Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

I'm Missing Something Here

Posts

I'm Missing Something Here

#1

I'm Missing Something Here

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

In making Memsahib's AV cabinet [below] I decided to get some "really good" Canadian cabinet grade maple ply at $130 a sheet. I also got some Maple ply [1 side birch] $45/sheet from Lowe's [also made in Canada] to use as the case floor and partitions. I happened to be moving the remainder sections in the shop and it occurred to me that, other than the second maple face veneer, there didn't seem to be any difference. I measured the veneers and both were the same thickness. I had several small pieces of scrap, so I cut them to the precise same shape and weighed each; no difference at all.

Duh? So why am I paying $85/sheet (almost 300%) more for a 2nd maple face that will never be seen anyway? :\

Damn I hate when that happens. :(

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

#2

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

Neal in San Jose

There may be more to it than meets the eye, literally. Sometimes higher end plywood has more plys, and the plys below the veneer are plugged (defects repaired with those little football shaped plugs). Both of these result in the surface veneer being less likely to telegraph problems up from sub-surface layers and the plywood is more structurally sound and able to hold fasteners. Or, maybe you just got taken!

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

#3

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

Thomas S Stockton

Mark

The expensive part of plywood is usually the faces, the high quality cabinet ply you bought probably had two really nice faces that were either bookmatched or flitch matched while the stuff form lowes might be a whole piece face which is rotary cut or it is of a lesser quality. On a retail level for raw veneer it would cost between $1.50 to $2 a square foot for face grade veneer a lower grade would be a third to a half less. Rotary cut whole piece faces are even less.

Another reason might be where you are purchasing, the expensive ply was probably from a hardwood dealer and you probably paid close top full retail unless you buy a lot from them or have a full time shop, the hardwood dealer also buys in smaller quantities. Lowes on the other hand buys a lot of plywood and gets a better discount and also tries to keep their prices as low as possible so that adds to the difference.

In plywood grade is usually what drives the price not the core.

Tom

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

#4

I found a whopping difference

Bill Tindall

I bought some sheets of "bargain" plywood at HD. It warped into potato chip shaped sheets. Even after several days of drying I measured moisture content at 18%!

Instead of butting the joints in the plies they were overlapped and mashed more of less flat.

In this case the "beauty" was only skin deep.

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

Moses Yoder

Your maple ply that was good both sides was very expensive. Around here I could probably get it for around $90 per sheet. But here I am working with someone that supplies the cabinet industry, which is a whole different business from a hobby shop. Maybe you need to look for a different supplier. I would never buy plywood from Home Depot or Lowes to build real projects.

Re: I'm Missing Something Here

#6

Unfortunately

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Haven't found anyone like that anywhere near me. Of course, since I use so little in the way of ply, I wouldn't get the benefit of a commercial "buy" with my 1 or 2 sheet order.