Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Design opinions desired

Posts

Design opinions desired

#1

JL

Design opinions desired

JL

Which looks more pleasing - an even number of horizontals or an odd number.

I am modifying a coffee table design. My previous design had an odd number of center stretchers (three). I want to incorporate more center stretchers so that they can act more like a "shelf". Three stretchers gives me ~5" with the three stretchers and the two sets of spacers. I would get ~7" with four stretchers and ~9" with five stretchers.

TIA

Re: Design opinions desired

#2

Re: Design opinions desired

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Sounds crazy but odd numbers are often used in various design areas. In Landscape Architecture they always teach to plant trees/shrubs in odd numbers...never even.

T.

Re: Design opinions desired

#3

Re: Design opinions desired

Jesse Cloud

I agree with Tommy. If you look at the number of slats on the back of a chair, its almost always an odd number.

Re: Design opinions desired

#4

One of the first design rules...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I learned in school was to most always use odd numders.

A good example: car rims.

Re: Design opinions desired

#5

Do you follow or march to the beat of

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

a different drum? It is hard to find your own style if you don't break some rules.

This sort of thing is not etched in stone.

An even number of parts has an odd number of negative spaces between them. How you think of the negative space cam sometimes influence the feel.

Re: Design opinions desired

#6

Distraction . . .

steve mackay

I'm don't know much of anything about furniture design (or construction for that matter) but I do have tricks and gags for designing and building my miniatures and models. If I want to distract attention from an element that can't be built like the real thing I exaggerate another element. Odd numbers are at the top of the list (if they are even on the real thing). In your case, my guess would be that an odd number would tend to distract from the table top. If I were intending for the top to be the focus of the piece I'd go even. With my stuff the trick works. With furniture its probably way, WAY overthinking !

Re: Design opinions desired

#7

Re: Design opinions desired

Jesse Cloud

Best way to answer this question is to build a model. You can make it 1/4 size or less, make it out of cardboard or whatever scraps you have around. Put it together with screws, nails, or hotmelt. But it should give you a feel for the "right" number of stretchers.

Re: Design opinions desired

#8

Re: Design opinions desired

mdclor

If you look at Stickley as a reference, I think you will always find an odd number is used. FWIW.

Re: Design opinions desired

#9

JL

Thanks for the replies -odd it is.

JL

I sketched it out to scale, and odd looked a bit better.