Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Any thoughts?

Posts

Any thoughts?

#1

Any thoughts?

Gary Smyth


I went to a house sale this week. I found this stone and paid much less than the gas it took to get there -- and the location was close. Anyway, the stone is very, very smooth, close to dead flat in the long direction with one corner low at the pictured end. (camera closeness exaggerates the curvature) It was semi-hard caked with clean gelled oil which I removed with solvent (the white haze). No name anywhere. The oil stain stayed, but I'm wondering if it might be a white Arkansas? It's almost as smooth as my black stone to the finger touch, but the pores seem bigger. It is not any where near as rough as any grit Norton stone I have, or for that matter, 1200 grit paper. I don't know how stones are graded and I haven't had success on the web identifying what stones are harder above the rougher grades. If it helps, the man was in his 90's and a farmer. Unless he went out of his way years ago, the stone would not be Japanese. Any recommendation as to what would be needed to touch up/flatten a very fine grained hard stone? Granite plate and diamond dust?

Re: Any thoughts?

#2

Re: Any thoughts?

Ron Bauman

Looks, on first glance, like a White Arkansas that I own. White with a sorta grey marbling.

Re: Any thoughts?

#3

Re: Any thoughts?

Neal in San Jose

You might consider posting this question over on the Hand Tool side. There are some very knowledgable folks over there that don't always make it over here on the "noisy side".

I'm of the opinion that it is not a white Arkansas, but rather a Washita stone. It looks just like mine, especially in the end view. If you hold it up to a bright light, is the stone slightly transparent? All of the white Arkansas stones I've seen are, and it doesn't look like this one is.

Washita stones are very useful; they are usually used after you reshape a damaged edge on a very coarse stone like a carborundum to refine the edge before moving to an Arkansas stone. They can also be used for minor reshaping if your blade isn't bad enough to require major work like taking out small nicks, etc. This stone can also give you an edge that is useable without further work where a very fine edge isn't required - kitchen knives come to mind. They are also somewhat elusive - I looked for a while before I found a good one for my shop. Good find!