Re: Water based dye for oak floor
Steve Schoene
The General Finishes product you mention is not your typical dye. It is a dye in a binder. In my opinion, that will make it harder to use. Because of the binder you have to apply and wipe off excess like most stains. But, being water borne, it will dry fairly quickly, giving little time to apply and wipe off. At the very least it would be a two person job with one to apply and one to follow behind wiping off (with perhaps a go fetch person to help). Having a binder means you have only one chance to get it right, and you could get streaks if you can't work fast enough to keep a wet edge.
A powdered water soluble dye would be easier to use, I think. You would adjust the shade by adjusting the concentration of the dye mix so that it ends up the right darkness if you flood it on. You would want to wipe up puddles. The powdered water soluble dye can be adjusted--darken by another coat after it has dried or lightened by wiping down with water. You can even use chlorine bleach to remove it if it has turned out horribly. There is a risk that the dye might not "take" inside of pores, which sometimes seem to have a waxy coating. If that happens you would have to follow up by sealing the surface and applying a pigment only stain to lodge in the pores. You do have to seal the powdered water soluble dye before using a waterborne finish.
Oak accepts oil based stains well. You have more time to work, and the only tricky part is making sure you wipe off any bleed back from the surface. That means you have to check on it every 15 minutes or so for a while. Stains with pigment do give a much different look. The pore structure would be emphasized while with dye it would be minimized.
As far as the top coat, you want to use a finish specially formulated for floor. Some ordinary high gloss varnishes would be too slippery to be safe. Floor finishes need to meet a friction specification. Water borne polyurethane finishes such as Bona Kemi Traffic or Mega or Basic Coating Street Shoe are highly regarded.