on making your own stain- why and how
Bill Tindall
If nothing else I hope this note inspires others that make their own stain to reveal how.
Why? Traditionally stains were made from mineral pigments- burnt umber, raw sienna, etc. Such stains are light fast for ever. Modern stains can be made from synthetic pigments and dyes that are more or less light fast. They do give access to a wide array of colors not possible with mineral stains, for example the purple Bartley calls cherry...... should these colors be desired. Additionally, I have not found it possible to match the colors of the traditional pigment stains with modern stains, in particular the reddish brown burnt umber I prefer for walnut and the slightly brownish red I prefer for cherry. Having exhausted my supply of circa 1970's Sherwin Williams mineral pigment walnut and cherry stain I needed to come up with a solution.
A plan: The tech staff at General Finishes told me that their line of "oil" stains are made from mineral pigments, good, but none were made with pure burnt umber. However, they went on to say that the stains are made by mixing mineral pigment into the what they sell as "Pre-Stain" wood conditioner, AKA, wipe on oil base formula "Natural", a mixture of dilute varnish and solvent.
Result: I mixed a bit of Japan color "Burnt Umber" from Moser's #843320 (available Woodworkers Supply) into the General Finishes "Natural" and the result was a perfect match for the old Sherwin Williams walnut I sought. I'm still smiling.
Note: The dry powdered mineral pigments available from Lee Valley are difficult to disperse. I think it best to begin with a dispersed formulated pigment, ie the Japan color.
Why stain? The natural brown walnut pigments photo-bleach in a sunny room to yield a light yellowish brown hue (yellow from the finish) which I find undesirable. With a light coat of burnt umber I can preserve a warm brown color forever. I find cherry looks richer with stain. To my eye unstained cherry looks "raw" and I associate the look with beginner woodworking projects. With the right finish cherry eventually looks warm and inviting, but there is no need to wait that long to get to this state.





