Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

Posts

OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#1

OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

OT? You be the judge.

Sweetie would like for me to cook some cedar-planked salmon on the grill. What species of cedar is needed? Will a cedar shingle work?

And what species of cedar is used for cedar shingles anyway?

Al

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#2

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

Kneale Brownson

My buddy who does this regularly uses a smooth-surfaced cedar board. I'd guess white cedar. Definitely not the aeromatic red cedar.

He soaks the wood overnight in water. Puts the skin side down.

I experienced his first attempt sans the water soaking. Burned board.

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#3

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

mdclor

We are using western red cedar. Soak it for at least 2 hours (weigh it down so that it isn't floating) before placing it over a medium hot grill.

HTH,

Merle

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#4

That's what my now-ex did

Neal in San Jose

Didn't read the part in the receipe that said to soak the board. Burned everything up! It was pretty funny, except that she paid about $100 per board foot at the specialty food store for the stupid board. IIRC it looked like white cedar.

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#5

What is the benefit?  A salmon lover wants to know

Bill Tindall

I have never met a salmon I didn't like and would like to meet this one. But I am curious, what is the purpose of the wood? How is the result different than just plain grilled salmon? I am at a loss to see what the wood does other than keeping the otherwise worthless skin from blackening(or at least it blackens when I grill it.

I would presume the origin of this approach would be the challenge of cooking a salmon beside the stream. Hence, build fire, split a slab from some wet drift wood and grill away??

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#6

Use white cedar soaked in water

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#7

JL

Re: What is the benefit?  A salmon lover wants to

JL

IMO, it adds flavor. It also sort of "steams" the fish. I've done it over charcoal and I've done it over open flame. You can get the fish nice and tender.

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#8

Re: What is the benefit?  A salmon lover wants to

Bill Howatt

I have done it with red cedar a couple of times but even though I like smoked food it really doesn't appeal to me all that much. Like you said, salmon is great by itself. The cedar smoke isn't ideal, IMO, and if the board dries out and starts to burn which it tends to near the end of cooking the smoke can be harsh.

Now cajun blackened salmon is a different matter!

Bill

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#9

Many woods will work.....

Dick Coers

I use western red cedar, white cedar is also great. Aromatic cedar has too much oil and will actually produce a foul taste. The other comments are correct about the steaming and then a subtle smoke at the end when the wood drys out. Works equally well on charcoal or gas grills. I've also used apple, crab apple, and maple with salmon and occasionally, orange roughy. I love it!

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#10

Red Alder

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

I've used a Western Red Cedar fence board before, but didn't think it was that great. A Red Alder board on the other hand is wonderful. My wife, Lisa, is the dining room manager of Seafood place and Alder planked salmon is one of thier big sellers. Fancy Alder planks seem to be hot items on the craft fair circut recently as well, although paying 5 times the amount of just going to the lumber yard baffels me. Use Wild King (Chinook) or Coho if you can get it, Sockeye as a last resort, any other salmon, eat the board.

glc

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#11

"produce a foul taste"

DizD

Does that mean smoked salmon tastes like chicken?

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#13

dream on......

Bill Tindall

Kings never get beyond sight of the ocean before they are eaten, definitely not as far ashore as TN.

I wondered what all the fuss was about King Salmon. And then a fisherman's wife in Port Alberni(fellow sheep raiser) had us for dinner and cooked a fresh King her husband dropped off before heading back to sea. (This lady has a two basket commercial fryer in her kitchen!) Oh, my. Thought I had died and gone to sea food heaven. I can't imagine that a piece of alder could have improved it.

One would suppose that any "white" wood would do- maple, birch, the fruit woods, etc.

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#14

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

Lynn Baker from chilly Glacier WA

Al,

I couldn't resist giving some tried and true advice. "Never eat uncanned Salmon of any species more than 50 miles away from salt water". :^)

The northwest coast indian method of cooking the salmon on a red alder plank next to an open fire is about as good as it gets.

Lynn

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#15

The early bird gets the pun

DizD

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#16

Re: OK, so I am a Salmon snob...

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

I admit it. The restaurant company my wife works for has it's own wholesale fish buying division and they fly fish in 3 times a week so it is pretty darn fresh. I can't say Alder improves the taste of King but it is different. There is just something about Alder and Salmon no other wood is quite the same. Port Alberni is a very interesting town / area.

glc

Re: OT?? Grilled cedar-planked salmon

#17

Clint Searl

When is an ex not a now?

Clint Searl

Except when she's a will be.

Clint