OT Sink Drain
Jerry Gibbs
Our daughter just bought an 85 year old house (Thanks for the help, Dad). The inspector said the S traps under the sinks should be replaced with P traps. My borg sells both. Why is a P trap preferred?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT Sink Drain
Jerry Gibbs
Our daughter just bought an 85 year old house (Thanks for the help, Dad). The inspector said the S traps under the sinks should be replaced with P traps. My borg sells both. Why is a P trap preferred?
Re: OT Sink Drain
Dave Paine
Good question. I have replaced some metal S traps which were corroded with plastic S traps.
I have used a P trap in only one location, due to the space constraint between the sink and the drain. Too tight for an S trap, so had to use a P.
If you need to remove a trap due to a blockage, it is easier to catch the water under a P. Need larger bowl for an S.
We all hope we rarely get blockages.
Re: OT Sink Drain
Barry Irby
The problem with S traps if they tend to suffer from syphoning. If you turn loose a fairly large quantity of water it flows through the trap so quickly that it "slurps" the last of the water right through the trap, leaving it empty or without enough water to seal the trap. thus sewer cases could flow into the house.
As a Home Inspector I see S traps all the time in older homes. It is wise to change them to P traps, but as far as I know the S Traps are Grandfathered in and no jurisdiction requires upgrading the traps. So, if you remodel or have an opportunity to change out the traps it a good idea and may be required if you upgrade the system.
You can play with them. Fill the sink about half way, let the water out and listen. You may actually hear the slurping. Try different amounts of water. If your daughter learns to notice this, she can run a small amount of water (a pint or less) into the drain to refill the trap. (Less water than it takes to set up the syphon.) If she smells the "sick/sweet" smell of the sewer gas, run a little water into the trap.
At least in theory it is possible for the sewer gas to be flammable and dangerous to breath I think the chances of anything really serious resulting from S Traps is pretty remote. Also, 85 year old houses are pretty leaky to air infiltration and that should dilute any gases.
In the early days of plumbing and indoor bathrooms it was very stylish to have it. But the systems did not include traps at all and the way you could tell who had indoor plumbing was that their house stunk. As far as I know, none of these high society folks died or exploded.
Re: OT Sink Drain
Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon
I did a quick google search (it's a little slow for me at work this morning) and found that, Generally speaking S traps are not vented, hence the syphoning. A properly constructed p trap should be vented.
glc
Dumb additional question
Lee Schierer McKean, PA
Since an S trap would exit straight down through the base of a cabinet and a P trap would exit out the back, wouldn't conversion from one to another be rather extensive and costly in a finished area?
Lee
Re: Dumb additional question
Barry Irby
That is my understanding and why I suggested the time to replace them is when you are remodeling anyway. The venting might be the hardest part, but you can use an air vent under the sink if the local code permits.
Re: Dumb additional question
Jesper, Denmark
Maybe I am missing something, but shouldn't the drains all be vented through a stack going through the roof? If done properly, neither trap would siphon.
85 year old house
Jerry Gibbs
Re: Dumb additional question
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
Jesper, I have installed many of those vents Barry is speaking of. They are screwed into a fitting above the trap and let in air thru a rubber valve which seals off again when no water is evaculating. Most of them were on island sinks and bar sinks.
Re: Dumb additional question
Jesper, Denmark
I am familiar with a syphon breaker valve as you describe it. I have some on my boat plumbing to prevent syphoning seawater into the hull and sink it!.
I do live in an approximately 85 year old house - not quite sure if built in 1923 or 1928. All the drain plumbing leads to a 4" cast iron drain stack, venting throuigh the roof. This was (and is) a code requirement when the house was built.
I am a bit surprised that this is not a building code requirement today. Grandfather clauses usualy would require meeting current codes if you make major modifications, such as remodelling a kitchen. Syphon breakers are OK as long as they work, but in lines with some crud potential, they get plugged up after some time. Think of the last time you looked inside your trap! It was not yesterday, and it did not look nice and clean inside, did it?
Re: Dumb additional question
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
You are correct in the assumption that they need some inspection after a few years. The innards can be replaced by unscrewing and installing new flapper seal with a spring... but that is very seldom needed in todays materials. Good proper installation will take care of most problems you mentioned. And sending ice cubes thru your disposer with some lemon peels and maybe some salt will take care of cleaning out most buildups in the disposers.