We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have a couple ways of dealing with "Squeeze-out". Try them on some practice blanks and see what works for you. I've done it with Titebond II as well as Titebond original.
I wash the excess glue off with water. I scrub with a rag and a toothbrush. This works with reasonably non-porous woods. You have to do it as soon as you've finished gluing and clamping.
I wait till the glue dries to a somewhat flexible "bead" and chisel or razor it off. This works well with flat pieces and long joins like table tops or chair seats.
Interesting question. Here's my two cents worth...
Are you going to put a topcoat over the stain? If so, I would do that before glueup. Without a topcoat, wiping the glue off with water might take off some stain, too. The chisel method would be safer, too.
How about using blue painter's tape over the stain where squeezeout is likely?
I don't think you have to worry about the stain affecting the glue, but the glue could play heck with the stain.
Waterborne stain, just like oil based stain, should not be used on surfaces that will be glued. The binder--light varnish or acyrlic finish--will reduce the bonding power of the glue significantly. Water itself shouldn't have much if any impact on waterborne stain that has cured before it is used to wipe off excess glue. (Waterborne finish may cause waterborne stain to bleed into the top coat, not because of the water, but because of the ethylene glycol that can soften the stain binder.)
There are very few objects that should be stained in advance of gluing. About the only thing that comes to mind is floating panels where staining the edges prevents light bands when the panel shrinks. In this stain, and the first of the top coats is OK to do first. But I would never prestain the stiles and rails of a panel or legs to rails, etc. because no matter how well made and dry fitted there is almost always a small "adjustment" to make after they have been glued for real. If you have to do that and plane or sand away a part of the stained surface trying to make a matching patch in the stain is a really ugly job.
Gobs of squeezeout means too much glue. If the joints are tight, just a little glue is all that's needed. Any little squeezeout can be wipid away with a wet paper towel without interfering with later staining.
With a water-based stain, can i stain first and then glue up? Yes, but this approach is seldom necessary.
Will the stain affect the glue's (Tite-bond II) adhesion? Definitly
In either case I will use the "dark" version of the glue. Again not necessary.
The solution to your gluing/staining problem is to use an amount of glue that doesn't squeeze out of the joinery. Let us presume the apron of the table is joined to the legs with mortise and tenon joinery. The mortise should be deeper that the tenon so extra glue has some place to go. With a stick or brush coat the inside of the mortise with glue. With a brush lightly coat the tenon. Assemble. If a tiny droplet of glue should squeeze out let it dry to the rubbery stage and then flick it off with a chisel.
To achieve a bond both wood surfaces must be "wet" by the glue. One can slather enough glue on one surface to ensure the other surface gets wet during assembly, but this approach always results in excess glue squeezing out and going somewhere. Better is to just coat each surface with a thin layer of glue and then assemble.
Some questions: Why are you using Titebond II for this application? Unless you are going to use this table where it will get wet, there are disadvantages to using Titebond II.
Why are you using water based stain rather than an oil stain?
I have not used a water based stain yet so I can't speak for it. However, I've used a bit of Lockwood water based dyes and have had great success with a method I've used.
First, wherever you have joints where squeeze out could occur, it's a good idea to lay down some blue painter's tape to catch the glue. I usually apply the tape during dry fitting to get things lined up like they will be after gluing and clamping.
Depending on what I'm making, I will apply a coat of dye to parts before assembly. Whether before or after, the whole thing gets an in ital coat of dye. This coat, called a trace coat, does several things. It reveals any sanding scratches that may be present. It also reveals any glue that didn't get cleaned up. Since I've used this method mostly on figured wood like maple, the trace coat also is used to highlight the figure in the end. Once it is dry, I use 150-grit paper to sand the color from the surface and remove the scratches and glue residue. This sanding also cuts the raised grain so a separate sanding for that purpose isn't needed. Finally, I come back with my final dye color and allow it to dry. Then I use an oil based top coat.
This method might work with water based stain but like I said I have no direct experience with it so I don't know for sure. Might be worth testing out.
You can avoid the whole problem by using hide glue. You can clean it up right away or the next day or a week or month later. You can use a UV flashlight to see where any hide glue is remaining and wash it off.
Perfectly compatable with water base stains/dyes you can even add the dye to the glue to darken it or add zinc oxide for a lighter colored glue joint.
I agree that hide glue has lots of benefits. But what I don't understand is why folks feel a need for dark glue or to add color to glue. If the joint is right the glue could be florescent pink (as long as it didn't migrate) and you wouldn't see it. Done right there is no glue line visible.
I use liquid hide glue more today than yellow glue. One of its benefits is it doesn't show up under a finish like yellow glues. Since it's so easy to clean up, I don't have to worry as much about getting excessive squeeze-out. However, to that point, I find applying a little to both surfaces and letting it tack up a bit before clamping limits the squeeze-out issue for me.
Ideally one wants all the glue to squeeze out that can, which is to say all the "extra" glue not involved in making the joint. Any extra in there just weakens the joint. The glues are formulated to be of such viscosity that this extra can squeeze out.
Additionally, glue must wet each surface. If glue is applied to only one surface, allowed to dry some and then the joint assembled, there is the possibility that the high viscosity, partially dried, glue will not properly wet the mating surface. Of course wetting both surfaces eliminates this potential problem but there is still the issue of it being desirable to squeeze out any "extra" glue, shich reuires a low viscosity glue, as formulated.
Carefully applied, there should be no squeeze out in dovetail and M&T joints. For edge gluing a bit of squeeze out is not any problem. If squeeze out is a chronic issue then learning to effectively use less is a better solution.
I find that a brush is the best way to apply glue sparingly. Squirting it out of the glue bottle is not.
Actually, when I say "tack up" I mean that I don't instantly assemble the two parts but wait a few minutes. Hide glue gives me the open time I need and I do still get squeeze out to some degree. Just not as much as I used to. Probably because I learned I didn't need as much glue as I was using years ago. And I do use a brush to apply except when doing a rubbed joint.
I'm with Bill. If this works, then it's harming the strength and perhaps appearance of the joint. If this does reduce squeezeout you are leaving more glue in the joint than is optimal. Conversely, if the joint isn't harmed, then you get just as much squeezeout as before so why wait.
An experienced woodworker will know how much time a joint can stay open, so I had no worries that your joints were at risk. What I hoped to point out is that too much time can lead to problems. Someone inexperienced could interpret leaving a joint open for a bit to mean if a little time is good a little more could be better, or at least ok. Eventually one hits a cliff and the glue on the two surfaces doesn't coalesce to make a good joint.
The glue guru at Franklin defined two working times for adhesives. The "open time" is where the joint is exposed to air and drying is affected by humidity and temperature. This time is but a few minutes for any of the water based glues. There is a second working time where the assembled joint can be coaxed into position. This time depends on temperature and moisture content of the wood. Again this time is minutes, 10 or less.