Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - GFI replacement issues

Posts

OT - GFI replacement issues

#1

OT - GFI replacement issues

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

Hello all,

I need some electrical help from my WC family. Due to my error both GFI oulets in my pool circuit shorted out and needed replacing. Unknowingly, the Little Giant 505300 pump I was using had some frayed, exposed wires at the point of entry on the pump. After several attempts at at resetting the GFI outlets, nothing would work. It was at this point I realized the pump was defective. With the circuit turned off, both (exterior) outlets were rewired exactly as before. On these receptacles there's a samll green indicator light. One indicator light works and one doesn't. Both receptacles work fine and trip on "test" and also with my GFI plug in tester. I suspect two things could be wrong. One: Bad receptacle. Two: Possible issues with the sequence in wiring. I add the second reason because in the receptacle box there are directions on wiring before the the circuit is turned or something. I'm not clear on what they mean. I've read it 4 times now and it doesn't make sense. So..........any thoughts on why the light isn't going on? Should I just take it back to Home Cheapo and try another one? From my description, is my circuit safe even though there is no indicator light?

Thanks everyone for looking.

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#2

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

John McGaw

Simple test that doesn't involve driving anywhere. Since both receptacles 'work', why not just swap them out. If the 'problem' moves then the light-less receptacle is defective and needs to go back to the seller. If the 'problem' doesn't move then you have something really weird going on and need to drop back and punt.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#3

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I agree that switching the outlets to see if the problem moves is the best approach.

There are 2006 code and 2009 code (I think those are the years) GFCI outlets. They work the same, but the indicator lights work differently. If you still have the boxes, you might see if you have two different code year outlets.

And, of course, double and triple check your wiring sequence. All it takes is accidentally putting the hot to the neutral terminal and vice versa.

If you don't have a plug-in GFCI tester, consider getting one. Not only will it tell you immediately if you've wired an outlet (GFCI or not) correctly, but it tests GFCI outlets directly, by replicating what would happen in real life, and is therefore a more accurate test of the function of a GFCI outlet. Just a few dollars, and worth it.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#4

Had the same problem

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I had the same problem when installing a GFI in my basement. The problem was there were four wires in the box and I mistakenly attached the hot wire to the out side of the outlet. Once I switched the hot and corresponding neutral to the in terminals on the GFI it worked fine.

The green light should be on all the time telling you the outlet is live. It should go off when tripped.

Lee

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#5

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Good idea John. Sometimes the simple solution is always the farthest from my way of thinking. I'll give it a whirl and see what happens. Lord knows I don't want to make a trip back to the "Orange Box".

Thanks,

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#6

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Hey Bill, :)

You're the second person that has suggested swapping receptacles. The "test" on the receptacle did work as well as my plug in GFCI plug in tester. That may have been lost in my jibber jabber. I'll try the easy first. Then if absolutely necessary, I'll go back to HD.

Thanks,

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#7

Re: Had the same problem

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Lee,

Even though the outlet works and "tests" okay, having that little indicator light off is bugging the crap out of me. I agree it should be lit. This particular receptacle only has two wires, actually three. Black, white, and the neutral. I put the wires exactly where they were on the old receptacle too so I'm stumped.

Thanks,

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#8

Re: Had the same problem

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

You may only have two wires, but there are four terminals on the GFI. Make sure you are on the right ones. It may also indicate that you have a bad neutral.

If all else fails, swap this one for the one that seems to be working and see if the problem migrates with it.

lee

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#9

Slight terminology correction

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What you're calling the "neutral" is probably the ground (sometimes called "equipment ground") wire. It's commonly bare or, if insulated, green.

The neutral carries electricity - it's the other leg that completes the circuit, besides the black wire (I considered an explanation of why it's called the neutral, but remembered that my wife and sons consider me too wordy...).

If the ground wire is carrying electricity, you're in trouble; it's there for when the electrons in the circuit escape and are running through the equipment plugged in or other scary places. It should be fastened to the ground lug on the body of the outlet (usually a green screw).

Black wire goes to the gold "line" screw; white to the chrome-colored "line" screw. If this is how they're wired up, then you've got a problem either in the outlet or in the wiring.

If you've got a multimeter, take the wires off the outlet, arrange them so they're not touching anything, and, with the power on, test for voltage between the black wire and the white one. You should show 110 volts (just for ducks, have the tester set to a voltage range above 220 volts, in case that's how the circuit's configured). Now test between the black and ground; again, 110 volts. Testing between neutral and ground should NOT show voltage. If you get any reading other than these, it's electrician time, because there's a problem in your electrical panel (depending on symptoms, it could be a number of things).

Disclaimer: all the above assumes your jurisdiction uses the commonly accepted practices for hooking up residential electricity.

That little green light, by the way, can be off and the GFCI still working because it's kind of like the "check engine" light on your car; it tells you've got a problem, but doesn't tell you what it is.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#10

C'mon, Bill

Henry Higginbotham

Unlike many on this forum, you actually know about electricity. So you also know that the meter shouldn't be reading 110 volts, but rather more like 120 volts. Is there anywhere in the U.S. where 110V is the standard? Long ago it was, and most of Asia uses 110/220, I believe. But not here, unless there's an undue strain on the local electrical grid. And wouldn't it actually matter when you're figuring power (watts) available through a particular size of wire? Come on in to the 21st century. ;)


Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#11

I sit corrected

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'll blame my age - back when I learned about this stuff, that was the standard voltage.

That was when I was an adult. When I was a kid, of course, electricity was something you got off a kite string during thunderstorms.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#12

Good point...

John in NM

I hadn't thought of that, but there are the two "downstream" terminals. Isn't there some wrinkle if you put another GFCI downstream instead of a conventional outlet (which is what I always do). I have a couple around, I may have to go read the little yellow label that normally cover those terminals.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#13

Re: Good point...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you have two GFCIs on the same circuit, and test one of them, you can trip the other one at the same time, which can get very confusing.

I have two on our hot tub; the electricity runs just fine. One came already installed in the hot tub, but it's in the mechanical space under the tub, hard to reach for testing purposes. I put another in the hot tub circuit, where I can reach it for testing, but I also put a switch in the circuit so I can isolate the circuit GFCI from the hot tub momentarily while I test it. That switch has been very helpful in general, and is considered a good extra safety measure, in case the GFCI fails and there's a leak to ground.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#14

I have seen it as high as 135 here

Phil Joines

The higher the voltage the lower the amps for the same load. Increasing the voltage lets the power company carry a larger load without increasing the cable size.Of course when it gets up to 135 it will decrease the life of things like light bulbs and some electronic devices especially the cheap ones.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#15

Re: I have seen it as high as 135 here

Henry Higginbotham

I doubt the power company is doing it on purpose. Transformers supplying 120-volt service are so close to the serviced building that they wouldn't save much of anything on wiring. More likely, your pole may be due for a new transformer. Ask the power company about it--they're probably unaware.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A few rambling comments.....

Jesper, Denmark

The neutral (white in the US in modern installations) should read no voltage if the circuit is not used. If that circuit is in use, there will be some voltage on the neutral, equal to the volatge drop between the measuring point aqnd where the neutral is grounded - either at the service entrance or at the transformer.

In recent installations, the ground is green and yellow. This is a Worldwide standard and has been so for 20+ years, maybe longer.

The GFI works by comparing the current running throgh the hot and the neutral - or in three phase applictions, all three phases. If there is no leak to ground, the result in this comparison is zero, and all is well. The standard limit is a trip point of 30 mA within 0.3 seconds. This is because the human heart can handle about 50 mA.

Local codes here require GFI on the whole house, located at the service entrance panel. This seems to me to be the better idea - I think we have all felt electric leaks in lamps etc. at some point. The only draw-back is that the older GFI relays were sensitive to lightning induced currents. Not nice to come back from vacation and find that your freezer has been out for a week. The modern GPFI's are not so sensitive to that.

110, 115 or 120 Volt is all the same, as far as terminology goes. Variations caused be the distance to the transformer and how much the circuit is used are common. Usually the power company arranges it so that there is at least 110 Volt at the furthest point from the transformer. The local single phase voltage standard here is 220 Volt. My actual supply is 230 Volt most of the time. All three phases are brought into the panel.

Since a 1999 rare hurricane caused extensive damage to the above ground power suply, all electric power below 10 kV has gradually been brought underground. No more ugly supply masts locally. This change is almost complete, and as they were digging anyway, the power companies laid pipe for delivering fibre optic cables to each house at the same time. This has not been a real success, as the ADSL with copper the last mile or so has improved to the point of most places being able to get 20 mBit/sec.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#17

Re: Slight terminology correction - pun?

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

That little green light, by the way, can be off and the GFCI still working because it's kind of like the "check engine" light on your car; it tells you've got a problem, but doesn't tell you what it is.

Bill, your statement is exactly why I want it fixed. I also want to know that I don't have a problem elsewhere. The package directions say it should be lit. I checked my wiring and EVERYTHING is done correctly. I suspect I have a faulty receptacle that was purchased from HD. Consequently, this particular package had the taped seal broken. Someone may have returned it and it could have been restocked.

Tonight I switch receptacles and if all else fails, I have a new one in a sealed package ready to go. Stay tuned.....

Thanks Bill.

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#18

My question is....

Barry Irby

Why are there two GFI"s? I don't know of any reason you would have two in the same circuit. Which ever one is first in the circuit can protect the rest of the circuit. Adding an additional one would not provide any additional protection. Something plugged into the second one would trip whichever one was the most sensitive, not necessarily the second one.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#19

Re: Slight terminology correction - pun?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...this particular package had the taped seal broken. Someone may have returned it and it could have been restocked."

Yep - sure sounds likely, and support for the possibility that it's defective. I never buy anything on which the seal's been broken anymore, unless it's a simple object on which any problems will be immediately apparent while it's still in the package.

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#20

Problem solved !!

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

Bad receptacle !! Installed new (sealed) one from HD, works perfectly. Took the old one back and ripped someone a new one for stocking a defective ELECTRICAL product. Nuff said.

Thanks all !!! :D

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#21

Re: My question is....

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

I agree, weird! I didn't wire it, had an electrician do because of Twp. code reasons. It works so I'm leaving it. I agree Barry, it's reduntant and possibly a hazard but it meets our local code.

Ray

Re: OT - GFI replacement issues

#22

Re: Problem solved !!

Phil Joines

Bought a light fixture from HD that didn't work. When I exchanged it it was obvious from the new package that the first one had been returned, resealed and restocked. I thought it was unlawful to sell returned items as new.

They didn't like it when I unboxed the new one at the customer service desk and tested it while explaining loudly why I was doing it.