Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A Sturdy Footstool

Posts

A Sturdy Footstool

#1

A Sturdy Footstool

Steve Kirincich

I am working on a footstool that was described in a 2002 FWW article by Mario Rodriguez, and my question is about wedged mortise and tenon joints. I am using hard maple and I currently have pretty tight joints when test fitting. Since there appears to be no good reason to make the tenons slightly undersized to accomodate the wedges, will wedges accomplish anything with an already tight fit and will the wedges have any meaningful effect if they are made from a wood softer than hard maple? Thanks.

Steve

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

#2

JL

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

JL

Through or non-through? I've used these in several chairs (non-through). The chairs in question were to be used by people of "above average" status. I didn't want the joints coming apart. The joints worked and are still working after several years.

Do they make a difference? Possibly. They make the joint a mechanical joint, sort of like a dovetail joint. When used with glue, the joints aren't going anywhere. The joints (if made properly) will last with repeated stresses. Will they work with wood softer that hard maple? Sure.

On the other hand - modern glues and a well made joint usually won't go anywhere either. (Note the word "usually".)

I wedge all of my through tenons in my chairs. I often use a contrasting wood to add a bit of "interest". I don't wedge the non-through tenons - except as noted above.

Think of it as "belt and suspenders". You know your pants aren't going to slip with just a belt or suspenders. You're darn sure your pants aren't going to slip with both. :b

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

#3

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

Bill Tindall

In your case to wedge or not to wedge would be a fashion statement. Unless there are forces that continue to seat a wedging action (for example Windsor chair) I don't see any practical function.

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

#4

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

John Lucas

I've always used a wedge on tapered tenons that fit perfectly. Here is my question. If you drive a wedge in obviously it expands the 2 sides. would it then possibly elongate the hole and leave the other 2 sides with a less than perfect fit. I don't think so but thought I would throw that out. I still own my earliest chair and stool and they both are as solid as when I built them maybe 12 years ago.

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

#5

Watch it JL

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You could get in trouble if you run into a Henry Fonda type.

Re: A Sturdy Footstool

#6

For Those Unfamiliar

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Fonda played the bad-guy hired gun in "Once Upon A Time In The Old West", and when the "opposition" sent in an emissary for peace, the guy was wearing both a belt and suspenders. Fonda promptly shot him dead. When asked why, he replied:

"How can you trust a man who wears both a belt and suspenders? The man can't even trust his own pants."