Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

How dry is dry enough?

Posts

How dry is dry enough?

#1

How dry is dry enough?

Randy Stukenberg

I recently purchased some red oak lumber that was kiln dried several years ago, then stored in a garage. The moisture tests at 8%. Is that dry enough to use? Or should it be closer to 6%?

Thanks!

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#2

Re: How dry is dry enough?

del schisler

It is dry enough it will go back to the moister around where the product is used. Somewhere 10% or more. Wood will loose and gain moister. That is why when you build some item's that have drop in panel's that you leve some space for movement. I belive oak will never quit moving and maybe some other wood's. I been around wood for 60 yr's now. Of course i don't know all my 2 cents

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#3

Re: How dry It Am

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Depenz ;)

You can dry lumber to 0% if you wish, but it will not stay there; its will pull moisture from the air until it reaches EMC "Equalized Moisture Content" for the environment in which it's placed.

In the high desert of Arizona or California, that might be 4%. In my house here in New Jersey it's an average 10%, 9-11% depending on the season.

What you need to know is not merely its moisture content, but rather if it's reached EMC and is thus stable. You find that out by measuring the moisture content of wood you've had in your shop for a while, or, even better, any exposed framing lumber in your house (like floor joists) because, regardless of the type of wood, EMC will be the same for everything in the same location.

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#4

Re: How dry is dry enough?

Dennis E Peacock

Randy,

That's plenty dry enough. Your wood is going to be whatever moisture level is in your shop. With wood like Oak, you should build with wood movement in mind. I have an Oak kitchen table I built with breadboard ends. The top of the table moves a total of 1/8" from season to season. In the winter, the breadboard ends are longer than the table is wide. In the summer, the breadboard ends are shorter than the table is wide. I built it with the idea that it would move almost 1/4" in normal seasonal movement. Red Oak and White Oak are both bad about moving, but as long as you build with that in mind? It's perfectly fine to build with now. ;)

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#5

It is right on target

Bill Tindall

The furniture industry standard for drying is 7% so you are within measurement error of this target.

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#6

Re: How dry is dry enough?

FredD

My shop environment keeps KD lumber down to 6 % or slightly less which is perfect for what I do and where the projects live.

That being said , if your wood is dry to the point that the direction of movement is expansion and you design with that in mind , your lumber is dry enough and if kept in your shop for awhile will go down even more.

That is far better then having wet wood shrink and ruin the glue joints as it dries out in the home.

FredD

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#7

Re: How dry is dry enough?

Randy Stukenberg

Thanks everyone. That's what I was thinking. Somewhere in the bak of my mind, I was thinking that it needed to be kiln dried to 6% to be more or less "stable." I know it will shrink and swell, but I thought it was less of a problem if it was kiln dried to 6%.

-Randy

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#8

Re: How dry is dry enough?

Rick Christopherson

It's amazing how many woodworkers stand behind wood stored outdoors/garage as being dry enough, yet the second most common question after that is why projects crack and warp when completed.

Contrary to the popular misconception, finished projects do not undergo significant seasonal changes inside climate controlled homes. They undergo a single change when the project is completed, but this initial drying is automatically attributed to seasonal changes. Unless you live in areas without climate controlled homes (windows open year-round), those seasonal changes are far more trivial than most woodworkers believe.

Wood is far more stable when it gains moisture than when it loses moisture. It has greater compressive strength than tensile strength. A crossgrain joint is more likely to survive a gain of 2% MC than it is to lose 2% MC.

Aside from outdoor furniture, when is the last time you read an internet discussion about a finished project failing due to expansion as opposed to contraction? Most of the discussions you read about telling you to "plan for seasonal change" are actually dealing with the initial MC change associated from moving a project from the common garage workshop into a climate controlled home.

If your workshop is in your garage, the best thing you can do is let the temperature in the garage get warmer that the outside air temperature. A kiln doesn't have to be high-temperature. It just has to be above the ambient outdoor temperature. Your garage can actually make a great low temperature kiln.

Re: How dry is dry enough?

#9

Perhaps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You put too much faith in "climate control", Rick. My home here in New Jersey is heated (with humidification) in the winter and cooled in the summer when 2 50-pint dehumidifiers have to be emptied twice daily in addition to what the A/C unit removes. The net atmospheric humidity in the space ranges from 35% in the winter to more than 65% in the summer, and my wood will change from about 9% to 11% MC during the year. My solid wood furniture is thus constantly moving across a range, depending on the species, of as much as a bit more than a 1/8". I made the mistake of discounting that movement with KD ash and wound up doing substantial repair work on some tables. BTW, air-dried or kiln-dried has made very little difference in my location.

I therefore meter my stock when selecting boards to use to make sure they've reached EMC for my space. I can then predict, quite accurately, how much I should allow for seasonal changes in joinery.