Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Leed Cert ?? detached garage

Posts

Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#1

Leed Cert ?? detached garage

Frank on Chestnut Hill

While reading about ways to increase your leed points, in fact it was called "cheating".

I was reading that one area to get a few more points was to not build a garage attached to the house. Anyone familiar with the benefit from avoiding the good old attached garage?

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#2

Just speculating here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I imagine the LEED energy ratings include the entire house. Garages are rarely energy-efficient, as anyone who's done a car repair in January can attest. I imagine they'd bring down the average rating of the house.

But, as I say, just speculatin'. Perhaps one of our building inspector folk or contractors or someone else familiar with the rules can come along and correct me.

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#3

Re: Just speculating here

Thomas S Stockton

probably has something to do with encouraging public transportation, no attached garage no car. You might also look into getting points from installing a simple bike rack or hybrid parking only sign, helps in commercial applications for leed points.

I don't think it is cheating at all, they set the rules and you follow them to get the max amount of points. I totally agree with what LEED stands for and what they are doing but they are just another bureaucracy that like things their way and are in love with their paperwork. I feel this leads to a loss of creativity and innovative thinking.

Tom

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

Moses Yoder

What you do is write a list of reasons why they would do that, just brainstorming. Then you pick the one that sounds the dumbest and that will be the reason why it is set up like that. For instance, Bill's mention of the whole house efficiency rating. If you attached the garage to the house, the house would actually be more efficient, as that side would not lose heat or cold air as fast. On the other hand, now they make you include the garage in the efficiency rating of the house. So that reason is by far the dumbest one I can come up with, so it is probably the reason the rules are set up that way.

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#5

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

Peter Carlsen

LEED points gained would have to do with indoor air quality. Separating the garage obviously create a barrier for exhaust fumes entering the house. This is one of the problems of an attached garage. An old regulation for getting a loan from Fanny & Freddie was to lower the garage so many inches from the inside floor. Such a regulation does not exist in the building codes of today.

LEED has little to do with energy savings. It's main reason for being is to promote recycled products and steer manufacturers to make "green products." In that respect it has been highly successful. It is for the owners, an expensive option for bragging rights.

Peter

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#6

My 1st thought was an air lock, a positive!

Frank on Chestnut  Hill

Re: Leed Cert ?? detached garage

#7

Steve Strickland

woodworking safety

Steve Strickland

Way back somewhere in the forums is the report of an engineer whose entire family suffered dust problems even though he was using a dust collector and HEPA filters. Yep, it was an attached garage. Commercial dust collectors and filters don't get the micro stuff that lodges in the lungs.

Excellent post if someone can find it. Go detached, it's much safer.