dust from the machines quite well.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#13

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Bill,

I�ve been using a Rigid 16 Gal, �6.0 HP Peak� model WD16500 wet or dry shop vac for about 11 � 12 years. It has the removable motor to use as a blower, but I can�t recall ever having used that feature. It�s a bit noisy, but serves well as both a shop cleanup machine and has also done �wet� duty for a couple of minor natural disasters involving water. I used it for machine dust collection for a few years until I got a used DC, which is much better for the planer and TS, but the shop vac would probably do pretty well for the BS.

In my small shop space, where floor space is at a premium, I keep it stashed in a back corner of the shop, and have a 15-20 foot hose and a an RF remote control. This lets me bring the hose to the machine or work and start and stop it from across the room. The remote is from Grizzly, the hose extensions from HD. Note the remote has two transmitters with it so when one is misplaced or across the room, there is another close at hand.

I don�t think the model I have is available, but there are similar ones that I expect would do the job.

I don�t think it pays to spend too much on a shop vac, the only feature on the more expensive ones that I see as being desirable is the lower noise level, but I don�t see that as being worth the 100 to 300 dollar price increase.

Vac: http://www.ridgidparts.com/vacs/WD16500.phtml

Remote: http://www.grizzly.com/products/Remote-Control-110V-75-Range/H2797

Bob in NJ

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#14

Follow up question...

Bill Tindall

First thank you for all the helpful advice. I paid $500 for the saw. I will not put a vac on it that costs near as much.

I looked at some on-line literature for a brand called "Sop-Vac". These things seem to have disposable bags for dust collection, apparently like wife's hose vacuum cleaner. This seems like a poor idea for my application. I would spend a fortune in bags. Hence the question... What is the best option for where the saw dust will wind up and what ever filter is involved? These things have a tank. Why would they have a bag? What is the best kind of filter.. Someone mentioned a washable filter which seems the best idea for my application. Is washable common?

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#15

Re: Follow up question...

Dave Paine

A bag is less expensive for the manufacturer and can reflect in lower initial purchase price.

Depending on the tank/bag size it may take a good time before it needs to be replaced.

My Fein had a cloth filter. I replaced with a fluted membrane filter AND bag. The Cloth filter was a mess to cleanup. The Fein bags are not cheap, but they take a good load and are so easy to remove, discard with no mess.

Most shop vac brands can have bags replaced by fluted filters. May be after market. These work well. I did this for my Rigid. Filter still going strong.

Just be prepared for a messy cleanup. Brush off most of the dust into a garbage can. I use a hand brush. I then blow out the remaining dust with compressed air.

My filter is stated to be washable. The only issue is leaving this out for the many hours/day in order to dry before placing back into service. This is needed to avoid mold.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#16

JL

Re: Follow up question...

JL

The way to get the least amount of dust to the filter is to build or buy a separator. You can make one with a five gallon bucket or a many (30 gallon) drum. You can also buy one.

I prefer pleated filters. When one clogs up, I empty the vacuum and clean it. I switch to a clean filter and vacuum the old one. The best pleated filter is a HEPA filter - in terms of having clean air come out of the filter. For most tools except for sanders, HEPA is a bit of "overkill". The ordinary less expensive filters work well for most tools.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#17

I was thinking the same...

John in NM

Definitely sounds like a job for a separator, especially since it's for a bandsaw and the dust is fairly coarse. Get a good separator, and the filter will rarely need any attention. Not exactly low bulk, but I'd say it's worth it. No point to spending any money on a setup that won't work well enough to be worth setting up or needs frequent attention.

Those pleated filters that fit most vacs and you can buy at HD or a hardware store are supposed to be washable. I've washed them before, or rather rinsed them. It works, but the filter is only good for a few rinses. If you're doing no wet pickup, I'd suggest taking it outside and blowing compressed air through from inside the filter rather than rinsing.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#18

Re: Follow up question...

David Yoho

My Sears vac has a pleated filter. To clean it, I dump the canister where I store a scrap piece of wood I use to tap the build-up from the filter. When I want to go above and beyond, I simply use my compressor to blow out the finer stuff. I can get a ton of life from one single filter that way.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#19

"bag" question

Bill Tindall

I presumed the chips/dust went into the "disposable" bag like the house vacuum. Not so?.....the "bag" in the pictures of the shop-vac equipment is just the filter?. In other words the dust/chips are on the outside of said bag, not in it? I am totally ignorant of modern shop vacuums. I need to take a trip to some store and check them out.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#20

Re: "bag" question

Dave Paine

Whether the bag contains the dust etc. of prevents the dust from being blown out of the vac. depends on the design.

My old Shop vac used small bags on the exit of the container, so was to hold back the fine dust. Most of the large particles stayed in the bottom of the container.

My Fein vac, is like the home vacuums of old. The bag contains the dust/particles, etc. The vac also has a pleated filter, to contain the fine particles. Rarely gets overloaded, unless the paper bags rip, likely due to my not replacing in time.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#21

Re: Follow up question...

les winter

Hello Bill. Here is the ticket to eliminate filter bags and reduce filter cleaning.

http://www.cgallery.com/jpthien/cy.htm

hope that helps.

Les

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#22

Re: "bag" question

Gary Smyth

The filter protects the motor from the sucked in debris. The dust is supposed to stay in the tub. The filter also stops the fine particles that are sucked in from being blown out the exhaust. With sawdust you won't notice it so much, but try it with drywall dust and you might as well not vacuum at all. Finer dust requires a different filter and generally you will not reuse those as the particles cake and fill in the pores of the filter.

The filters that are wet dry usually have a rubberized top and bottom like drum heads and fit by being locked in with a cage with a protruding stud or some style of a locking bottom. Either way it hangs down into the tub and is held tightly to the cover. The filter is similar to an accordian folded oil filter but bigger and courser for larger particles. If there is a cloth filter is is generally for dry only. I find cloth/paper filters a pain in the rear. They clog just like the wet/dry style, but not as efficient and incredibly messy when trying to clean. Reuse of these is not a good use of your time.

If you visit a store to look take the top off and the filter ought to be attached to the underside. I think that you will see for yourself the advantages of the wet/dry accordian style filter.

Re: need small shop-vac suggestion

#23

Am I the only one to reuse the bags

Earl

Bill I have a shop vac with a paper bag. It keeps the dust away from the filter for the most part. I have changed bags up to 3 times without cleaning the filter. The bags are folded over and glued together on the ends. When mine are full I change bags then take the full one out in the woods and cut the fold off dump it out and take it back to the shop and fold it over and glue it back. I usually get to use it 3 times or more. The paper will get plugged up after awhile tho. Lotsa luck with your choice Earl