Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT Newbe welding

Posts

OT Newbe welding

#1

OT Newbe welding

Jerry Gibbs

I want to do some general welding. Repairs, small fabrication. No exotics such as aluminum. Any suggestions welcome. Especially welcome discussion of arc vs mig ect. I have 220v 50amp available. This is in the toy catagory as it does not make economic sense. Jerry

Re: OT Newbe welding

#2

MIG is fairly easy...

John in NM

I think it worth getting the gas kit instead of depending on flux core wire. Only thing I like the flux core for is outdoor work. MIGs are kind of the hot glue gun of welders.

Last year I bought a DC TIG, though I've yet to use it much. TIG's will also do stick welding, but only worth it if you need the TIG capability (basically for fussy tidy little welds :D )

Arc is probably going to be the cheapest way to get into it, but I found it harder to learn than MIG. For hobby work, I don't think arc would have any advantage except for relative cheapness. But there are plenty of guys around here who know more about it than do I.

For cheap it's hard to beat Everlast. They're Chinese, but have lots of features and a good warranty. I'd stay away from Harbor Fill myself, but that's just me. If you can afford a Miller or Hobart, they both make great equipment (both owned by Illinois Tool Works). You may be able to find a good deal on a used machine if you're patient.

Re: OT Newbe welding

#3

Rick L

Re: Oxy/acetylene

Rick L

Oxy/acetylene is the most versatile. You can weld, bend metal, cut, silver braze, loosen rusted bolts. The ultimate electric welding is TIG and if you can't gas weld you can't TIG. Arc is harder to learn and MIG with gas is better than flux wire. You should find a class first before you commit to one, but I'd never give up my oxy/acetylene torch set. Nothing comes close...

Re: OT Newbe welding

#4

craigd

Re: OT Newbe welding

craigd

OA is handy but slow and being able to braze is nice. I have both OA & TIG (inverter) and much prefer to TIG rather than OA. You can also TIG braze with silicon bronze filler. I don't MIG, I hate the look and splatter of the welds but it is quick. If you have the bucks, check out the little "lunch box" DC TIG welders, they run on 115/220, pump out 150 amps and weigh 14#. They are also about 4x the cost of a OA unit (eg Miller Maxstar: http://www.millerwelds.com/products/tig/product.php?model=M00143).

With your 50 amp circuit, you can probably find an huge old transformer AC/DC TIG pretty cheap, the Miller Syncowaves are nice but you could probably only get 150 amps out (the 350 'waves needed a 100 amp circuit and wieghed 600#).

Remember that the Argon tank + regulator is an required "extra cost option".

Re: OT Newbe welding

#5

Re: OT Newbe welding

Bill Howatt

TIG is the most versatile but it is also costly and there is a learning curve before you get good at everything it will do and based on your description if probably is overkill - it is unlikely you will want to cut in two an aluminum pop can and then weld it back together.

Arc (stick) requires a lot of practice but is probably the cheapest to get going with. Used machines are not hard to find and there isn't much to go wrong with them. The simplest ones are just a big transformer with a current limiting core arrangement. A major problem with stick is that when you get material much under an 1/8" thick it requires more skill so you don't blow holes in the work.

MIG is good for thinner work and is probably the easiest to learn. A problem with MIG is that you can lay down a very nice looking bead that has little penetration (strength). I would avoid buying the cheapest machines and if you want a good range of materials handling get a 240V input machine.

OA is handy and provides a heating benefit for bending etc and it is easiest to use if brazing is desired. It is essential you check out in your area the cost of gas and possible tank rentals. You may find the cost high if you are just using it infrequently. It is also an issue but a lesser one for TIG and MIG if you are using a cover gas.

Bill

Re: OT Newbe welding

#6

Rick L

Re: More info required...

Rick L

I get the impression you don't want to spend a lot as it's a toy not a real tool.

What exactly do you see your needs as? Thickness of steel and just the occasional use like once a month? For 1/4" average oxy/acetylene is the way to go. Stick is the cheapest and messy and harder to learn and mig is certainly the easiest with argon gas. Flux Wire is messy.

Did you know you can do a simple modification to a stick welder and make it a basic scratch start TIG by adding a few things such as the gas tank, regulator, TIG torch and special adapter fitting. Couple of hundred bucks.

Don't confuse silver brazing with regular brazing. We use silver bazing for making custom hardware from brass.

If you have no experience with joining metal I STRONGLY recommend you take a class somewhere. It starts with simple soldering and goes to Oxy/acetylene, Stick, MIG, TIG. To make a choice over a couple of recommendations on a wood forum is just plain silly.

Economically you can't beat O/A and it's cordless so you can free a rusted bolt or repair that chain link fence bracket in the back yard. I have a MIG and O/A at home and access to larger Stick and TIG. My O/A costs a few hundred bucks plus leasing the tanks. I have full size tanks but when empty next time I'm getting the smaller ones as they are more portable and can get them filled a fw miles away.

O/A , MIG and TIG will require tanks and often it's best to lease instead of own as testing of the tanks is required every so many years so do the research to determine what's best for you.

Re: OT Newbe welding

#7

Re: OT Newbe welding

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have an oxygen/acetylene torch setup, an AC stick welder and a small MIG (115 amp) with shielding gas. I have also welded with a friends TIG (about a $3000 to $5000 unit) They all have their advantages and disadvantages. The OA is great for braising, cutting and light welding. The OA unit is quite versatile, the easiest unit to cut and heat with, allowing you to remove stuck bolts etc. Welding with OA is trickier than with MIG but a little easier than stick IMHO). Stick welding is probably the cheapest to set up but the hardest to learn, it is very difficult to do thin material (1/16 or under) with a conventional AC stick welder. On the other hand it is quick and fairly easy to weld thick materials with the stick after learning. Stick welders can also be AC and DC, these units are quite a bit more expensive but also easier to use and more versatile. The MIG is the easiest unit to use and learn in my opinion. A small unit such as I have is relatively inexpensive - I think I spent about around $200 to 250 for the welder (on sale at Tractor supply). and another $80 or so for the shielding gas tank. The shielding gas allows you to make a "flux free" weld so you can build up (weld on top of welds) to fill somewhat thicker materials and also produces a neater weld IMO. TIG welding is great, although my experience may be biased as I was using a very expensive unit. Unless you have a real need (or a LOT of extra money, I don't think it is practical for the hobbyist user. Used welders are available at auctions fairly reasonably priced. I purchased my OA outfit with tanks, cutting head, goggles, heating tips and cart for around $100 - I spent another $50 or so to trade in the tanks for the "Thoroughbred" brand tanks (you own them and can trade them in for refilled tanks without any annual fee). I bought the stick welder at another auction for $60 - it had a helmet, about 75 foot of #8 extension cord and a toolbox full of welding rod with it. The cord had a broken splice, after repairing it the welder functioned perfectly and we have used it quite a bit. If I were just starting out I would watch the sales and purchase a 125 to 150 amp MIG with the shielding gas option. (you can use it with flux cored wire if you don't want to invest in a tank at the start) It is the easiest to learn and will do 90% of the welding usually done in a hobby shop. i don't know anything about the Harbor Freight units - I probably would not buy one, Rural King, Tractor Supply and many other of this type stores all carry small MIG welders and usually have them on sale once or twice a year.

Re: OT Newbe welding

#8

Leo Cuellar

Re: OT Newbe welding *LINK*

Leo Cuellar

It depends a lot on what you actually want to do. I'll add that with Oxy/Ace you can weld Almost anything, aluminum & copper included.

I've added a link you may find helpful


Tin Man Tech