Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

Posts

trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#1

trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

ron

A contractor is about to commence groundwork on my 48x32 shop building. While planning I initiated this thread several months back.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives.pl/bid/1001/md/read/id/420196/sbj/if-you-re-planning-a-hobby-shop-and/

I like the flooring suggestion made by a couple of folks in that discussion, involving floating 2x4 sleepers spaced by foam board under a heavy plywood. There's also a vapor barrier under those sleepers, and the sleepers have to be cut to 3.5' max length.

Any opinions about using Trex (50% plastic 50% wood fiber) or something like that instead of 2x4s?? They wouldn't have to be cut to short lengths, though ripping them in half might be an economic move. They're a consistent thickness (1" or 5/4" I think) and not? prone to decay. Perhaps letting the concrete breath a bit (no vapor barrier) is a good idea too.

Reactions?

ron

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#2

JL

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

JL

Vapor barrier or not...

Is the contractor putting a vapor barrier under the slab between the dirt and the concrete?? If so, you may not need a vapor barrier. Way back when (my first job) was working for a concrete contractor. We always graded and dug the foundations, put down the 4 mil plastic and then out down the rebar and the wire.

BUT - you made a point about letting the concrete "breathe". It won't "breathe" unless the space between the concrete and the plywood is vented. After your concrete is fully cured, lay down a piece of plastic with a weight on the plastic. If you get condensation on the underside - you need a vapor barrier or venting.

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#3

Yes to vapor barrier under slab, but

ron

There is to be a vapor barrier under the slab, but due to my under-slab ducts for dust collection, the poly will have a few holes through it.

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#4

Clint Searl

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

Clint Searl

For my 30 x 40 slab floor, I laid a vapor barrier followed by 5/4 x 6 PTSYP sleepers (1" actual), 24" OC with 1" EPS between, topped with 4 x 8 T&G Advantech OSB. Perfect after six years.

The vapor barrier question is irrelevant. Just do it.

Clint

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#5

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

FredD

Slab work by competent Contractors is fairly straight forward Ron.

I would require the concrete poured over a sand base rather then on dirt.

Use a 6 MIl Plastic vapor barrier directly under the concrete rather then over it .

A 6"x6"x10 Ga. wire screen was used for many years for reinforcement, recently a 1/4" Rebar mat is used, either works fine.

Ask the Contractor if he uses a Curing compound sprayed on the slab as soon as he can walk on it, if he doesn't. insist on it.

This curing compound is carried by all Cement supplies and Concrete batch plants and a lot of larger Hardware's and keeps the Concrete from drying to fast and developing shrinkage cracks. It also is a measure of how good your Contractor is.

Use pressure treated 2x4's under the Plywood for the same reason code requires it for sole plates in contact with Concrete.

If you want the Concrete insulated , put the rigid foam under it , not over it.

I prefer a hollow space between the sleepers , foam added , would form a moisture stop that you don't want under the floor.

You will enjoy the floor , keep us informed.

FredD

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#6

Re: t rex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

Barry Irby

Not sure you want to know this, but lemme splain to you bout concrete floors.

A good slab will be relatively warm and dry. What makes a "good" slab?

The floor should be high enough above grade to allow for good grading around the perimeter and to keep the siding up off the grade. this may dictate or at least indicate that you should used a masonry foundation with a separate slab. This makes it easier to provide for insulating the slab. A "monolithic pour" has the foundation and slab as a single unit. A little more difficult to insulate the perimeter.

Assuming a block or block and brick foundation, install a perimeter drain around the inside on top of the footing. Slope the soil so that it is like a dome with all the surface sloping toward the drain. Fill with very coarse sand or gravel with few "fines" in it. Install the plumbing, conduit, and ducting in the gravel. Insulate the perimeter with closed cell styrofoam, perhaps two inches thick. this can be let down into the gravel, leaving four to six inches for concrete. Cover the surface with 6mill polyethylene. Either reinforce the slab with welded wire fabric or re-rod mats or use concrete with fiberglass reinforcement mixed in.

The premise behind these steps: Water will try to find its way up and out of the soil and it will soak up through capillary action. Capillary action depends on the soil having capillaries or very fine spaces in it. Capillary action always moves water from wetter to dryer, trying to make everything equally wet. If it rains on the surrounding soil, water will try to find its way in. Coarse sand or gravel does not have capillaries. Thus its technical name is a "capillary cut off or boundary layer." The water can not soak upward through the gravel. But water is insidious. It reaches the surface and then it will evaporate and rise through the gravel as humidity, condense on the bottom of the slab and soak through. If you put in the the poly, it hits that, condenses and drips off, falling back down through the gravel to the surface of the soil and either soaks in or runs down the slope to the pipe and drains out. Thus the poly is both a humidity/vapor barrier and a water barrier.

Properly mixed concrete does not dry, it sets. Theoretically every molecule of water is bound chemically in the setting reaction and none remains to "dry out", but that probably never happens and there will be excess water. People pouring slabs like to add extra water to make the mix soupy and easier to flow and flatten. So in the real world, the slab will dry for a while.

If you insulate the perimeter, you cut off most of the heat trying to escape. The center of the slab should be a relatively comfortable 60 degrees plus, unless you live in a very cold climate.

You could install sleepers with foam in between and T&G plywood over the top and it would be a better floor, warmer and easier on the feet and knees. On a well constructed slab you probably don't need the vapor barrier over the top, but do it anyway, its cheap and easy and good insurance. Use treated sleepers, again, cheap and easy and good insurance against both rot and termites.

Be sure your ducts for the DC are suitable for ground contact and are sealed against the intrusion of water (and air). Not a bad idea to treat the gravel for termites. Would not want the DC ducts to "inhale" termite treatment or any of the other baddies that might lurk under the slab.

Also, any piece of concrete over 1000 SF is prone to crack. You could "solve" this by installed control joints. The reason I said "solve" is that the solution is to install cracks rather that let them occur at random.

I have no experience with Trex and certainly none is this unusual application, so I can't comment other than to say I know treated lumber works for this application.

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#7

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

Ed Wesolek

Sounds like a fun project and you will enjoy building it. I built my barn and used radiant floor heating and I have been very pleased with the results. I did put a vapor barrier underneath the concrete both to insulate it and to stop moisture from coming through it as well.

The contractor did pour it wet so it took a little longer to set up. Afetr about a month or so we then painted it with an epoxy paint which is holding up well so far.

On the side walls we dug a 2 foot rat wall and had 2 inches of foam on the outside and then made the pour all as one. Also did the controlled cuts and that has worked out well as well.

Here in Michigan my barn was at an uncomfortable 63 degrees for the winter. I also over killed on the insutlation with R-27 in the side walls and an R-50 in the ceiling. The dust collection is in the floor along with some electrical and air supply.

Have a great time building it and putting your dream together as it is very cool.

Enjoy

Ed

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#8

What about the trex idea??

ron

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#9

Re: What about the trex idea??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not sure where you are Ron, But Trex doesn't have the greatest track record in my area. Contrary to popular belief it will absorb a significant amount of water and will swell. It will hold that moisture longer than SYP, and so can foster the increased growth of molds in confined spaces.

Given its high cost relative to treated wood, I rather don't think I'd bother with it.

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#10

Re: What about the trex idea??

Barry Irby

Ron, Trex is a man made product and does not have a long track record and part of what it does have is not great. It is my understanding that the entire first generation of it was recalled and had to be replaced. Lets hope the current generation is significantly better. Not only does it have something of a checkered past, you are proposing to experiment with using it in a situation that is non-standard. You would have to contact the manufacturer to see if they have tested it for this application or anything like it. Additionally, normally Trex is screwed to wooden framing. We don't know what it's screw holding characteristics are and whether it will offer the withdrawal resistance needed to hold the flooring down long term. In Spite of your best efforts there will be moisture migration through he floor system and some temperature differentials. We don't know how the Trex will react in relation to the concrete and plywood or OSB and what stresses that will put on the connections in the systems.

So, if you want to experiment with this and use an expensive product in an unusual application for which it was not designed, go ahead, and let us know how it works out. The manufacturers of Trex might be interested also.

Otherwise, stick to more standard materials.

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#11

Re: What about the trex idea??

FredD

"So, if you want to experiment with this and use an expensive product in an unusual application for which it

was not designed, go ahead, and let us know how it works out. The manufacturers of Trex might be interested also.

Otherwise, stick to more standard materials. "

Excellent answer and right to the point.

FredD

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#12

Clint Searl

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

Clint Searl

2x4's, Trex, and 9/8 ply is overkill. In my 30x40 shop I used 3/4 T&G Advantech screwed to 5/4 (1" actual) x 6" PTSYP, 24" OC with 1" EPS between the sleepers, all over poly on the slab. It's been great.

Why does the slab need to "breathe"?

Clint

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

#13

Re: trex sleepers under 9/8 ply for shop floor?

FredD

Your terminology is wrong Clint and so is your assessment for what is overkill.

241Plywood or construction grade 1/ 1/8" plywood is made for the times that you want a increased O.C, span between joists and or a stiffer resistance to deflection.

The 241 grade allows you to omit underlayment for sheet flooring like Linoleum.

That isn't overkill , it is good construction.

Anything less in specs is simply that.

FredD