Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Looking for Decking Recommendations

Posts

Looking for Decking Recommendations

#1

Bart Goldberg

Looking for Decking Recommendations

Bart Goldberg

I'm in the planning stages of replacing my 18 year old CCA lumber deck. I am still trying to decide between hardwood and wood alternative decking materials. I know that there have been lots of issues with some of the composites in past years, but the latest generation of coated decking materials and PVC products look promising. Has anyone here had any recent experiences with these products (Correctdeck CX, Azek Procell, Trex Transcends, Fiberon Horizon, etc.).

Thanks

Bart

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#2

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

Dave Paine

I replaced a section of deck with ChoiceDek, from Lowes. Cedar shavings and resin.

This section is SW exposure, so gets a lot of sun. The colour is fading as expected.

I used the special screws with two sets of threads to pull in the 'mushroom' at the top, which occurs even though I pre-drilled.

I also made some lamp posts out of the stuff.

So far, holding up well. Not sure how long, at least 3 years.

I also made a cover for a septic well out of Trex. This stuff has warped a great deal. Pulled out the initial screws.

The ChoiceDek can be laid across normal 16in span. Others, e.g., Trex requires 12in span.

So if the framing is not being replaced, give consideration to the span requirements.

The ChoiceDek was easy to cut, drill and install. I would consider this again. I have to say it is boring to look at, but I do like the zero maintenance. :)

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#3

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

DizD

Do a search for thermally modified wood decking. I haven't used the products, but from what I know of the technology it would be worth checking out.

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

Clint Searl

I also used Lowes ChoiceDek on my floating dock about four years ago, using the special screws. The screws drove in flush with no mushrooming, and the material has been completely stable with hardly any fading. I'd use it again.

Clint


Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#5

I did Ipe *LINK*

John M in Mid Mich

I have an extensive, multi-level, complicated deck that I did in Ipe (also called "Brazilian Walnut" I believe). This wood is hard and heavy and eats bits and blades for snacks. It is holding up extremely well after ca. 6 years. I have not treated or painted it at all. It is now silver gray. Not overly attractive, but way better than the old stained/painted treated pine that it replaced. When you see the marketing pics for this wood, it is the fresh and/or oiled appearance, not the untouched look that I have. When I did the costing calcs, Ipe was only slightly more expensive per board foot than Trex brand composite, and given the recommended span comparison (12-16" for Trex, 24"+ for Ipe) it turned out to be cheaper, especially since I was replacing the decking on existing structures that had been designed for 2 by 6 pine decking. This whole cost analysis would need to be updated now, as I believe that Ipe has gone way up in price. I would currently be looking at the new "thermally modified" southern yellow pine products like "PerfikDek" and "Stay-Tru" from a company called EcoVantage (I have no connection, just sayin'...). Good luck


Thermallly modified SYP

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#6

Re: Ipe as well...some regrets

Jason Falejczyk - Frankfort, IL

I chose to go the Ipe route as well, and agree with everything John said. There's a link below to a WC article about it.

Rather than let it weather, I kept it maintained and sure am paying for it. If you want that deep red finish, you will need to oil it EVERY year. I let mine go last year, and am currently in the process of restoring it. I have about two weekends in with just prep work, and due to the rain this Spring, have been waiting 5 weeks for a rain-free weekend to apply the oil (you want 48 hrs afterward with no rain).

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love the look of this wood after finished. If you go with Ipe, and don't let it weather, just be prepared to have a ton of maintenance year after year.

Good Luck!

Jason


img

Re: Looking for Decking Recommendations

#7

Re: Ipe as well...some regrets

FredD

Jason,

that Herring bone pattern is a eye catcher, very well done.

FredD