Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

Posts

Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#1

Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

jsheaney

I made a hall table out of wenge and cherry and delivered it just over a year ago. (Please see the link below.) It has been through all of the seasons here in Rhode Island. It sits indoors, of course, and doesn't get a great deal of direct sunlight. There's no air conditioning in the house, so there is no protection from the seasonal humidity changes.

The table top is connected to the base with sliding dovetails, which seem to be doing a good job. The dovetails poke out and withdraw as the seasons change.

The problem is that the table is splitting at one end. In the picture, you should be able to make out a pattern of hairline cracks that kind of look like shattered safety glass. Some of them have penetrated the top, which I think you can make out, as well. Most of the cracks in the finish are fractions of an inch, but there are many. One or two might be an inch long.

I describe the finishing I did in some detail on the project page, but it's basically a couple of coats of Bush Oil (an oil/varnish blend). On the top, I filled the pores and then put a few coats of poly and then rubbed it out.

Does anyone have an idea of what went wrong? I suspect the wood wasn't dried properly or maybe I didn't cut enough waste off the end. It seems like a really weird pattern of checking, though.

Is there anything I can do about it? I've had suggestions of retrofitting the ends with breadboards. I don't think it needs breadboarding for stability because the sliding dovetails seem to be doing that job. I think the idea is more to just cover up the splits. It seems to me that the assumption in that repair is that the splitting won't progress any further. How long should I wait?

I don't know if there is some way to seal the endgrain. I'm concerned about doing anything that will add any material into the splits. I would imagine that any material would ultimately just act like a wedge and lengthen the splits.

I don't really know what to do at this point. Any suggestions are welcomed.


img

Hall table project

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#2

McKinneyMike

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting

McKinneyMike

Are both ends of the top affected equally? Is one end more exposed to changes in environment changes more than the other (close an outside doorway)?

If it is only one end of the top, i would say that it probably stems from drying issues and not trimming off the end of the board prior to making the top. The first two or three inches of either end of a board can have unseen defects from being dried. It is difficult to lop off seemingly good lumber, but I try to remove at least three inches from the ends of lumber, especially if it is used for a top like this, as I am always paranoid about this type of issues showing up later.

If both ends are doing this same thing then it well could be that there was a moisture issue in that the lumber was not as dry as it should have been and you are seeing issues from this movement.

What a tough deal. Beautiful design and execution. I might steal the basic design for a hall table that I have been considering.

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#3

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting

Charles in Mtl.

what if you flood the cracks with cyanoacrylate glue and clamp across the top until dry? The cracks will wick in the glue, probably, and when dry will stabilize them. Even rolls royce, when making the wooden inlays for the dashboard, use crazy glue to repair small crack and defects.

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#4

Unfortunate situation

Bill Tindall

If it is only on one end of one board it looks to me like a classic case of not trimming enough from the end of lumber that already had cracks developed.

When logs sit around before sawing the ends check from shrinkage. If even the slightest amount of these cracks are not trimmed off they will continue to propagate over time. Ditto for any checks that develop in the ends of boards during drying.

If these cracks are showing up on both end of the board then "wind shake" is the problem.

The bottom line is that some tiny amount of cracks were there to begin with and over time as the board shrank and swelled they propagated, as they always do. I have a the top of a chair post suffering the same problem. You might try wicking thin cyanoacrylate glue into them in the hope that the glue will keep the end of the cracks from separating and propagating more. It can work but doesn't always.

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#5

Wenge *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Is not my favorite wood to work, I'm always forgetting where I left my Kevlar gloves the last time. End-checks or just mean stuff, this is the very reason I'll only use it if it's "enclosed" by other wood in the piece, and at $18-20 a board foot, I'd be pissed if the guy I bought it from blythely told me to whack off 4" from the board ends as waste. In fact, I'd tell him, "You do that and then I'll pay just for what I take."

As your nice design and very nice execution will not sit well for recutting the top, and breadboarding would by very much out of style, I suggest you "fly" the top with a pair of wings. You can make them out of cherry to maintain the blend of woods, and you can make them either long grain (like your supports) or in end grain orientation (to move with the top) depending on taste. You will, either way, have to cut a tenon on each end of the top for the joint, but not as much as for a breadboard.

Link is to a Nakashima design page to give you an idea of how it's done.

Good Luck


Wings

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#6

Re: Unfortunate situation

jsheaney

All of the wenge for this table came from one 8/4 8' long plank. The top was half of that, resawed and bookmatched. So, one end of the table was close to the end of the board and one end was close to the middle. And one end is splitting and the other isn't. Actually, there might a couple of hairline cracks on the other end, but nothing that has penetrated the top. There's a huge difference between the two ends.

I guess I just didn't cut enough waste off the end. Judging by the hairline cracks that are showing up now, I can imagine that I didn't see it before. Normally, I cut off the end of a board and then check the integrity of the cutoff. I didn't have the experience to know that wood could check like this.

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#7

How to discover tiny end checks beforehand

Bill Tindall

Sometimes it is important to coax as much out of a board as possible which means trimming as little as possible from an end. Application of some low viscosity solvent-acetone, ethanol or mineral spirits- to the end will reveal any hidden cracks. The solvent will wick up a crack to its very end and show up as a dark line.

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Unfortunate situation

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like you've narrowed down the cause. As far as fixing the situation, I like the idea of wicking some CA or thin epoxy into the endgrain to fill it and arrest the checking. Then sand it smooth and recoat with your finish. This kind of repair doesn't come with a lifetime guarantee, but it will restore the table to its original beauty, and, now that the table has had a chance to go through a few seasonal cycles, any further movement is likely to be miniscule and nearly unnoticeable.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#9

Re: How to discover tiny end checks beforehand

jsheaney

Hey, that's an awesome tip. Thanks!

Re: Problem with wenge table top splitting *LINK*

#10

Re: Unfortunate situation

jsheaney

Actually, it's only gone through one complete cycle. Here's how I understand it, please correct me if I'm wrong.

I delivered the table in March last year. That's the end of the winter here and is the driest season. In fact, the table is kind of a hydrometer. The dovetails were a bit proud of the table top edges. The summer is the most humid season around here and, indeed, the top expanded and the dovetails became shy. In my project pages, I documented this with pictures. I was very happy about it because it showed that the design was working.

Here we are at the end of winter again, the wood has shrunk and the cracks have opened up a tiny amount, which has cracked the poly on top. My guess is that the cracks will tend to close up again in the summer when the wood expands and open up again next winter. Of course, the damage to the finish is already done.

Now, when I think about putting CA glue into the cracks, I can't help but wonder if the CA material that wicks up into the cracks will act as a wedge when the summer comes and expands the wood. If that happened then the cracks might get longer than they would otherwise.

Would it make sense to wait until summer before fixing the top? That would minimize the gaps, minimize the amount of glue taken up and, hopefully, the glue would hold the cracks closed when the wood shrinks. Is there a best time for me to make this fix?