We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Hello, I have just brought home a hard maple log from northern Wisconsin and before I take it to my local kiln to dry I thought I'd see if I might get some suggestions on how to keep it as pristine as possible. I.e. - reduce checking. The log is 62" long and aprox 24" at it's largest diameter and weights 300-400 pounds. I have stripped all the bark off leaving the wonderfully warped wood underneath exposed.
If anyone has suggestions on any part of my process of project I'd be most grateful for them.
They could include:
- what temp to kiln dry it at, I believe he runs his at 185 degrees.
- air dry for months or years before heading to the kiln?
- time you think it needs to cook in the kiln?
- any of a number of things I am not thinking of at the moment.
Ultimately, my plan is to cut the log in half - 2pcs. aprox. 30" in length and use them as a base for a dining room table with a glass top.
Fundamental principal: The radial shrinkage of wood is typically about 1/2 the tangential shrinkage. This fact means that when a section of trunk or limb dries it will develop pie shaped cracks to relieve the stress of the circumference shrinking at twice the rate of the diameter. This differential shrinkage will not begin to occur until the wood is about 30% moisture content.
Another fundamental principal: maple will develop black mold if the surface of the wood is a high moisture content. This mold will penetrate the depth of the wood in days.
And yet another: The center portion of trees always splits when drying. The fist wood a tree forms is different from the rest. It is very unstable and prone to excessive shrinkage. For this reason the center of logs never is included in furniture wood; its fate is pallet lumber.
As a result of these facts it is impossible to dry a log with out it cracking severely, and, it will be difficult to avoid black mold discoloring a drying maple log.
If you saw the log in half before the drying begins you will have some small chance of drying it without severe splitting, except at the center. The problem is that you want to dry it slow to prevent splitting and fast to avoid mold stain.
Virgil Leih is a woodturner in MN who does some pretty spectacular turning of whole logs, bigger than the one you have pictured. He dries them in a homemade microwave capable of handling huge sections. I've seen some of his turnings at the MN Landscape Arboretum - they're huge and have no cracks.
When I saw the quality of the work published here - I knew this was the wood working site to join. The level of professionalism is impressive and and an active forum to boot, just what a rookie like me needs. Awesome!
Bill - thanks for the thorough response. Regarding the mold, are you speaking of spalting? I believe that is the case and when that happens I am more than happy for the added texture it adds to my work. I actually do a lot of work with thick slabs of end grain maple, yes I know but I'm a glutton for punishment, and they always wind up with spalting around the edges. I have also worked around large cracks, I cut them out and leave the space as a void in my work, an example can be found here (let's see if I can create a link) http://williamallendesigns.com/splittable.html"
Bruce - thank you sir, I will check out the site and contactVirgil.
There is a fungus that attacks green lumber under warm moist conditions. It secrets a black pigment (actually I think it may be blue but in high doses it appears black). It can penetrate wood at an astonishing rate, reaching the center of 4/4 lumber in but a few days under warm conditions. The result is a blue to black stain anywhere it has penetrated. Maple and the pines are particularly susceptible to attack. At least in the case of lumber, in warm weather getting the surface dry immediately will prevent this stain. Coating with fungicide also works for lumber.
The picture shows a mild case of this stain on the end of a maple chunk I attempted to dry for turning stock. Note I split the log in quarters before attempting to dry it. Because it was a large piece I dried it slowly after getting the surface dry to "prevent" the mold. It molded anyway, all the way to the center. In severe cases the wood will be black.
Yeah, it is nasty stuff. I bought a truckload of undried hard maple from a local sawmill which was too slow to dry it and the mold hit the stickered 4/4 lumber over a weekend. Since I intended to use it for secondary wood it didn't matter much to me but it made it effectively worthless to them and they just wanted to get rid of it as quickly as possible. It makes great 'Shaker' blanket boxes as long as they are going to be painted anyway.
Another wood that is ruined almost immediately by the mold is holly. I've only managed to dry holly turning blocks a couple of times and only then by bathing them in hydrogen peroxide to knock down the spores before they sprout and then getting them into a plastic tent dried by a dehumidifier (my 'kiln'). With holly, meant to be pure white anyway, the little bit of bleaching that occurs is no problem.
I saw this earlier and started to be the first o answer, but was in a hurry and decided to let Bill T and Clint and the others answer for me. Thanks fr saving me a lot of typing.
The truth is that none of actually knows what will happen, but the advice you have gotten represents a lot of experience and will give you a much better chance at success than a shot in the dark. Unless you know something we don't.
To recap, I would split the pieces in half now Might even take a two inch slab out of the center to eliminate some of that early or juvenile wood Bill mentioned.
I'd give it a liberal dose of Clorox. Coat the ends with wax. And cover it with a liberal coat of Timbor or Boracare. Sack it with plenty of air space and hope for the best. I assume the will warp, with the center appearing to bulge outward and the edges pulling back, but only time will tell. You will have to flatten the face later or perhaps carve it.
I normally like Bora Care better than Timbor, but it has Glycol in it and I an mot sure I want to be carving and sanding a piece that is soaked in glycol. Timbor might be best.
Shame you can't figure out a way to cut a bowl blank out of each of those bulges (burls?) and keep the shell.
Just to be clear, considering the nature of the exterior of the log, my vision is to turn it into 2 solid pieces of equal height and use them to support a large piece of glass, I.e. a dining room table. Once I get into it I'll probably attach pieces of copper where the wood is flatter as is my style.
Thanks for the responses I have a few questions to the last poster.
Might even take a two inch slab out of the center to eliminate some of that early or juvenile wood Bill mentioned.
Not sure what you mean by taking a slab out of the middle? After these posts I'm thinking I might be able to bore out some of the center? Say a 6" to 8" hole thru the middle heartwood. Not sure how I could do that, but perhaps it might eliminate the chances of a complete split? Thoughts?
I'd give it a liberal dose of Clorox. Coat the ends with wax. And cover it with a liberal coat of Timbor or Boracare. Sack it with plenty of air space and hope for the best. I assume the will warp, with the center appearing to bulge outward and the edges pulling back, but only time will tell.
So I'm assuming you are saying I need to forego a kiln and air dry this over the course of years? Considering the size of the log wouldn't that take 10+ years?
Shame you can't figure out a way to cut a bowl blank out of each of those bulges (burls?) and keep the shell.
I honestly don't know what exactly forms a burl, I'm assuming this is a disease that has caused the tree to bulge in this manner. Also, I don't turn, sorry.
Also, if I am able to remove a portion of the center of the log would you risk kiln drying or opt for air dry? Would I need to wax the interior I cut out as well as the ends?
I really appreciate all the comments and the help folks! I love what I am making and have no teachers to help me with my craft - so this is awesome.
I have managed to work with some full logs without checking before, but only by taking a bit out of the middle. I did that by drilling out progressively larger holes. Twist drills for steel drill nicely in end-grain, and I have some over 1".
Once you have a 1" hole, a large spade bit will enlarge pretty good, but rough. My final bit was a multi-spur type, ~ 3", which was enough for the cherry I was working.
On another occasion, I use a whole tree, which I ripped down the middle with a chain-saw. Then I cut the juvenile wood out with the chain-saw also, by cutting two 45� rips which touched at the tip, more or less. This was a Post Oak about 20" diameter, that I re-assembled the parts around a steel column in a restaurant, with the understanding with the customer, that it would shrink, and likely check. As it turned out, it hasn't checked, but I have had to go back in several times to fill, fair and texture the joined gap to look like the rest of the bare cambium.
Since you are going to half it anyway, I would just use a circular saw to rip two 45� rips that touch at the bottom,to get that much out. Then be thinking about how to use that as a design element, or hide under the copper.
I like the others will warn you to expect the blue stain, but also note that sapwood of most species dries about twice as fast as the heartwood, and since it happens to be on the outside, will drop below the 30% MC which Bill mentioned first.
What you need to do is slow that moisture loss down some, so it will not get out ahead of the MC of the heartwood. I have used wipe on poly on wet wood before without any problems, and I would imagine there are other finishes that might work better. But obviously you can't build a high coat of anything without the possibility of clouding underneath. One good wet coat of penetrating finish on the sapwood only might even help inhibit some of the staining.
You can talk to someone about kiln drying it, but don't expect their schedule to fit anywhere close to what your wood needs, so don't get your hopes too high.
The whole tree that I mentioned above went in green, and only took less than two years to settle down. However, let me warn you, not to set the end of these logs on a hardwood or carpet floor too soon, or there will be thick mold growing under it, that can ruin the floor. Getting it up on casters would be a good idea.
If you choose to air dry, keep it out of the Sun. If you can keep it close to watch closely, and tiny checks appear, toss a drop cloth over it for a spell. This will slow the surface moisture loss, and allow it to absorb from the interior.
Don't put it in a loft or attic, but don't store it too close to the earth or slab either.
Dang, Sorry to go so long. I only want to add a paragraph. sorry
Bill, What I was proposing was that you split the log right down the middle turning it into two half logs. (I'll get back to the slab out of the middle in a minute.) The idea was to reduce or eliminate some of the stresses that occur when a log tries to dry as a whole. That problem occurs when the wood on the outside drys faster than the wood in the center. The outer wood shrinks but the center does not and the cracks appear. Cutting the log in half allows the outer part to contract and not crack (as badly). Imagine that the end of the log is a pie and you cut it in half. Then when the log is dry it might look like somebody came buy and cut a small sliver off each half. The cut across the center would not longer be straight and there would be a little dihedral angle or point in the center.
You are planing to cut it in half anyway (right?), so doing it first seems like it would improve you chances of getting it dry without serious cracks.
The idea of taking a slab out of the middle was to cut an inch on either side of center. This would remove some of the juvenile wood.
Keith has given you some good ideas and has actual experience. Rather than take the slab out, if it suits your design you might take out the center. If you could remove four or six inches out of the middle it would remove most of the juvenile wood. Even if it is not juvenile wood, whatever it is is part of the problem in that it will dry more slowly than the rest simply because it is surrounded by the rest of the wood.
The idea of coating the end grain was to retard drying out the ends. The ends dry faster than the edges or face, because the wood is usually a bunch of fibers or straw like tubes and water readily escapes that way. Wanted to even out the moisture migration.
The Clorox and Timbor were trying to kill the sports and fungi to retard staining.
I think Keith is right about the kiln. This piece of wood is in no way like the other pieces that will be in the kiln and I'm fairly sure the kiln operator has little or no experience drying such things and is probably unwilling to adjust his schedule to suit yours, even if he knows what it should be. Might be time for a very gentle dehumidifier kiln.
Keith is also right about the mold growing under the piece of wood in to the carpet. BTDT
Bill, I just realized I have apparently made a mistake. Your original post had what I thought were two pictures, but it turns out there is only one log, both are .004jpegs. I thought your plan was to split them length wise and space the halve apart like some of your other pieces. Now that I see that the pieces are 62" long, Are you cutting them the other way, into two pieces about 30" long? But still in the round? In that case, The idea of boring out the center might be the best you can do and forget I mentioned splitting them lengthwise. (Still a good idea, but it might not fit the design.)
There is a lot to know to be able to dry 1" lumber successfully and it would take a book to describe in detail. Attempting to dry a log is impossibly more complicated and no matter how many paragraphs we write you will not gain the knowledge necessary to ensure success.
Indeed forget the kiln. Dried under optimum conditions to minimize the destruction that will occur when drying a maple long this big, I would estimate the task will take about 2 years. In a warm location with good air circulation you could get the logs dry in a year or less but the stresses, and hence destruction, would be greater. Put the logs in a kiln and the result will be tooth picks.
It seems to me to be the best bet would be to dry the logs somewhere for about a year and then build what ever it is you are contemplating, using construction that will accommodate further drying.
PS you can monitor the drying by weighing the log.
Yes, 2 30" logs to use as a base for a glass dining room table top.
From what I am reading it seems my best bet is to bore out the middle of both pieces best I can, remove as much heartwood as possible, then seal the ends and prop the logs up off my concrete workshop floor, say 2x4's turned on their sides and let them sit to dry.
I have certainly learned over the past few years the difficulty of drying wood. (10 years ago we had 30 acres of northern WI hardwood select cut and I saved aprox 1500 board feet which air dried in a shed) And I have had many challenges working with the large, end cut slabs I use to make tables, not the least of which was shrinkage after I had finished a few pieces that had expensive copper bubbling up under pressure. I wept.
All I can say is thanks to everyone who has commented. I now have a good idea of what to do to increase my chances of keeping this awesome log from splitting as it dries. If it does, I guess I'll just have to work with it.
Bill, I think the best thing would be to send the log to me and let me cut open those bulges and see if they are burls and have nice burly grain. Then I will make bowls out of it and send you one as payment. The turner in me is dieing to know whats in there.
Other than that, I think you are on the best track. Might consider getting a couple of tiny fans and putting them in the holes through the center to keep air moving, trying to shrink them to the inside.
Good luck, its a gorgeous piece of wood. and Like Bill Said, post a picture.
I have a guys with a local mill that could cut it into boards, but honesly I don't have the skillsets to make fine furniture like nost of you. I'm just a novice. I've thought about trying to sell the log, but don't really think I could get that much for it. Also, I like making big, weighty, solid pieces and this certainly fits that bill.
Bill, maybe somebody else here's a better eye for burls than I do and may have a good idea what the inside would look like, but short of that you should use it as you see fit. Burls have the bad habit of disappointing you when you open them. Some are rotten, some have little or no grain, but then some are spectacular. So, If you have a plan and like what you see don't take the chance.