Re: Regular Poly Vs. Wipe On
Steve Schoene
Whoa. I'm quite sure Flexner never said mixing linseed oil with varnish would make a wiping varnish, because it doesn't. It makes Danish Oil or an oil/varnish mix. When you mix the oil with varnish the result is quite soft, in some cases even gummy, if you were to leave it to build a film on the surface. That's why the directions for using an oil/'varnish mix call for application, letting it penetrate for a short time, like 15minutes, and then wiping off any that remains on the surface. The final result is an in-the-wood finish, with no film.
You can make your own wiping varnish by thinning "full strength" varnishes. As was mentioned, the proportions are not at all critical. Thinning by 25% may work for youi, many formulae call for a 50-50 mix, and commercial wiping varnishes may add even more --because thinner is cheaper than varnish. In any even this is applied in then even coats, more like using a damp cloth to clean a table, not imitating a brush. These coats are NOT wiped off, they can can be allowed to build a film. That film will be essentially the same as if you had brushed on the varnish. It will take 3 or 4 coats on to built the same dry film as one brushed on coat.
There may be some small differences between just thinned varnish and wiping varnish sold commercially, basically in the additives that impart certain qualities, like flowing out, etc. But, these differences would be minor and not a reason to really prefer a commercial wipe on.
You can apply wipe on varnish with up to about 3 coats in a day--applying each after the preceeding coat has just lost it's tackiness. Done this way, the coats tend to crosslink together enough to avoid witness lines when rubbing out. After a day's "set" of coats has been applied you need to let it dry overnight as if you had brushed them on. And then, as with a brushed on coat, you would want to scuff sand with 320 before applying the next "set". (You can't sand between coats within a set--it will be much to soft for that.)