Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

How Would You?

Posts

How Would You?

#1

How Would You?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Working on the leg-sets for Memsahib's slab coffee table. Legs are based on Shinto Tosi gates


The legs are beveled on all four sides,

and I have to join them with the cross pieces which are, in turn, tied together with a center board.

Top piece goes the fill thickness of the leg while the bottom one does not

Would you use a bridle joint, router dado, on the legs to accept the flats?

Re: How Would You?

#2

Not A Trick Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The pictures show the "sketch" of the horizontal elements that were merely notched and slipped onto the taper leg posts. My question is how to make the actual joints.

Would you cut dadoes into the legs and then cut smaller notches in the cross-pieces? Would you do something else? I know that these will be end grain joints so it's most important that the joint itself, exclusive of any glue, be as strong as possible.

The side taper is 3� [93�] and the front is a hair more than 2� off of vertical [92.1�]. The joints will be structural because they will control and stabilize the legs that will be holding up the 90lb. slab of walnut.

Friend looked at the mock up today and said "You really love the angled stuff, don't you? I do shaker because everything's at a nice neat 90� to most everything else."

Re: How Would You?

#3

Re: Not A Trick Question

Pat Evans

Far be it from me to recommend anything to an expert, but since you asked... I'd cut dadoes (blind dadoes for the lower cross pieces) into the legs before tapering them. I'd probably make the inside edge dado deeper for more support and the others very shallow. Notch the cross pieces. I don't think expansion of the leg would be a problem, but just in case, you could leave some room at the bottom of the dado on the outer edges of the leg. No real support there anyway.

Re: How Would You?

#4

I attended a router class a few years ago

Ray Thompson - Middletown, in

with Marc Adams and that is one of the joints he demonstrated, just as you describe. He also showed several jigs to facilitate the operation. Sure wish I could find those notes and sketches I made that weekend.

Ray

Re: How Would You?

#5

Painted Myself Into The Corner

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As all 4 of the legs are finished short of sanding and they were the last of the 13/4 stock I had.

Looking like I've got some hefty jig engineering and making in the near future.

I'm thinking about a dado for the smaller (bottom) horizontal and then actually cutting the top section free like a cap so that the upper horizontal piece will remain solid (no short grain to break off). Problem with this will be that the grain in the leg will be interrupted on the 4th side, and it'll be dicey to maintain the flow in the tapered sides and corner lines. Some very precise cutting following that route.

Shame on me in that I was so concentrated on working out the design that I didn't give proper consideration on how I'm going to have to build this beast. Originally I was going to do through M&T with the horizontal pieces passing through the legs. The design committee nixed the idea as too heavy looking.

Thanks for the input. This will take some time to figger. ;)

Re: How Would You?

#6

Re: I attended a router class a few years ago

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'd REALLY like to see how he/you did it. :)

Re: How Would You?

#7

Re: Painted Myself Into The Corner

Bruce, a MN Galoot

If I were in your shoes, and I haven't had that particular pair on lately, but close, I'd take a look at how Sam Maloof did the leg joint on his rocking chair. I think there's an article on it in an old FWW.

Re: How Would You?

#8

Re: I attended a router class a few years ago

Ray Thompson - Middletown, IN

I'm covered up today but I will try to draw it out this evening and send it to you. As I recall he called it the joint Maloof used on chairs.

Ray

Re: How Would You?

#9

Do you still have the offcuts from the taper?

John in NM

If so you can use them as wedges in a dado jig to re-create the untapered stock. Even without, I guess it would be easy enough to create a similar wedge, tack it to a ts sled and cut your dados. Might want to use a router though, that kind of un-supported cut is going to have hellish tearout (part of the reason this is typically done before the taper).

At this point, I'd probably use a handsaw and chisel were it my problem to solve. Easier to sneak up on the fit, and I always seem to find some catastrophic conceptual error when making jigs to use with routers. :D

Re: How Would You?

#10

Re: Do you still have the offcuts?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Actually I do, but they are too small; tapers were made with a sled on the planer since the total taken off each face was "0" to a bit less than 1/2" so the wood removed is still sitting in the DC bag. :D

I do, however, have the sled (to add to my ever-growing collection) with the actual spacers used, so I can precisely duplicate the tapers. If I have to, I can make the pieces needed to return the legs to "square" blocks in order to make dado cuts, but that's going to be a lot of time and more wood "up the pipe".

Big issue is going to be the fragility of the short projections to the outside of each leg. When I was going to do them as through tenons, it wasn't an issue because the horizontals would be intact; very different play, now.

Thanks for the input. This kitty's still got all her fur. ;)

Re: How Would You?

#11

Looked

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

But since I don't subscribe (anymore) I can't pull up a back issue. I have seen the joint you're talking about, and I think I've seen a picture of it posted here, but couldn't find it. I'll try a search later. Thanks

Re: How Would You?

#12

Re: How Would You?

paul in AZ

I have been following this thread not because I am likely to ever try it but because the concept baffles me.

Seeing as Maloof was mentioned, a search for 'maloof chair joint' came up with a couple of places with photos that may be relevant.

dunno if this will help but here they are.

One is on a site called "Canadian woodworks" and this is another.

http://thecraftsmanspath.com/2009/03/08/sculpted-rocking-chair-seat-joinery/

Re: How Would You?

#13

Re: Looked

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'll go take a look. If I find it, I'll scan it and email it.

Re: How Would You?

#14

Thanks, Paul

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've bookmarked your link. The join I have to do is not "sculpted", but the "U" tenon is what I was considering while trying to figure how to "house" the horizontal piece in the joint. I'd still have the issue of the fragile short projections on the outside staring at me.

Got some compromising to do, I'm afraid. Galls, because the phrase "you can't get there from here" usually sets me off looking to prove it wrong, but I've only very rarely been successful with it being always not worth the effort.

Re: How Would You?

#15

Before You Dodat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Check Paul's post below. The link in his message covers the Maloof joint pretty well. Thanks for the effort!!

M

Re: How Would You?

#16

Ellis Walentine

A variation I'd suggest

Ellis Walentine

The Maloof U-joint isn't generally subject to the same design constraints as your table rail situation. By that I mean that there is plenty of wood on either side of the joint so that short grain will not be an issue. In your case, you want to maximize the integrity of that lonely piece of short-grain material at the outboard end of each rail. Also, you don't need the double overlaps of the Maloof joint, because barefaced joints will look just fine, with the full thickness of the rails set into the leg housings.

Here's a suggestion for how you might want to cut the notches in your rails to minimize the amount of endgrain on the rails and to maximize the integrity of the legs.


The trick, of course will be to rout those dados, but it shouldn't be too difficult. All you need is a tapered reference surface for the router base, with a strip of wood tacked on as a fence that you can ride the edge of the router base against. If you want, you can even set the bit into the reference surface in such a way that you can read your top and bottom cut lines directly on the jig. Something like this...


Ellis

Re: How Would You?

#17

WOW - THANKS!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

An elegant approach and one of us may just be psychic!

In working through my options last night I had about decided to do a combination of a stacked leg for the top crossbar [cut the 2" cap free, use the straight crossbar, then glue back with dowels], and then use a dado for the smaller bar with a hidden angled notch to leave more meat to support those end pieces just as you've drawn them.

My plan called for me to cut the face dado on the table saw and then hand-cut the inboard and outboard stopped dadoes by hand and chisel. You router sled looks to be a more precise method so now I've got more thinking to do.

Thanks Again, Boss. :D