Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Posts

Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#1

Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Stuart Johnson

What is the difference between regular poly and wipe on other than wipe on being twice as expensive? Is there an inexpensive something that can be added to regular to allow it to wipe on?

FWIW, I have been spraying lacquer but I guess the heat has kicked up high enough to start causing problems. I'm starting to get small bubbles. If I can figure out how to eliminate that problem I can go back to spraying. To get rid of the orange peel I have been spraying 50/50 Sherwin Williams and thinner using a cheap Rockler HVLP. All was going good and I was getting a nice glass smooth finish but the last couple of 95- 99 degree days have been a no go.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#2

sprying lacquer

del schisler

i been spraying lacquer for yrs. now in florida and it get's hot here to. I don't thin that much. I use M.L.CAMPBEL which is own by shermam william's. But they make their own lacquer and thinner. I only thing 10 percent most of the time. I use a 2mm nozzel and 30lbs or air. The air that you use ??? maybe to much or to much thinner will do that. A little more info. I use the sanding sealer and than 2 coat's and no more. Also i don't spray in the morning due to the moister. If i can see it on the grass i don't spray. If you do it will look cloudy but let it dry and than spray over it will disapear and than come out ok. i have done this . thanks del

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#3

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Jesse Cloud

The wipe on finishes are simply diluted versions of the brushing finish. For oil based poly, just add some thinner. Start with 75 percent regular finish and 25 percent thinner. If its not going on smoothing, drop down to 50 per cent. Of course, the more you thin it, the more coats it will take to build up.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Clint Searl

The bubbles are a result of the reducer boiling out from underneath, compounded by high ambient temperature and if you're spraying in the sun. The HVLP makes the finish hot to begin with, which makes it worse. Don't thin so much and spray when and where it's cool.

Clint

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#5

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Bill Tindall

At 99 degrees any sort of varnish is going to dry like crazy too.

You need to be thinning lacquer with a retarder, which is a higher boiling solvent mix, for example butyl acetate.

To answer your question......Flexner, the guru of finishing, says you can make wipe on by diluting regular varnish with linseed oil. However, the commercial products are likely much more complex formulations that that.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Clint Searl

Make your own wipe-on by diluting gloss poly from the can with mineral spirits for a slow cure or naptha for a faster cure. Nothing else is necessary.

Clint

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#7

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

FredD

Try either a Summer Lacquer thinner that flashes slower or retard with some Toluene, the idea being to allow more time for the Lacquer to flow out and set.

I have also noticed if any sun light were shinning on a fresh coat of Lacquer ,like though a Window or Skylight , you will get bubbles.

FredD

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Moses Yoder

When we spray conversion varnish, it dries from the top down. If the top thin layer dries too fast, the gases in the finish under that layer cause bubbles. Laquer is probably the same, so as has been mentioned, you need a retarder which will make the finish dry more slowly. I would talk to your finish supplier because they probably have an additive made just for that reason.

You can make a really nice wiping varnish by mixing 1/3 poly, 1/3 linseed oil, and 1/3 turpentine. I usually get a satisfactory finish with 3 coats of this if I apply the first coat thick.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#9

retarder

Bill Tindall

I may not have made clear that Sherwin Williams sells retarding solvent. Often just 10% will slow the evaporation rate significantly.

If you are spraying in direct sun....don't. Nothing will solve that problem.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#10

Re: Thanks Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Stuart Johnson

Many good answers. I like the glass like finish from lacquer so I'll stop in at Sherwin Williams and talk to them about a retarder. Just a small update, I went out early this morning and sprayed another coat using the 50/50 mix that was giving me good results. The coat went down much better with very few bubbles. I have a large shop so I open the roll up door and made sure the sun wasn't hitting.

I still don't know what is causing orange peel. I've tried straight lacquer, just a bit of thinner then through a Google search came up with the 50/50 mix that seems to be working when it is cooler. I have a whole bunch of cabinets to make so I would like to get this down pat before I start the next batch. What I've found so far (when it is working well) is 1 coat of sanding sealer, sand, then two coats of lacquer. I haven't tried adjusting the flow rate yet and with my sprayer it is on or off with no air pressure adjustment.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#11

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Steve Schoene

Whoa. I'm quite sure Flexner never said mixing linseed oil with varnish would make a wiping varnish, because it doesn't. It makes Danish Oil or an oil/varnish mix. When you mix the oil with varnish the result is quite soft, in some cases even gummy, if you were to leave it to build a film on the surface. That's why the directions for using an oil/'varnish mix call for application, letting it penetrate for a short time, like 15minutes, and then wiping off any that remains on the surface. The final result is an in-the-wood finish, with no film.

You can make your own wiping varnish by thinning "full strength" varnishes. As was mentioned, the proportions are not at all critical. Thinning by 25% may work for youi, many formulae call for a 50-50 mix, and commercial wiping varnishes may add even more --because thinner is cheaper than varnish. In any even this is applied in then even coats, more like using a damp cloth to clean a table, not imitating a brush. These coats are NOT wiped off, they can can be allowed to build a film. That film will be essentially the same as if you had brushed on the varnish. It will take 3 or 4 coats on to built the same dry film as one brushed on coat.

There may be some small differences between just thinned varnish and wiping varnish sold commercially, basically in the additives that impart certain qualities, like flowing out, etc. But, these differences would be minor and not a reason to really prefer a commercial wipe on.

You can apply wipe on varnish with up to about 3 coats in a day--applying each after the preceeding coat has just lost it's tackiness. Done this way, the coats tend to crosslink together enough to avoid witness lines when rubbing out. After a day's "set" of coats has been applied you need to let it dry overnight as if you had brushed them on. And then, as with a brushed on coat, you would want to scuff sand with 320 before applying the next "set". (You can't sand between coats within a set--it will be much to soft for that.)

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#12

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Howard Acheson

>>>> You can make a really nice wiping varnish by mixing 1/3 poly, 1/3 linseed oil, and 1/3 turpentine.

No, that formula makes an oil/varnish mixture which is similar to Watco Danish Oil or Minwax Tung Oil Finish.

A thinned wiping varnish is a 50/50 mixture of varnish and mineral spirits.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#13

Re: Thanks Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

FredD

Stuart, I don't know what kind of spray equipment your using, but the Orange peel problem would be the same regardless.

Generally caused by not getting a full coat with the first pass of the spray gun on each coat which inhibits flow out.

Holding the gun to far away will do it also. Lacquer drying to fast is a instigator,I use a airless rig with extremely high pressure and that seems to avoid the orange peel for the most part, unless I day dream while spraying ;-))

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#14

Re: Thanks Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

This is my HVLP system. It seems to work well but is is sure hard to get the cups started so they screw on properly.


Rockler HVLP Sprayer

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#15

I Agree

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Stuart,

I have used both the "premixed" poly and my own 50/50 naptha and oil based poly. Frankly, I really do not see any appreciuable difference between the two except price. My own methods require a full day between coats of the 50/50 mix. I apply two coats and scuff with 320 grit. Then do two more. I may have to use more 320, which I wrap around a felt bloch, lubricated with eihter naptha and lemon oil, or (believe it or not) naptha and WD-40. Clean off with nore naptha, and then apply another thin coat of the 50/50 mixture. I use 4/0 steel wool and rub it all out, follow with paste wax. It does take time, but the finish is softly lustrous, but tough enough for a rambunctious bunch of kids and grandkids. I will add that I nearly always apply a coat of Zinnser dewaxed shellac, Sealcoat, before I apply any oil based poly. I like the look.

George

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#16

HVLP

Bill Tindall

I tried HVLP (Apollo) and went back to conventional spray. While it was certainly possible to get as good a finish as with conventional it was more critical to get the adjustments and distance from the target optimum. I found it more orange peel prone than conventional.

I did like the lessened blow back with HVLP when spraying in a corner for example but these advantages were not compelling compared to the extra care I needed to use to get a good finish.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#17

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I use Minwax poly - it's fairly cheap and available everywhere. I have read (can't remember the magazine - probably FWW or Woodworking Journal) a review on all the oil based poly's and Minwax came out on top of all the expensive one's in finish ease, durability, color etc. I often thin with Naptha - but have used acetone and mineral spirits as well - dependent on how fast I want it to dry in the temperature, humidity etc. I have thinned up to 50% for spraying and wiping without any problem - usually re-coating in about 24 hours. As far as spraying lacquer in higher temperatures. I use Behlen Qualalacq lacquer and add quite a bit of retarder during hot and or humid days. I have sprayed in direct sunshine at 90 deg and it worked ok with additional thinner and retarder.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#18

Ellis Walentine

Excellent post, Steve

Ellis Walentine

I think you've summed it up nicely.

I've been using and swearing by Waterlox for over 40 years, since it came in the old orange and white can and cost $16 per gallon, but I refuse to pay $38 per quart or whatever paint stores are charging nowadays. They've also changed to their new VOC-compliant formulation, which has changed the handling and drying characterisitics. I've found one good substitute for Waterlox, General Finishes Seal-A-Cell, which has similar characteristics but with a much lower tendency to turn to jelly in the can. It is not as amber as Waterlox, but that's fine; if I need a toner, I add one.

Neither Waterlox nor Seal-A-Cell have great abrasion or UV resistance, so if the job calls for high-wear or sun exposure, I use an appropriate polyurethane or spar varnish, applied normally with a brush to hasten the build. If I don't need much build, or I want the control and faster tack-free time of a wiping finish, I will add up to 25% thinner to the stock varnish. All these mixtures handle differently, so you might need some practice to get the right amount down evenly before it starts grabbing your rag. Unlike "Danish oil" finishes, which are just mixtures of varnish, oil and thinners, a wiping varnish doesn't have to be wiped off, so it's more economical.

Ellis

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#19

Steve Strickland

Poly Vs. Velvit Oil

Steve Strickland

Velvit Oil gives a similar result to poly but I think it's superior for fine hardwoods. Just wipe it on and let it dry.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#20

Re: Poly Vs. Velvit Oil

Steve Schoene

The directions for using Velvit Oil call for wiping off excess after letting it penetrate for a short time. That makes me think that it is an oil/varnish mix (Danish oil) not a varnish. The company's web pages provide no link to MSDS or other technical data to tell what the product is.

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#21

Re: Waterlox

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Ellis,

Waterlox has two versions of Sealer Finish, the Original, which has not been changed for VOC and a new VOC compliant version.

The cost for the original is $24.50/qt. One of my local paint stores in Flemington, NJ carries it.

While not $16, it's still pretty far away from $38.

Bob in NJ

Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On

#22

Steve Strickland

Re: Poly Vs. Velvit Oil

Steve Strickland

It's a penetrating, polymerizing tung oil with soy particles. The oil penetrates carrying the soy particles in to block the pores, then polymerizes. It's not a surface finish. It's dry to handle quickly but there is some solvent outgassing that occurs for about 3 days if you plan on shrink wrapping your product.

The finished wood feels natural but is water resistant. It has the highly desirable quality (for puzzle makers) of blocking moisture migration through the surface.

I learned about Velvit Oil from Barbara Gill a long time ago. I never used poly again once I tried this stuff.