Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT - Printer suggestions

Posts

OT - Printer suggestions

#1

OT - Printer suggestions

Joe Grittani

I don't like to rant but sometimes...

I had an Epson printer quit on me two years ago. I was told I had an ink problem so I bought color and black cartridges for $56 and guess what. It still didn't work and I was out another $56! I was tired of the high cost of ink and lack of dependability, so I went out and bought an HP Photosmart C4480 printer. Ink was reasonably priced and print quality was good, so I was happy. Today I started getting messages telling me I had "incompatible ink cartridge(s)" five minutes after I finished printing a document, although they're the same HP cartridges I've been printing with for months. I went to HPs Customer Support site and numerous people have had exactly the same issue with the same printer and get nothing but the run around from HP. None of the suggested fixes change anything. Still the same error message.

So I guess I'm looking for a new printer. I don't print a lot - mostly B&W text with an occasional color photo on plain paper (so I'm not looking for perfect photo reproduction). I'd like something reasonably priced, with ink I don't need a bank loan to replace, that's reliable. I don't print a ream of paper a year, so I'm a fairly light user.

I'd appreciate any suggestions anyone might have, although I'm beginning to suspect the printer of my dreams only exists in the same realm as unicorns and $20 Panther saws.

TIA.

Joe Grittani

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Moses Yoder

One thing about printers is that they are not made to last long. They are made to be cheap. The best quality Ink Jet printer I have found is Hewlett Packard but I don't expect it to last more than 2 years. If people are buying printers just because it's $2 cheaper, the managers are not going to try to make a good quality printer, it would be too expensive. If you only want black and white prints and a low cost per print get a Brother HL-5250DN laser printer. The laser printers last a little longer and cost less per copy but you will have big cash outlays for toner and drums when the drum goes bad.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#3

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Joe W Detroit, MI

I just purchased a Brother Color Laser Printer. I like it, but I don't think it is what you are looking for. Lexmark makes an inkjet printer the Pinnacle Pro 901 that advertises $5 black ink cartridges. I have never used one and don't know anybody who has, but if the advertising is right it may be worth looking at.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#4

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Terry in Edmonton

I have had Canon and HP printers in past. I am using a Kodak now and I like it. The photo quality is excellent, it prints fast and the ink is the cheapest on the market. I forget what I paid for it but I remember that it was inexpensive. Another bonus for me was that it handles card stock much better then any other printers I have used except my HP 5MP laser.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#5

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

The best thing I ever did was get rid of my crappy inkjet and buy a laser printer. The problem with inkjets is the heads get clogged with dry ink if you don't use it often. That and the ink is super expensive. I bought a Brother HL-2040 (less than $100 on sale at Best Buy) over 2 years ago and haven't had any problems at all. And I'm still using the original cartridge and toner. So, if you're like me and don't print a lot and don't really need color keep an eye out for the sales and get yourself a laser printer.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#6

Bart Goldberg

Printer Suggestions

Bart Goldberg

If you don't need to print in color, stick with a laser jet printer. Toner cartridges never go bad and can even be refilled cheaply. I have an HP 6P Laser printer I purchased in 1996 and its still going strong. I have had HP photo printers and unless you print often, the ink jets dry up, clog etc. and your out a significant amount of money. I trashed the last one I had, and now just print color to my local pharmacy when I need to make color prints.

Bart

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#7

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Paul Blackwell

I second the Kodak recommendation. I just bought a new Kodak ESP7250 all in one printer, copier, scanner. It has great quality, and the ink is half what I used to pay with my previous HP. It was on sale at Best Buy for a bit over $100.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#8

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

John McGaw

For reliability a laser cannot be beat (at least compared to any of the ink sprayers) but you've already been told that. I've got a 1993(?) HP LaserJet 4P and it still works perfectly but it is used mostly for long listings since it resides in the equipment closet downstairs. My main printer is a Dell color laser and it has had no problems in the years I've had it. But I've also got an Epson RX595 bought as a refurb and it has been trouble-free also. This is one of the high-end units which use six rather large ink tanks along with a fixed head. There has never been a single clog or failure in the years I've had it and I don't use it terribly often, mostly with photo paper. If there was going to be a drying/clogging problem I suspect it would have cropped up by now so it may be that some product grades are better than others at avoiding the problem. Downside is that the ink tanks are expensive and doing top quality prints on photo paper sucks up a lot of ink.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#9

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have gone through several brands and types. The HP does a good job but they have (expensive) patented ink jet cartridges with the spray head built into the cartridge. So you can't purchase generics cheap. I was using one of the better models of the Epson for photo's for about 3 years but the head finally clogged. A couple of years ago I found a Brother HL2170W wireless/usb laser mono-color printer for around $90 on sale and purchased it for the black and white printing - using the Epson for color. The Brother came with a "limited use toner cartridge installed" so I purchased a replacement for $40 with the printer. I replaced the original after about a year of normal (for me use). By far the cheapest way to print B&W. When the Epson quit working well, I purchased a Kodak ESP9200 series for $150. While the printer cartridges are more expensive than the generic ones, they are the cheapest of the brand name cartridges I have found. So far I have been well pleased with the unit (about 4 months old). I have a standalone scanner so haven't used any other feature of the printer but the printer, it includes printer, scanner, copier and fax. It can also be connected wireless or USB. I am using it as a wireless on the network and have it located near my wife's laptop station as she likes to print out photo's.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#10

Re: OT - Printer suggestions *LINK*

doug f, san clemente, ca

Joe - I bought a Brother MFC-495CW Inkjet about a year ago because I got sick of paying $95 for cartridges about every three months with my HP. I also got the generic ink cartridges in the link below.

The printer performs just like it's supposed to and also scans, faxes and and makes copies when I need to. Photo printing is not fast, but the quality is very good to excellent, at least in my opinion. I'm still working on the original order of ink cartridges and it's been almost a year.

I figure I'm at least $100 ahead of the HP and the hits just keep on coming!

Good luck with your choice.

Doug


http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002744YQS/ref=ox_ya_os_product

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#11

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Li9ke so many others...over the years I have had many different types and models of printers. Lately my two HP printers stopped working...think they just need a very good cleaning of the ink situations..dry and too much buildup at times. My other printer, HP4110 does not scan, copy or fax anymore, so I am buying a new printer at WalMart this next month...Canon 340 model...it does all of the needed things plus it is wi-fi so my daughter can also use it from her room....and the cost is so inexpensive.

As a side note.... I have bought the replacement inks at Staples to refill all of my HP cartridges over the years and it does save me a great deal of money. Can refill six times before buying some more ink. and they also have colors.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#12

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Easy answer: Buy a laser printer.the Brother mentioned above for +/- $100 is perfect.

I have an HP 1012 laser printer it was $25 on Craigslist ,$20 gets me a toner cartridge via Amazon.com. Have had the printer for over a year now and I still have the used toner cartridge that came with it.No more dry,fouled up ink cartridges for me.

As far as color printing or photos,Walgreens does an excellent job on photos FedEx kinkos or Staples can handle the rest.And it would take a looong time to equal the cost of ink.

i can upload photos to Walgreens website and usually pick them up in less than 30 mins.Much shorter time than trying to get the color printer to function properly.

Andy

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#13

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Wade Mackey

I just picked up the Epson Workforce 1100. I doubt if its any more or less reliable, But it prints 19x13 sheets of paper so I can have better shop drawings.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#14

Brother 2170W

iew

I'll second the 2170, I use the wireless feature and it is great. I have a wireless router and we can print from anywhere in the house from any computer.

I use a Epson R2400 for color and photo printing. Epson can't be beat on color printing.

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#15

We used to have exactly the same problem

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

We had an ink jet printer and had the same problem. We didn't print often enough to keep the ink jets clean. New cartridges didn't help. We printed mostly B&W so we didn't really need the color. I bought a Brother laser printer for $99 and it has worked flawlessly ever since (more than 3 years). Our first toner cartridge lasted almost 2 years. We purchased another toner cartridge and it is working fine as well. If we need something in color we take it to an office supply store and have them print what we need. It is cheaper than color cartridges.

Lee