Short answer?
David Barnett
They're wired differently.
Oversimplified, perhaps, but the right brain vs. left brain paradigm probably factors in.
Which is also part of the long answer.
Then there's focus. It's hard to think about turning without thinking about lathes. Turners are often carvers, pyrographers, and painters, too. Turning can be more about form, more about wood, both, and decoration. Carvers can be relief, sculptural, architectural, of course, and hand, power, both, and whether the wood, the figure, texture is a feature rather than a vehicle alone is another issue.
Either way, there's something 3D and spatial going on. I'm not saying that turning or carving are limited to that, just that their scope and centers of gravity are more defined. There are certainly left-brain elements; aesthetic decisions, procedural and planning dimensions. To me, though, turning and carving aren't woodworking in that overarching sense that woodworking is generally used.
Not that I'm saying, either, that so-called flat woodworkers are lacking in 3D visualization talents -- not at all -- but there's a long continuum and much of it constrained by function first, aesthetics second.
[I should probably say right here that I do turn, although rarely wood and mostly for mechanical elements, and carve in wood and other materials.]
Then there's the breadth of woodworking. It's nice that we can use woodworking to cover it all; from carpentry to carving to cabinetmaking to boat bulding, chairmaking to model ships, and so on. And that's just a lot of ground to cover.
There's a big difference in carving and turning clubs, too. They feel different, at least to me. Lapidary works this way, too, although many lapidary clubs are subsets of rock hound and amateur geology clubs.
Woodworking? Will period furniture aficionados really have that much in common with the scroll saw crowd? How long will that last? There are just too many factions, directions, levels of accomplishment, and interests in woodworking for the term to cohesively cover. Eventually one faction will predominate. If it's large and active enough it may survive, otherwise it will likely fizzle. At least that's been my experience, and especially so in smaller communities/localities. As for my few experiences in urban clubs, at least in the Northeast, you'd have thought woodworking was a competitive sport.
Am I a woodworking snob? That is, do I look down on certain types of woodworking and certain interests, tastes, proclivities? Maybe. Probably. I use both power and hand tools, so my snobbery lies elsewhere, more likely in design/aesthetics and choice of materials. There's also that rift between professional vs amateur vs hobbyist. I like to think of my attitudes euphemistically, as discriminating, but snobbery probably doesn't miss the mark by much. But mostly, though, I'm just not interested in those things -- not presently, anyway. Woodworking as the broader aegis of all occupations and crafts having wood as a commonality just doesn't do it for me.
My interests are personal, idiosyncratic, specialized, and I really couldn't care less to see tool demos in a woodworking store club or learn how someone else does whatever with whatever -- again, not presently. You're just not going to find me there. Fine for others. Just not me.
Where do I fit in? In the group sense? I will admit my interests and aesthetics are perhaps outliers to what most others here follow -- most not being terribly relevant -- but I still feel this is the best place for me to learn and contribute. I can't imagine a better woodworking club that WC.
Some of what keeps this forum going is our shared interests, diverse as they sometimes appear, but if you'll notice, there are other woodworking forums where the focus is more artsy-craftsy, say. Not a lot of birdhouses, woodworking by numbers, scroll saw patterns here. WC is not router dominated, power tool or hand tool dominated, and so on. There's definitely as WC culture, though, and it's a pretty amazing mix if you ask me.
None of what I just wrote may apply or make sense to anyone except me. I know there are some very healthy woodworking groups out there. So the longer answer to the original question, how I'd say it, anyway, is because turning is turning, carving is carving, and woodworking is too many things to fit in one basket.
You may disagree completely. It's just my take. My experience with woodworking clubs is limited, not only by the relative dearth of robust woodworking clubs where I now live, but I'm not exactly a social butterfly, much less a joiner, and not even much of an attender, when you get down to it. I am curious as to what others think and have experienced.