Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

Posts

Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

#1

Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

mike

Take a look at this months issue of Fine Woodworking April 2011 No. 218. Shaker Tall Chest

If you were building this piece how much lumber would you buy?

thanks

Mike

Re: Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

#2

Ellis Walentine

More questions

Ellis Walentine

Your question isn't very specific, Mike, and it begs a lot more questions. First, that article wasn't about "build this cabinet" (with drawings and dimensions) but rather "try these techniques" (loose moldings, door fitting w/ jointer, butt hinge mounting), so there's little to go on besides the lede photo. How big is it anyway (I'd guess ~36" x 76" x 20")? Do you mean including secondary wood (back, drawer sides and bottoms, dust panels), or just the cherry? The door panels are 1/4" thick and maybe 11" wide; would you be resawing them from a single board? What is the back made of? Are there interior dividers and shelves, and what species are they? Are you a person who makes extra pieces in case something twists or gets screwed up? Are you ordering lumber over the phone or the Internet or are you picking it out yourself? How important is grain matching across the show surfaces? All these questions impact the amount of lumber you will need.

If all you want is to cover the finish square footage with primary wood, you can take that area and multiply it by a waste factor to get the surface footage of rough lumber it will take. The waste factor is going to vary from species to species, as different woods have differing amounts of defects, knots and sapwood depending on the grade. If you want clear cherry inside and out, it's going to be a significantly higher waste factor than if you will settle for clear heartwood only on the show faces, with sap permissible on the insides and hidden surfaces. A top quality cherry piece probably has a waste factor of 25 - 40%. If you want wide boards and/or matching grain, you will probably have to actually specify the individual pieces you need. In that photo, it looks like Becksvoort has used some really premium, straight-grained cherry, possibly all from the same log, judging by the grain matches on the sides and drawer fronts. There's another wrinkle for your estimating formula; if you want wood like that, you may have to buy an entire log.

As far as determining the amount of primary wood you'll need for this piece, I suggest you: 1) do a drawing to scale, with the dimensions you want for your piece; 2) do a take-off of the parts you will need; 3) make a list of the rough pieces you will get each part out of and whether they need to be clear heart both sides or not; 4) figure out how you will harvest these rough pieces from rough lumber and make a list of the actual boards you will need; 5) order or pick out the individual boards to make the piece.

If you are prepared to make it generically, that is, with more random grain matching, occasional sapwood, etc., you can just order your loaded total (actual finish board footage multiplied by waste factor) and work with what you get.

There are too many variables here to come up with real estimates for you without answering all the above questions.

Ellis

Re: Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

#3

Re: Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

Gary Smyth

There are two books that show a cabinet similar to the one shown in Fine Woodworking. I must admit that the one in the April issue of FW is better looking if not as authentic as originals. One from Watervliet, New York is on pages 44 and 45 and reveals a few dimensions, the height is 73 1/4" x 46 1/8" x 19". It is in the book by John Kassay "The Book of Shaker Furniture". Drawer heights from the bottom are 8 15/16, 8 15/16, 6 15/16, 6 15/16, 5 15/16, and 2 15/16". The doors are 24" high and are on either side of a 4 5/8" center stile.

The other is by Thos. Moser "How to Build Shaker Furniture" and is on pages 128 -129, called Dr. White's Cabinet. Its dimensions are 72" high x 43 1/4" wide x 19 1/8" deep. the drawer heights are 9", 8". 7" and 6". This one has a center stile of 8" between the doors that are 18 1/2" tall.

Neither cabinet is identical to the one in the magazine, but they look similar. Neither is a complete set of plans. The books are no longer in print as far as I know, but a library may have them.

Re: Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

#4

Ellis Walentine

Mike, contact me please...

Ellis Walentine

Re: Classic Shaker Cupboard FineWoodworking

#5

Re: More questions

Tony - Memphis

Another thing you could try is looking at similar projects in FWW and other mags and see how many bdft they list. Some magazines don't like to list total bft becuase of all the stuff Ellis discussed.

Tony