Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Question on strength of this assembly

Posts

Question on strength of this assembly

#1

Question on strength of this assembly

Stephen Kirk

The picture shows a really rough view of how I want to assemble the side frames for a chair. I want to use Kreg joinery for this as I have some clients who would rather control cost than add complex and time consuming joinery. This drawing is certainly not to scale, but if I put a Kreg joint at the circles (and I didn't draw them all), would this prove strong enough to keep a chair together? My quick tests seem like it is strong. Obviously, I would have a rail across these which the seat is attached to.

I plan to do a lot of scribed joints, as the job calls for a fluid, free form look. The Kreg makes this easy to assemble. The extra lines are just some artifacts in the drawing, they wouldn't exist on the real thing.

Let me know if my drawing is clear enough, I can provide more details.


Re: Question on strength of this assembly

#2

Doubt It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Pocket hole joints work great for face frames and table aprons, by the tortional stresses on chair legs will be, I think, a very different story. On top of which, that'll take a s-load of screws! In the time it takes you to do all the positioning, screwing, etc. I would have the M&T joints with real strength, made, glued, and pegged.

As an aside, with your stretchers notched into the legs, you'd get way more strength running 2 screws in from the outside, through the legs, into the endgrain of the stretcher, and then into cross-bored dowels 3/4" or so in from the stretcher ends.

As far as the slats go, route a grove in the top and bottom of the stretchers and glue and brad them in place. You can then fill the spaces with some short pieces. IKEA's making zillions this way ;)

Re: Question on strength of this assembly

#3

Re: Doubt It

FredD

I would agree with Mark 100 %, it sound as though your letting your client's parsimony dictate the construction process and you can bet when the pocket screws let go , you will be the first to hear about it.

FredD

Re: Question on strength of this assembly

#4

Re: Doubt It

Stephen Kirk

Yeah, I'm still going to do a more or less screwed together chair, but I'll opt for overlapping the rails on the legs and going through the side. That is much stronger.

I'm getting to indulge my artistic side on this one. I have some nice figured maple and cherry. The goal is to finish without straight edges. So, I'll start square to layout my joinery, then curve everything around that. I'm used to neat, clean lines - so this is something new for me. Fun, though.

Re: Question on strength of this assembly

#5

Re: Question on strength of this assembly

Jesse Cloud

If you really want to use screws, do what Maloof did. Clamp the rail between the legs, bore a few holes through the legs and into the rail. Screw and plug. That's how the crest rails are attached in his rockers.

Re: Question on strength of this assembly

#6

No

AZ in Colorado Springs

I've made a bunch of stools. It's a simple design. The legs are made two at a time, from solid stock. The two pairs of legs have opposing notches, so they slide together, to make four legs set 90 degrees from each other. Four screws thru the seat, and they're rock solid.

I made one with an octagonal seat, painted like a stop sign. I used pocket screws to secure the legs from below. It lasted about one week.