Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Why are there so few wood working clubs?

Posts

Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#1

Why are there so few wood working clubs?

Phil Joines

An earlier thread got me to thinking. Why are there so few wood working clubs?

I only know of one in the Dallas/Fort Worth area while there are 3 turning clubs with about 250 members all together. There are at least 3 carving clubs in the same area.

A friend started one in Fort Worth but he shut it down when most of the members only wanted to use his equipment to build kitchen cabinets and then drop out.

The existing club, North Texas Woodworkers Association, has been around since 1991. My wife and I used to attend the meetings until we moved too far away. As far as I know the only other clubs are part of some of the senior centers.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#2

Interesting Question

David Yoho

I've often wondered the same thing. Because of the local Woodcraft store, I know there is a local group of turners and a group of carvers that meet frequently but that's all there is. I've wished many times there was a local club where woodworkers like myself could get together and share ideas and information.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#3

David Barnett

Short answer?

David Barnett

They're wired differently.

Oversimplified, perhaps, but the right brain vs. left brain paradigm probably factors in.

Which is also part of the long answer.

Then there's focus. It's hard to think about turning without thinking about lathes. Turners are often carvers, pyrographers, and painters, too. Turning can be more about form, more about wood, both, and decoration. Carvers can be relief, sculptural, architectural, of course, and hand, power, both, and whether the wood, the figure, texture is a feature rather than a vehicle alone is another issue.

Either way, there's something 3D and spatial going on. I'm not saying that turning or carving are limited to that, just that their scope and centers of gravity are more defined. There are certainly left-brain elements; aesthetic decisions, procedural and planning dimensions. To me, though, turning and carving aren't woodworking in that overarching sense that woodworking is generally used.

Not that I'm saying, either, that so-called flat woodworkers are lacking in 3D visualization talents -- not at all -- but there's a long continuum and much of it constrained by function first, aesthetics second.

[I should probably say right here that I do turn, although rarely wood and mostly for mechanical elements, and carve in wood and other materials.]

Then there's the breadth of woodworking. It's nice that we can use woodworking to cover it all; from carpentry to carving to cabinetmaking to boat bulding, chairmaking to model ships, and so on. And that's just a lot of ground to cover.

There's a big difference in carving and turning clubs, too. They feel different, at least to me. Lapidary works this way, too, although many lapidary clubs are subsets of rock hound and amateur geology clubs.

Woodworking? Will period furniture aficionados really have that much in common with the scroll saw crowd? How long will that last? There are just too many factions, directions, levels of accomplishment, and interests in woodworking for the term to cohesively cover. Eventually one faction will predominate. If it's large and active enough it may survive, otherwise it will likely fizzle. At least that's been my experience, and especially so in smaller communities/localities. As for my few experiences in urban clubs, at least in the Northeast, you'd have thought woodworking was a competitive sport.

Am I a woodworking snob? That is, do I look down on certain types of woodworking and certain interests, tastes, proclivities? Maybe. Probably. I use both power and hand tools, so my snobbery lies elsewhere, more likely in design/aesthetics and choice of materials. There's also that rift between professional vs amateur vs hobbyist. I like to think of my attitudes euphemistically, as discriminating, but snobbery probably doesn't miss the mark by much. But mostly, though, I'm just not interested in those things -- not presently, anyway. Woodworking as the broader aegis of all occupations and crafts having wood as a commonality just doesn't do it for me.

My interests are personal, idiosyncratic, specialized, and I really couldn't care less to see tool demos in a woodworking store club or learn how someone else does whatever with whatever -- again, not presently. You're just not going to find me there. Fine for others. Just not me.

Where do I fit in? In the group sense? I will admit my interests and aesthetics are perhaps outliers to what most others here follow -- most not being terribly relevant -- but I still feel this is the best place for me to learn and contribute. I can't imagine a better woodworking club that WC.

Some of what keeps this forum going is our shared interests, diverse as they sometimes appear, but if you'll notice, there are other woodworking forums where the focus is more artsy-craftsy, say. Not a lot of birdhouses, woodworking by numbers, scroll saw patterns here. WC is not router dominated, power tool or hand tool dominated, and so on. There's definitely as WC culture, though, and it's a pretty amazing mix if you ask me.

None of what I just wrote may apply or make sense to anyone except me. I know there are some very healthy woodworking groups out there. So the longer answer to the original question, how I'd say it, anyway, is because turning is turning, carving is carving, and woodworking is too many things to fit in one basket.

You may disagree completely. It's just my take. My experience with woodworking clubs is limited, not only by the relative dearth of robust woodworking clubs where I now live, but I'm not exactly a social butterfly, much less a joiner, and not even much of an attender, when you get down to it. I am curious as to what others think and have experienced.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#4

McKinneyMike

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

McKinneyMike

Hi Phil,

Judging from the forum traffic on all of the forums that I frequent, I would say that woodworking has hit a lull overall as compared to say just 5 years ago.

I have to say that the economy has a great deal to do with this too. People just don't have the disposable income that they used to have to support hobbies. I might be wrong, but I do feel that this is part of it.

Then here in the Dallas/Ft. Worth Metroplex we have far fewer woodworkers than say the Midwest or Eastern cities. Why? I am not sure if it is the lack of forestry or just a regional thing.

Some areas of the US have strong woodworking clubs, like the one in Kansas City, MO. I am familiar with the that one and it has always been strong.

Really good question and one that has puzzled me too.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#5

lack of leaders

Bill Tindall

The success, or even existence, of a club depends on a succession of leaders with the skills and commitment to keep the club going. I think the turners are helped by the existence of a national organization that can provide some of the leadership. Ditto SAPFM.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#6

Cat herding

wilbur

I think that the main obstacle that woodworking clubs face is that you're trying to form an organization with a membership of people who are by nature somewhat solitary and, um, frugal. ;)

Plus you have the issue of any voluntary organization where a small number of people are doing the majority of the work, unless your woodworking club has a paid staff, and I don't know of any woodworking club where that is the case.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#7

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

David C. Lykins - Dallas GA

Metro Atlanta has both "Turner's Club" and a general "Wood Working Club/Guild". I was in the "Wood Workers Guild of Georgia" for about a year or so. As many of you know, my MAIN focus in the beginning was learning to build guitars, i.e. Lutherie. Well needless to say there was only one person that I met in the Guild that had even attempted to build a guitar, so that was somewhat dissapointing but I remained in the club and payed my dues as I knew, just like WC, the people here would have a WEALTH of knowledge and I could probably learn something from each of them.

But what I've seen, is that some wood working is somewhat "Specific" therefore hardcore turners aren't really thrilled with a guy that build high end cabinets, and a cabinet/furniture guy could care less about learning something about Lutherie. Other's that I've stayed in touch with that dropped out indicated that they "Just don't have the time" for it any longer. And for some, driving 30+ miles in Metro Atlanta's traffic become enough of a challenge when you're trying to get to a meeting.

JMHO.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#8

"Wood Working" is so vast.....

Barry Irby

I am a member of a turning club and the topics there are pretty varied. Bowls, spindles, hollow forms, plain, decorated, segmented, carved, and on and on. Wood working would be even more varied. A person interested in building a Philadelphia Highboy is not going to attend a session on building yard furniture. Someone interested in building kitchen cabinets will get little for a session on building a guitar. Someone has got to organize and run the club and we all know that most clubs have about 10 percent of the people that do 90 percent of the work.

And then there is the risk and expense. who is going to provide the equipment and cover the cost of the insurance?

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#9

The "E" word . . .

steve mackay

SWMBO and I have a running joke that has, sadly, become the reasonable explanation for most things now a days. The "E" word. Effort. Why would I put out effort if it isn't neccessary ? Pepole go from the bed to the car, car to work (we hope), work to car, car to Boob Tube. Thats their life. Going to a meeting would take effort they don't HAVE to expend. Making something they can pick up a Wally World for cheap would take effort. It extends WAY beyond woodworking. Keeping up their property would take effort. Gardening, parenting, learning, trying, failing, succeding, pride in work (if they do). All these take a small level of comitment, a sense to purpose and, yes, the "E" Word.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

Clint Searl

The two clubs I looked at were mostly populated by old farts (not that I'm not one myself) that seemed to fill their meetings with presentations on how to sharpen a chisel or the virtues of a tail vise. I would rather see recent examples of member work and discuss design issues than watch Ian Kirby chop a dovetail. I may not be representative, buy in my case neither club offered anything of interest to make me want to come back.

Clint

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#11

Ours didn't last long.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I joined one that was just forming. I realized that the club only had a couple of skilled guys. The rest broke down like this:

- Old guys who "knew everything"

- Uninspired birdhouse makers.

- Guys who came to get free lessons and stuff.

- a couple of shifty guys who sat in the back and seemed to be doing some sort of reconasance (made me nervous)

There were plenty of well intended folks there who went out of their way to tell me what I should be doing istead of what I was doing.

It wasn't long before I realized that I could be there or I could actually be in my workshop doing something. The choice was clear.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#12

Re: Ours didn't last long.

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

We have two woodworking guilds in the greater Seattle area. I am a founding member of the about one hundred member strong Evergreen Woodworkers Guild (www.ewwg.org) and the current Programs Chair. We have had to draft and coerce folks into taking leadership positions. Elections are coming up and I don't know if we have any candidates. I am supposed to find my own replacement. So, leadership and a succession of leadership is an issue. From professional experience, I don't believe this is any different for almost any volunteer board though.

Another problem for our meetings is finding presenters of interest. We just had John Economaki, founder of Bridge City Tools, present earlier this month. As Program Chair it is difficult, if not impossible, to find presenters who would be of interest to the majority of our members due to the diversity of interests. I try to get a nice mix of presenters from outside our Guild membership. I would like to say household names but, was reminded recently that they are all dead.

As was already mentioned, at 61 years of age I feel like the new kid on the block at meetings. I see this trend in turning and carving clubs as well. We need younger and more energetic members or, at least those with more stamina. After a full day at work, even I have been known to doze off at club meetings.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#13

I think this is the best woodworking club there is

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

I for one am not much of a club joiner. I belong to one horse association / club. Mainly so I can show ocassionally (showing creates goals, goals promote higher skill levels). Otherwise WC is as close to joining a club as it comes for me and frankly I can't think of a better club to belong to.

Thank you Ellis

glc

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#14

Clint Searl

Well put, Gary!

Clint Searl

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#15

Clint Searl

Re: Ours didn't last long.

Clint Searl

Perhaps as Program Chair you might think about pulling a member's name out of a hat to assign the program to for the next meeting. Any topic for any length of time, but delivered by the assignee. Might be worth a few yuks.

My point is that without real participation by the individual members, a club only serves to boost the egos of a few and make a few Xmas toys or birdhouses. :b

Clint

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#16

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

Dave Paine

Good question, although this may not be specific to Woodworking.

My first reaction was to think of the Groucho Marks quote "I would not belong to any club which would have me as a member". This may not be an accurate quote, but you will understand the meaning.

Back in the mid 80's I purchased my first PC. I went to a local PC club, attended a few meetings, and quickly outgrew what the club had to offer. My questions could not be answered, and I had to go elsewhere to find the solutions to my problems.

These days with the internet, I am typically able to find some answers to my Woodworking questions either via reading this forum, which is very useful, or by Google searches, and the associated links,

Even if a local club were available, I am not sure I would expend the "effort" (as stated in another reply) to attend.

Attending a club would need to provide me with something I am not able to get in my internet searches. Examples would be meeting people and getting to know them. This would be beneficial, but to be honest, when I am trying to solve a problem, it is the last thing on my mind.

Re: Why are there so few wood working clubs?

#17

One thing

Dan Donaldson

About WC as a "club" is that there are enough people that frequent the boards that it is much easier to find at least someone else interested in the same things that you are. I would feel safe in guessing that the readership of WC is much greater than the membership at most regular clubs. The sheer numbers can help keep things interesting for Woodworkers of almost any particular bent.

This is not to mention the fact that the people here are from all over the world with many differing perspectives that can create a lot of creative energy and a tremendous amount of unique knowledge. Very seldom is a question on almost anything here not answered in at least some fashion.