Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

on making your own stain- why and how

Posts

on making your own stain- why and how

#1

on making your own stain- why and how

Bill Tindall

If nothing else I hope this note inspires others that make their own stain to reveal how.

Why? Traditionally stains were made from mineral pigments- burnt umber, raw sienna, etc. Such stains are light fast for ever. Modern stains can be made from synthetic pigments and dyes that are more or less light fast. They do give access to a wide array of colors not possible with mineral stains, for example the purple Bartley calls cherry...... should these colors be desired. Additionally, I have not found it possible to match the colors of the traditional pigment stains with modern stains, in particular the reddish brown burnt umber I prefer for walnut and the slightly brownish red I prefer for cherry. Having exhausted my supply of circa 1970's Sherwin Williams mineral pigment walnut and cherry stain I needed to come up with a solution.

A plan: The tech staff at General Finishes told me that their line of "oil" stains are made from mineral pigments, good, but none were made with pure burnt umber. However, they went on to say that the stains are made by mixing mineral pigment into the what they sell as "Pre-Stain" wood conditioner, AKA, wipe on oil base formula "Natural", a mixture of dilute varnish and solvent.

Result: I mixed a bit of Japan color "Burnt Umber" from Moser's #843320 (available Woodworkers Supply) into the General Finishes "Natural" and the result was a perfect match for the old Sherwin Williams walnut I sought. I'm still smiling.

Note: The dry powdered mineral pigments available from Lee Valley are difficult to disperse. I think it best to begin with a dispersed formulated pigment, ie the Japan color.

Why stain? The natural brown walnut pigments photo-bleach in a sunny room to yield a light yellowish brown hue (yellow from the finish) which I find undesirable. With a light coat of burnt umber I can preserve a warm brown color forever. I find cherry looks richer with stain. To my eye unstained cherry looks "raw" and I associate the look with beginner woodworking projects. With the right finish cherry eventually looks warm and inviting, but there is no need to wait that long to get to this state.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#2

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I never "stain" any wood. To my eye stains deprive the wood of it's natural beauty. But that's me. I will however enhance some wood with light dye washes. I like dye because it does not distort the natural figure. I usually only use lightly tinted applications for the purpose of warming wood tones....such as walnut.

I'm not anti-stain but I just don't consider it for my work.

Tom

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#3

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

paul in AZ

Good post. This has the makings of a fascinating thread.

I'm another who basically never stains wood.

My limited experience with dyes could be a factor but for the most part I think that dyes also give wood a "furniture store" look. Just me. Perpetual beginner?

As to cherry, a little linseed oil and a week or so in the intense Arizona sun puts at least a year's worth of color on it. Of course i rarely have to worry about it getting rained on. Obscuring that glow with stain or dye is the last thing I'd want with cherry.

I want to learn about this and hope more people chime in.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#4

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

Jesse Cloud

Not gonna take sides in this dog fight. :b

However, its good to know that a huge range of pigment powders are available at dirt (pun intended) cheap prices. The big market is people who formulate their own makeup. Just google pigment powder or search for it on EBay.

I have a friend who has a few hundred different pigment powders in his shop and he produces some amazing products, typically by tinting shellac or lacquer.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#5

Ellis Walentine

Stains and reasons

Ellis Walentine

Good explanation and rationale, Bill. I use stains for much the same reasons, especially on woods that will change color unacceptably if I don't. Here are a few observations relevant to the discussion...

- Not all brands of pigment stain are pure mineral pigment dispersed in a vehicle. Some include varying proportions of dyes in the vehicle as well, and some use synthetic pigments.

- Dyes vary greatly in lightfastness. Water-soluble dyes generally are more lightfast than alcohol-soluble dyes. Some dyes dissolve to differing degrees in different solvents, often with different color outcomes and lightfastness. As a rule, if a piece is going to live in a bright room or in direct sunlight, I try to find a pigment stain solution that works, because I don't trust any dyes to retain their color over time under those conditions.

- I tend to use dye stains followed by pigment stains to get a complexity of coloration that neither seems to impart by itself, in most cases.

- Pigment stains lodge in pores and wipe off of summer wood, so they create a lot of grain contrast in open pored woods. You have to make the call as to whether that look is desirable for your particular project.

Ellis

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#6

How I apply (for stain users only)-example

Bill Tindall

It may be that some eschew staining because they have had poor success doing it. Favorable results begin with meticulous sanding. Any place that is catching sanding dust and looking dull will catch excessive stain and look blotchy. I stop at 180 for porous woods and 220 for dense woods like cherry. For example, if your end grain isn't stained to the same depth as flat grain work on learning to sand until it does.

I apply stain with what shellac finishers call a "tampon" or "rubber". Wad up a golf ball sized piece of cotton(tee shirt) and then single wrap this ball with a more durable cotton or linen piece and tie, or use a twistie, to secure. Old blue jeans work great. The finished product will look like a golf ball tied in a pouch.

Dab the bottom of this arrangement in the stain and rub it on the wood. The rubber should be wet enough that if stain is not wetting pores you can apply pressure and squeeze some into pores......but dry enough that some pressure on the rubber is required to transfer stain. Dab in stain and rub away on wood until all is uniform. Wipe excess off every minute or two with a dry cloth, eg blue jeans. Don't let excess stain dry on the wood. If it is going on right very little will get wiped off. By controlling pressure on the rubber the wood can be made more or less darkly stained.

A quart of stain will do an acre of wood when applied this way. A quart of cherry stain has lasted me nearly 30 years.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#7

In my woodworking books I found a book

Gary Smyth

that might be worth exploring if you can find one. Mixed Paints, Color Pigments, and Varnishes. Clifford Dyer Holley, Ph.D., (Professor of Chemistry) and E.F. Ladd, B.S. (Professor of Chemistry) Published by John Wiley and Sons, 1908.

It gives percentages and weights of various chemicals for the stains of that time. It's more scientific than most books. It covers white lead and other leaded paints, blue tints, green tints, brown and black tints plus varnishes clear and colored.

For example an analysis of Burnt Umber

(by percent) Moisture 2.01, Silica 3.94, Ferric Oxide 51.04, Alumina 6.80, Calcium Oxide 1.95, Sulphur trioxide 0.22, Manganese dioxide 9.79, Undetermined 0.04, Loss on ignition 3.94.

These are more like the formulae used by paint manufacturers. Interesting book if you want to make proprietary finishes. It's a nice little book though (235 pages)

The only problem I discovered is that some chemical companies won't sell the ingredients unless you are registered and approved by them. Thhey also want to sell you a drum or 50 lb bag. Even school chemistry lab suppliers get particular without a purchase order on school or company letterhead. I was told it's a Homeland Security thing. Damn, they make things hard for do it yourselfers sometimes.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#8

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

Steve Schoene

I'm a proponent of making stains. That way you get pigment only stains without them having to be gel stains. The secret to dispersing powdered pigment is to start with a mound of pigment and add a small amount of oil (BLO) and work them together with a pallet knife or the like to get a paste. (If you want to be fancy spend an inordinate amount of money for a "muller" (a flat bottom glass pestle)

Then you can more easily dilute the paste. I like a combination of a little varnish and oil, adding relatively more oil for longer working time. I then thin with mineral spirits to a pleasant consistency. No critical proportions at all.

I use it just like the can from stains. Apply liberally, let penetrate a few minutes for the mineral spirits to flash off, and then vigorously wipe off any excess.

And, definately it's not a case of either stain or dye. Both is usually a good answer for a finish with depth. As long as it isn't used as paint, or a pigmented toner, you can have a quite natural looking finish superior to all but the finest factory finishes.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#9

David Barnett

Something to mull... *LINK*

David Barnett

"They do give access to a wide array of colors not possible with mineral stains, for example the purple Bartley calls cherry...... should these colors be desired. Additionally, I have not found it possible to match the colors of the traditional pigment stains with modern stains... "

Although I don't often, and haven't for a long time, used pigments as a primary stain on wood (I do use pigment glazes, and so on), if I were to use pigments I would certainly mull them before thinning to coating strength. It's quick, requires no real special equipment (you can redeploy-repurpose some around the house to use as a muller), and a broader range of high-quality earth pigments is more widely available than ever. It's even fun if you don't have to do a lot of it at once as I have now and again.

As you said, Bill, a really good reason to mull your own is to get total control of the color (tone, shade, tint, opacity, etc.) and to have a versatile palette at the ready. Maybe I just like to complicate things. A go-ban was bleached several times before repeatedly dye-washing and knocking back the resulting tint, followed by the palest glazes (washes, really). The lines were inlayed, then more glazing. I was ambitious back then.

While you can order earth pigments from LV (which is fine), as you've found, they'll usually need some work before they're ready for the medium/vehicle. This is entirely expected. The advantage of stand-alone pigment suppliers? Lots of choices, with full ranges of traditional and historical pigments for fresco painters, encaustic artists (that'd be me), muralists, finishers & restorers and artists who prefer to make their own aquarelles, gouache, pastels, oils and encaustics. For finishes, I've never really felt comfortable with the Universals and Japans, but that's just me. They can be doctored, but I'd prefer to start elsewhere.

Without getting any deeper into it, of interest to furniture finishers may be:

"Our Colonial Natural colors come from North America, deep in the Blue Ridge Mountains of Virginia, where several veins of color can be found. Just like our Natural Earths and Ochers, our Colonial Natural pigments are all natural with no manmade ingredients. Lime stable, they are compatible with all mediums and permanent to UV."

This five-year-old Tuscon company carries a somewhat small but well-chosen selection of very high quality pigments* mainly for those who make finishes and color plaster and cements for the decorative trades. Although I've long purchased from Kremer and Sinopia (and will continue to do so), the pigments (and oxides) I've tried have been quite finely ground and competitively priced. They also sell sample kits, but as you can order most of their pigments in very small amounts, sampling is affordable (for instance, 100 grams (3.5 oz) of Colonial Burnt Umber is $3.73).

*"The Earth Pigments Company offers the entire line of Earth, Ocher and Mineral pigments from the world famous quarries of The Soci�t� des Ocres de France, located in the Provence region of France."


Blue Ridge colonial pigments

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#10

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

John Pappas

Steve, I have made stains and glazes using artist colors. What, if any, is the difference from powdered pigments? Thanks.

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#11

Clint Searl

Pigments source *LINK*

Clint Searl

Try these folks for any and all pigments = natural, unnatural, and supernatural.

Clint


Pigments

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#12

David Barnett

If you made it past that last post...

David Barnett

Kremer Pigments

http://kremerpigments.com/shopus/index.php?lang=ENG

With over 1000 pigments, many in various grindings and purities, Kremer can be daunting to the uninitiated. And once you get beyond the pigments, it's a whole world of dyes, media, vehicles, gums, glues, binders, resins, gelatins, varnishes, chemicals, additives, tools, conservation materials...

Sinopia Pigments

http://www.sinopia.com/pigments.aspx

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#13

David Barnett

"Saint Peter, don'tcha call me... "

David Barnett

" ...'cause I can't go --

I owe my soul

to th' company sto'... "

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#14

Nice source - thanks

Gary Smyth

Re: on making your own stain- why and how

#15

David Barnett

Making your own stain -- as you go

David Barnett

"I never "stain" any wood. To my eye stains deprive the wood of it's natural beauty. But that's me. I will however enhance some wood with light dye washes. I like dye because it does not distort the natural figure. I usually only use lightly tinted applications for the purpose of warming wood tones....such as walnut."

I hear you, Tom. I've swung to both extremes in thirty years (and lots in between) to this bleached, faded extent of color and water-clear coatings where I am most at home. On the other hand, I'm an unrepetant ebonizer.

While I do appreciate the 'found' state of wood's unadorned face, I further extend my acceptance to no finish as a viable finish -- get my wabi-sabi going on, you might say. I don't care about naturalness of wood for its own sake but what I wish to feel and invoke. As for thick pigments under resinous goo, that's strictly les boules.

Most would consider hypernatural non-finishes, such as heavily-used tabletops with nothing but light wax impractical, but I'm pulled towards it, this do-it-yourself bring-your-own-wine-coffee-blood staining kit. For less-challenged surfaces, a hanging cabinet or tall clock, say, lightly-sculpted waxed pear is one of my favorites. Bleached, though. At least a little.

Light dye washes also appeal to me, but I find myself bleaching to bone or oyster before I'll entertain that palest pastel hint, that merest coral or grey, perhaps. My fascination with the faded may itself fade at any moment, of course.