Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT sort of Electrical ?

Posts

OT sort of Electrical ?

#1

OT sort of Electrical ?

Dustmaker Mike

All right I am done with all the little stuff around the house that has stopped me from doing the electrical in my shop addition I did last year. I have done a little research and I am comfortable doing it myself. I have two questions that I have found conflicting information on. First off here is what I am doing I have a main panel in my basement that has a 150 amp feed. I want to run a 100 amp panel in the new shop area. Here are my questions I have to run about 60 to 70 feet from the main to the sub (shop) what I want to do is put in a box on the side of the main with a single breaker in it and tap the main line instead of taken up a breaker spot in the main box. Is this legal? I am going to ask the inspector before I do it but I don't really want him to laugh at me. The next thing is what gauge wire do I need to run? It is all inside runs I am going to use stranded copper I am thinking 4 gauge X 3 and one 6 gauge. I have been told by a few other folks that 6 gauge would be enough, but I am not so sure. Is there a site that makes the NEMA code easy to read for dummies(-;

As always Thanks

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Moses Yoder

I would suggest having a licensed electrician put in the panel, then wire the shop yourself from there. Where I live I would need a permit to do the wiring, and it would have to be inspected when it's finished. Also, if you have a 150 amp panel in your basement and you pull 100 amps off of it, you only have 50 amps left. If you attach direct to the incoming wire it seems like that wire would have to be big enough to draw 250 amps. I would get an electrician out to your place to look at it and see where the best place is to get the electric into your shop, which might be directly from your transfromer if you have one for your house like we do.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#3

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

John Veerkamp

If you have a main breaker at the pole (code in many places) That breaker will govern the max draw at any one time. It is unlikely that you'll ever be pulling that load simultaneously. If you air condition the shop as well as the house and you're cooking with electric and have electric hot water , you may approach your limits when you turn on your DC and table saw, otherwise loads should be OK. #4 stranded copper will carry your proposed load. I'm not sure if what you suggest is up to code in your area, but theoretically it is doable.

Not professional, just reasonably proficient DIY'r.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#4

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Galen Vetterick

Where I live you would have to use a dual breaker in your main panel to feed to your sub panel. The main breaker in the master panel has to be able to cut power to your sub panel.

That said it was for a shop area that was attached to the house.

For the electrical to my remote shop/shed the power feed came right fom the meter on the side of the house and the main disconnect then was in the shop/shed panel.

I tried to fight the atached shop regualtion as it only shared a commpn wall and you had to exit the house to enter the shop door. The meter box was right on that common wall for such a short hook up. I had to open a finished basement ceiling all the way across the house where the main panel was located to run the feed instead!

Two differnt regualtions or at least how the inspectors read it.

Good luck.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#5

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Barry Irby

Mike, if you don't install a breaker in your existing panel what are you going to attach the new wire to? I can't remember seeing a breaker panel with what I call "take off lugs". If there were such lugs it is possible they would not be after the main breaker and put you at risk of over loading the income service conductor. If the lugs were present and after the main breakers you could not overload the main service conductors, but it might be possible to trip the mains.

You need to do some sort of survey and figure out what your maximum draw might be at any given moment. That will tell you if the 150 amps is enough.

Also, locally you would have to set up the new panel as a four conductor panel. Two hots, and neutral and and a ground and you should separate the grounds and neutrals in the new panel. The four conductor cable will cost more than the three conductor stuff.

Money spent on a competent electrician might be well spent.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#6

Couple thoughts...

John in NM

I think you'll have to have a sub panel coming from the main panel. Two independent panels on one structure is a no-no (an unsuspecting person could get zapped when they thought they'd killed the only panel).

The general rule of thumb I've seen around the internet ww world is that bigger is always better with electricity. Big circuits, over spec wiring, etc, etc. Obviously, I don't know what your requirements are, but I suspect 100 amps is going to be far more than you need. IIRC, for a residential structure you're allowed 25% over your main (but check that, don't depend on the word of some schmoe on the net), so the sum of all breakers in the main panel should not exceed 180 to 190 amps. You probably don't need to worry much about balancing in the main panel, but you should be aware of it in the sub panel.

If 100 amps is what you in fact need, the wire sizes you listed will be fine, assuming the length of run isn't huge. Your public library should have a code book if you don't want to buy one (probably the IRC, not the NEC). You can find out from your local building inspectors office which code you need and if there are any local amendments to it. Code books are protected by copyright I think, so you're not likely to find significant parts of them on the web, just discussion of them.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#7

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Stuart Johnson

I had an electrician install my sub panel then I wired the shop (garage). The sub is connected to the main line ahead of the main panel with a single pull breaker. When the garage space was remodeled into a sewing studio several new circuits were added in the room also by a licensed electrician. We are in the county and there is not only no requirement for electrical inspections there are no inspectors. I am not comfortable with the idea of not knowing for certain all power is off when the main breaker is thrown so I made a couple large warning labels to go inside both panels giving the location of each panel and a caution about throwing both breakers. There is also a warning inside the sub panel main breaker.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#8

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

FredD

You definitely need a Electrican to surrvey your proposed electrical requirements Mike.

Don't be surprised if he says you would need a service change to a bigger main , divided panels rated at 200-250 Amps are made for this situation.

Taking a 100 Amp load off a 150 amp Main won't work without causing problems.

For instance the maximum load on a residential panel is figured at 80% of the Breaker protecting it.

So your 150 main is really only rated for 120 Amps.

If you have a typical shop load and house load , your present service is to small.

Get a Electrician , it's way safer and you avoid any problems with substandard wiring down the line , if you sell your home.

FredD

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#9

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Mike, a couple of thoughts. First I think your capacity is ok, 150 amp is plenty for a home unless you have electric heat, electric range and electric water heater all running at the same time - even then it probably would work ok. BUT I personally would not tap into the main buss to install a second panel. I would install the 100 amp breaker and go from there. I installed a 200 amp in my house several years ago (replacing an old 60 amp 4 circuit fuse type entrance). When I built my shop I installed a 100 amp breaker and fed the shop entrance with a 2/0 copper underground feed line. The main reason I wouldn't drop off the buss is that the main bus is only fused by the 150 amp main and the wire to the 2nd panel should be rated for that current. The FIRST thing you should do is go to the local building inspection office and request the answers to your questions - many areas do not go by the NEC - they have their own set of rules. If the reason you don't want to install the breaker in the main entrance is lack of circuit space - you may want to expand the 2nd box so you have room there to install a few breakers for your house. I doubt you will ever pull more than 40 amp in the shop at one time unless you have 4 or 5 or your biggest machines running. Remember a 100 amp service actually carries 200 amps on 120 volt - or 100 amp on 240Volt. I have a 3 hp cyclone, a 5 hp joiner, 3 hp cabinet saw, 3 hp joiner, 6 hp ( actually about 2 hp compressor) and a 4.8 hp bandsaw. with about 25 4 foot dual florescent fixtures and central air. Doubt if I ever exceed 40 amp at 240 volt except when machines are starting, as I seldom have more than the compressor, dust collector and 1 big machine running at a time.

BTW I contracted on the side for about 25 years and installed electrical entrances, residential, commercial and some industrial wiring during that time.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#10

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Tony - Memphis

I don't know much about this stuff, but her eis how the electrician wired my shop when it was built (at the same time as the house). I have a 200 Amp service for the house. Next to that panel is a switch that controls power to the shop. The shop has its own 100 panel. Som, the shop is not going through the house panel. My shop panel is full now. I recently added another 220 (240) outlet for a new tablesaw. I thought I had plenty of physical space, but it turns out that some of my slots were dummies! Now, why would they do that?!? That's when I called the electrcian. I wired the outlet into the panel myself before realizing there was nothing to hook it to. They just moved some things around and added some slim breakers and made it work. Cost me around $125. I don't know what wire size they used to wire from the house to the panel. It is inside conduit though. They originally just wired the shop out of the house panel, but that is not what I had specified in the contract. My builder neglected to tell the electrician. Oh, my shop is an outbuilding.

Tony

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#11

Re: OT sort of Electrical ? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If it's truly a main panel, you should treat it as the point from which everything flows; I wouldn't put the breaker in a box beside it.

Also: my understanding is that code requires a breaker at the main panel and another "main" breaker (service disconnect) at your subpanel for your shop, for a distance like that. Good idea anyway - you want to be able to disconnect power to the subpanel from the upstream end of the wires, as the wires leave your main panel; and also at the panel itself, if you encounter a problem while in the shop for which killing all power is the right answer.

There are tables for wire sizing; the link below is to one that looks pretty cool, but you could find others. I googled "wire size, residential wiring, voltage drop."

If in doubt, it's always better to go larger than smaller. Too large requires a little extra money, but harms nothing but your wallet; too small can lead to motors not performing right or, in rare cases, burning out early; and way too small can lead to fires, which is so much not fun.


http://www.csgnetwork.com/wiresizecalc.html

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#12

Installation comments

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Conduit size matters, too (I'm assuming here that the run will be in conduit; if you're all interior and using NM, or if you're burying underground feeder, disregard these comments). The code provides for a maximum number of wires in a conduit, but a conduit one size larger than code makes for an easier pull.

Lay your wires out and tape them together periodically, so they don't twist over each other.

And get wire pulling lubricant (any hardware or big boxy store). Messy in use, but makes a huge difference.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#13

Got my answer

Dustmaker Mike

alrighty I played hookie from work this afternoon and talked to the inspector about how I should proceed. I like living in a small town. He said all I have to do is put in a 100 amp breaker and use it as a feed to the box in the shop. I can use 4 x 3 stranded copper or 2 x3 aluminum. So I guess I hit the supply house this weekend and start pulling wire.

Thanks for the replys

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#14

Re: Got my answer

Steve Schoene

One more thing to note: Since the shop and house are connected, I believe you need to keep the ground and neutral separate in the sub panel. (There is a connector that must be removed to separate the buss bars in the subpanel.) That does mean that wiring breakers in the subpanel will be different than in a main panel. Neutral (whites in 120 v. circuits) go on the side bus bars and the bare ground wires to the top, separate, bus bar.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#15

Aluminum vs. copper

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Back in the 1970s, there were problems because aluminum wire will slowly deform under pressure, which resulted in a lot of loose connections, overheating, fires, etc. Aluminum-rated connectors are supposed to solve that problem; but, myself, I'd go with copper.

But, my biases: I get conservative when it comes to materials. I still use metal boxes rather than plastic, because metal boxes will last longer/break less, and can be repaired in the wall if they strip out.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#16

Depends on the panel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"(There is a connector that must be removed to separate the buss bars in the subpanel.) That does mean that wiring breakers in the subpanel will be different than in a main panel. Neutral (whites in 120 v. circuits) go on the side bus bars and the bare ground wires to the top, separate, bus bar."

The Cutler-Hammer subpanels my local home improvement store sells don't come with ground busses; they have to be purchased and installed separately. They screw directly to the box. Although it's redundant, I like to run the incoming ground wire through a grounding tab on its way to the ground bus (I am a big believer in the principle that it's not possible to overdo safety grounding).

The Cutler-Hammer boxes do come with a bonding connector that you don't use, to bond the neutral bus to the box.

Mike talks about having a main panel in the basement - depending on how his house is wired, that may already be a subpanel, with the bonded main out at the meter. That was how we wired our house, because the only space available to put the meter was too small for a true main panel, so I treated the main primarily as a service disconnect and ran wire in conduit (THAT was fun to do solo!) to a subpanel in the back entryway. I've upgraded the panel size once, now, to accommodate more breakers.

At any rate, yes, regardless of how the basement panel is wired, any and all subpanels should separate the neutral (white) and equipment/safety ground (green/bare).

Depending on code in your area, you may also need to install a redundant ground rod for the garage subpanel, which then may need mechanical shielding (flex conduit) for the wire to the ground rod, depending on wire size. Given the size of the subpanel, you will probably want a wire to the ground rod large enough that mechanical shielding won't be needed.

If you've never driven a ground rod, you should know that those pipes-with-handles that they sell for driving metal fence posts are your very best friend (absent a power hammer with a ground rod driver, that is). They'll let you drive the rod with both hands without having to find a third hand to hold it still. Finishing off the last couple of feet with a sledge hammer is simple; driving it from the top with a sledge hammer is way over toward the other side of the simple/doggoned hard scale. Your favorite cold beverage is your second-best friend for this particular project, to be savored when you're done finding every rock and thick root in the ground outside your garage with the tip of the rod (I have this mental image of the rocks/roots/old tractor motors jockeying for position underground, so they can be right below the rod as you drive it).

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#17

Re: Aluminum vs. copper

Barry Irby

Not to argue with Bill, but the problem with aluminum is with single stranded conductors, not the multi stranded. If you use aluminum you should be sure the breakers on each end are rated for both copper and aluminum and you should coat the ends of the wires with anti oxide paste. My personal opinion is that copper is better, but aluminum meets the Code and is cheaper. As a Home Inspector I seldom see copper in larger sizes.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#18

Re: Aluminum vs. copper

Dan Donaldson

I would not use aluminum for regular wiring, but for service feeds etc., if you are in the business and quote copper for those, you will probably starve. For the big stuff, the difference in cost is just too much for most to accept, you just have to make sure it is done properly.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#19

Re: Aluminum vs. copper

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The stuff we use is ACSR - aluminum core, steel reinforced. But then this is used for 115kv and 230 kv transmission lines. It's also used for 800kv dc lines. I can't imagine how much it would cost to build a transmission line with copper.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#20

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

Phil Joines

I believe the code doesn't allow two breakers in series on the same circuit. The sub panel should be a main lug type.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Ahhh....Grounding rods...

Jesper, Denmark

I built a solvent recovery plant in Augusta, GA many years ago. All the equipment had to be bonded and grouns�ded, so ther was a grund rod grid all asround the plant. When the inspector measured the resistance to grond, he expected 2-3 Ohms, but found zero resistance???

It turned out that ther was a 10" FRP fire main already in the ground and we had hit the main squarely along one side of the plant, pounding the ground rods through the fire main.

The ground rods stayed. The fire main was replaced to a diffeent location. The consulting engineer ended up paying, as they had not shown the fire main on the drawings. Poetic justice.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#22

Plans vs. as-built

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My university, for a while, was devoting effort to amending campus drawings to show how buildings and infrastructure were actually built, not just what the architect thought. The senior plumbers, electricians, groundskeepers all knew where there was a pipe or conduit not on the plans, but that's not the kind of knowledge you want just in heads - your story is a vivid example of why.

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#23

Re: Depends on the panel

FredD

"Depending on code in your area, you may also need to install a redundant ground rod for the garage subpanel, which then may need mechanical shielding (flex conduit) for the wire to the ground rod, depending on wire size. Given the size of the Sub Panel, you will probably want a wire to the ground rod large enough that mechanical shielding won't be needed."

A couple of things about grounding a sub panel.

Depending on the soil composition.it's resistivity and the distance between the house and shop panels, driving a ground rod for the shop panel can form something called a "Ground Loop" which is one of the reasons why a professional Electrician is much preferred over week end warrior anecdotal " did this my way" methods and something to be avoided.

In my experience this has always been determined by the Electrician doing the job, based on His Experience grounding Sub Panels in that area.

In the the parts of Northern, Ca I operated a construction company in, the rules governing the wire size and type and whether or not it was required to be shielded for a ground wire from the Panel to the Ground rod varied , a lot...

I had one Job in Oakland , Ca where the Electrical was done by a Electrical Contractor and he was made to shield the ground wire because he used a braided conductor unshielded, which was okay in the County , but not in the city.

Go figure.

FredD

Re: OT sort of Electrical ?

#24

Good reason to check the local amendments...

John in NM

Grounding is one of them here, where the ground is usually dry enough for what Fred describes. All ground rods downstream of the meter must be connected by #4 solid wire - at the time we built, IRC allowed grounds of separate buildings to be isolated unless there was a non-powered connecting wire (like telephone).

NM has other amendments dealing with plumbing, alternative building methods, stucco, etc. The larger cities likely have their own set of amendments to the code they follow - we're fortunate to be rural enough to follow the state rather than city or county ordinance, making things relatively simple.