Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Well, folks, sometimes the Ides sneaks by on me, and this month is one of those times. This month, I would like to address the issue of how you decide which tools and supplies to buy:

What influences your buying decisions of woodworking tools and associated paraphrenalia? Do you get your information mostly from magazines, woodworking shows, retail store demonstration, on-line reviews, discussion sites, friends, clubs, other sources?

As usual, we will edit your replies and forward them to our friends at Woodworker West magazine to be published in our next column, in the July/August issue.

Thanks for participating!

Ellie Walentine, Host


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#2

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Dale Penkala

Hello Ellis

Once I decide I'm going to get something I will do a lot of online research & post questions here & ask 1 or 2 of my friends that are into woodworking. Once I look at all the info I then make my decision.

There are the main home improvment stores here in the tri-city area here (Home Depot, Menards, Lowes etc...) but they don't handle the bigger brand names. There is Woodcraft in Saginaw but I go there to look at something specific unless I absolutly need it right a way for a project. For me they are just to expensive even when they have there so called specials. Every once and a while I'll find something at a good price and buy it just to help keep them around but that is far & few between purchases.

Hope this helps!

Dale

Mid-Michigan

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#3

JL

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

JL

What influences your buying decisions of woodworking tools and associated paraphernalia? Do you get your information mostly from magazines, woodworking shows, retail store demonstration, on-line reviews, discussion sites, friends, clubs, other sources?

Lee Valley :b .

Seriously though - on-line research (of which the Lee Valley site happens to be a source) - would be first. WoodCentral is one of the better places to do the research - as somebody has tried about every tool here.

Friends would be second. We gather together every once in a while to talk and shoot the breeze.

Magazines would be third. As far as retail store demos - there ain't any retail stores near here. Once in a great while (every couple of years), I go to a show.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#4

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't buy tools all that much anymore :( . However, when I need a tool I look at catalogs and print magazines to find out what's available. I rely almost exclusively on woodworking forums for advice and recommendations. With virtually no one in my area with my interest in woodworking, online advice from those with actual experience is all I have to guide me.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#5

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Dave Paine

My influences are my perceptions of which tool will satisfy a given need. I sometimes purchase a tool which looks to meet a future need, and sometimes, perhaps most, will meet a present need.

I do searches in web sites, sometimes just a single site, e.g., if a site has a tool and explains the features which allows me to feel it is a tool I will use. This does happen a lot at Lee Valley. My preference is showing .....

I recently wanted to purchase some turning tools. Lots of sites, lots of reviews. Very difficult to decide on the initial purchase.

After my use of this initial purchase, I now feel I need some additional tools.

Nothing like actual usage to show what works well and what may be desired for the future.

In some cases, "capability" is a deciding factor.

I had a Sears "hybrid" 1 3/4 HP table saw. It worked well for most uses, except thick stock such as 8 quarter maple. The motor was just under powered.

I replaced this with the latest Unisaw. A 3 HP motor made the difference. I wanted the latest for the features such as riving knife. I really like having a riving knife. I would not want to purchase a table saw without this feature now that I have seen how useful this can be. The older saw I had to use a splitter mounted in the insert. This worked, but not as well as the riving knife.

So sometimes features push my desire to purchase. Sometimes reviews. Sometimes I admit to a basic "I want that" desire.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#6

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Bill Tindall

I get information from every source you listed. But a recommendation from a trusted colleague carries the most weight in a purchasing decision. In that regard the people on WC have become one of my most trusted sources of information.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#7

PS

Bill Tindall

A trusted supplier also influences a buying decision. For example, if Lee Valley recommends something I trust the recommendation. I bought their spoke shave set on such a recommendation and was not disappointed.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#8

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Gary Smyth

I wonder how many Marketing Directors will lose their jobs over this collective reply. This response could be worth a lot of money. I�m only half kidding. My decision for tool addition these days rests largely on real need, actual users, magazine articles/reviews, and live conversational demonstrations. I find most forums too short form, and woodworking shows too time constrained to assess true value. I consider myself very selective. I want a tool to prove of value in use and result to what I do before I decide if it needs to be in my inventory. I have from early on bought the best tools I could find at sales or afford, so I very rarely have to �trade up�. But, new, more convenient tools do come along like biscuit joiners, large capacity, variable speed, heavy duty routers, mitre saws, and cordless. I also find that the better I get at woodworking the fewer tools I need, want, and use.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#9

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

What influences your buying decisions of woodworking tools and associated paraphernalia?

Most of the Equipment in my shop (built just prior to my retirement) was purchased just prior too/or right after my retirement as a upgrade from mostly lightweight hobbyist tools - many of which were Crapsman. I wanted to set up a shop that would meet all of my needs/wants and to be capable of lasting and being useful to my son after I no longer could use them. I always try to purchase North American made tools when possible. I also try to purchase the highest quality equipment I can find and afford. Now that my shop equipment is fairly complete I purchase additional tooling / equipment when I believe it will make the projects I am working on easier or improve the quality.

Do you get your information mostly from magazines, woodworking shows, retail store demonstration, on-line reviews, discussion sites, friends, clubs, other sources?

I used magazines for some information, although I am skeptical regarding their reviews. Tool shows provided me with some information and close inspection of the major equipment. By far the most influential information came from this web site. Although most people are obviously influenced to recommend the equipment they own, the people here are by far the most honest about the faults they do fine. In my area there are no close Woodworking stores or clubs. (50 mile to Rockler and Woodworkers Supply in Indianapolis) so I do not use this resource to any extent. Although there are a few woodworkers in my city, I do not know any that I could use for information. The ones I have met (at estate auctions etc.) either did not have the type of equipment I wanted or did not do the same type of woodworking.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#10

Steve Strickland

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Steve Strickland

Talk to the folks that use it to make a living, not the folks that sell it to make a living.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY *** *LINK*

#11

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MAY ***

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

In today's economic climate....budget, budget, budget. If I can afford it, I buy it. If I can't buy the GOOD tool I want but can afford the the cheaper one that I know will only last a short while, I wait until I can afford the better tool. I fix older tools, especially power tools. It's usually a bit cheaper and I can keep the tools that have some sentimental value as well. I have a Makita 609D that was going. So I fixed the bad and kept her running.

My two cents worth,

Ray