Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Posts

A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#1

A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Bill Tindall


The table previously described has a slat shelf. (The picture shows the table up side down. ) The idea was to notch the slats and fit the notch over a stretcher between the short side of the legs.

One of the problems I have as an amateur woodworker is dealing with interruptions. I had made the slat pieces but returned later to cut the notch with a dado blade. Well, without thinking of the task at hand I dadoed most of the slats on the wrong side of the line before catching my mistake. In cases like this I usually mark with a crayon or chalk where the saw, or mortise, or what ever, is to remove wood, but failed to in this case. It was daunting to think about remaking all those slats. Yet, expanding the dado to enable the slat to fit over the stretcher would leave an unsightly gap behind the stretcher.

The lesson: For once I took a deep breath and considered the situation. Actually I walked away from it all and a while later imagined a fix that would look good and improve construction.

I inserted the walnut strip behind the stretcher which filled the mis-cut dado in the slat. I screwed this walnut strip to the stretcher and then nailed the slats to the strip. This construction relieved stress from the overhanging notch in the stretcher. Any force that spreads the legs will be absorbed by the nails and screws and not the weak grain of the overhanging slat ends.

The second "fix" is the walnut slat. When I dry fitted the slats the spacing was too great. Rather than cut one more strip from a fresh maple board I used a walnut strip that was waste from a previous project. I am typically not fond of mixed woods but walnut and maple can complement.

All's well that ends. It's done except for the tile

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#2

I know you could do it  Looks good

del schisler

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#3

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Jesse Cloud

That's the hallmark of a skilled woodworker - fix a mistake and make it stronger and prettier than it would have been with the mistake!

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#4

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Nice lemonade!

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#5

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

A fine example of thinking on your feet. Great job!

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#6

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

clay foster

The difference between a professional and an amateur is knowing how to cover up mistakes. Congratulations, you have now taken your place alongside many of us in The Royal Order Of Professional Screw Ups.

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#7

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

I hear you Clay, and I think I am a "charter member"..... LOL

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#8

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Nice fix Bill. In computer programming lingo, you have "bug." Some times, those bugs are fixed with more programming, and called a feature. Likewise, you have added a nice feature to your project.

You may have a future in computers,

Ken

Re: A lesson in fixing screw-ups

#9

I love when a screw-up becomes a design feature

Dave Paine

Bill, nice job with the design, and especially the "recovery".

I made this cribbage board last year. The ends are a small tenon with mortise cut in the slab. Hard to see in this angle. I had cut the tenon on the router, flipped the piece and cut the other side.

When I tested the fit, somehow the piece was not exactly square, or a moved, but one cut was a slight difference in length than the other. This resulted in a gap.

The "recovery" was either to re-cut the tenon, with no guarantee the second time would be better, or else glue up the ends, the route out the gap and enter an inlay.

I chose the latter, which is the rosewood strips. Solved the problem, and I feel actually looked better than if the original cut was perfect.