We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
What kind of non-corroding fasteners are needed for the new brown pressure treated lumber?
I am redoing my deck. The old one (~15 years old) is terribly dry-rotted, especially the supporting girder system. Eastern exposure to high altitude Arizona sun and snow. And can I not finish it, or if I need to, with what?
And kindly do not bother with suggestions for non-wood products. They are not in my budget, thus a waste of words to me. Thanks.
You live in a ideal climate Carol ,to fasten your decking with PL 500 construction glue formulated just for things like decking.
I have used it for years without any call backs, once you see a deck down without any fasteners showing , you wonder why you hadn't done it before.
It has many superior qualities ,the main one being that you won't have any fastener heads creating little pools of water when it is wet thereby speeding the dry rot process.
Most hardware and Building supplies carry it and it comes in quart size caulking tubes which require a bigger caulking gun.
Setting the deck lumber with a occasional toe nail which never shows is how you can keep on working without waiting for glue to set, which sets very fast , especially in hot weather.
I have a large "M" Senco Staple gun for the toe nailing, this eliminates any hammer tracks ,you could rent one or just be careful if you use a Hammer.
If you elect to hand nail it , 8d hot dipped galvanized nails is all you need.
About the finish , I am old school and always use original formula Thompson Water Seal , which out there in dry country, should last two years between coats.
On PT you probably won't notice as much, unless you put on enough to build up a film. I've yet to see a film finish that doesn't crack, peel, and generally turn into a pain in the neck in high desert conditions. Well, any desert really, but the elevation makes it worse.
Personally, I've had best results from Sikkens SRD on hardwood. My neighbor used a Sikkens (don't know which, the array is a little bewildering) product on his log house too, and I think his porch, which is PT. Outdoor work finished with these product will still require recoating, maybe once a year. Junk from Home Despot lasted about 3 months (we're at 7000 feet).
Can't help with the PT fastening. I won't use the stuff if I can avoid it - little point in the wood lasting forever if your fasteners rust away in 10 years
The little bit that I have used recently was pretty dry (most isn't), so it doesn't seem to have attacked the fasteners as quickly as I expected. That was ACQ IIRC, they may be on to something else by now.
But I much prefer screws. I want decking to be easily repairable and properly counterbored screws allow for easy replacement of deck boards. I also favor the look of a straight screw-line as a mark of craft.
I have absolutely no use for Thompson's original wax sealer. In my area its gone in 3 months if you're lucky. I use Penofin oil on all my decking as it's non-film forming, renews easily without stripping, and will take mildewcide additives.
PT Wood Indus. group state that hot dipped galv is fine, but there are variations in both the process and the product. I know stainless will be there at least as long as the boards.
I used to have a place in Pinetop AZ which is at 7000 feet and not far from you. An outdoor PT deck was a problem. The best coating of a bad lot was "log oil" for treating log cabins. I can't recall the brand name but the local weed-and-feed store carried it. It lasted one year and sometimes two but had the undesired effect of being shiny and thus slippery when wet.
Thompson's used to have decent products until they went big time and my experience with them is that they are now a waste of time and money. Baehrs is the other commonly seen but is no better.
There is no really great solution for deck coatings.
You need to check out what the chemical actually is. ACQ is five times as corrosive to metal as the older stuff was. This is the stuff that brought on the rush to find better fasteners. The Orange Borg is selling something different locally. Not sure what it is. If its borate based it will probably be gentler on the fasteners. I would use either the ceramic coated ones or the stainless steel (better).
I would not use Thompson's Waterseal. Many years ago I had an opportunity to question one of the two leading experts in the country on working with treated wood. His strongly held opinion was that it was crap. Described it as little more than paraffin dissolve in thinner. His opinion was that applying finish to treated wood was that it was a waste of time and may be detrimental. His explanation was that you will do a good job of finishing the top and perhaps the edges but that water will run under it and soak in from the bottom. The other finished surfaces will then retain the moisture and accelerate the decay.
If I were building a deck and wanted to maximize the life, I would bevel the tops of the joists so the deck boards rested on a knife edge and I would cover them with something like butyl rubber tape or strips of Ice and Water shield to keep the dryer.
All due respect Mark , I actually did decks for high end clients and also for Bob Morris , a Landscape Architect who was associated with F.L. Wright and his insight and workmanship requirements made me a much better Carpenter.
His opinion of a screw or nail line straight or otherwise would have exacted a "Amateur " comment from him and for a host of good reasons.
By paying close attention to his ideas of how the outside of a home should look was a education one couldn't easily acquire otherwise.
As for Deck finish , all of them require attention , if you like a particular one, fine, that doesn't make another inferior,it's just a unsubstantiated opinion that you nurture, not anything factual about it.
Untreated softwood in the desert environment is a no-no. The sun destroys it about as fast as termites could.
A finish is important out here because it buffers MC changes which slows cracking and checking, and gives some UV protection. Wood out here dries out and cracks apart long before the bugs can get it, assuming the deck is sensibly built with no ground contact.
Good stuff, would be my next choice after Sikkens, and down there with all that nice UV blocking water vapor, I doubt one would notice much difference between their performances.
Now whether or not one has exposed fasteners or not is just a matter of taste and whatever trend is current in my view. No one is likely to remember the name of that deck designer 20 years after he's gone, but clean, workmanlike construction will continue to be appreciated.
I don't really think calling nicely lined and regulated screw spacing "amatuer" is going to win much appreciation around here, and frankly such fad following talk lowers a craftsman in my view. Work doesn't have to follow just one person's taste in order to be good work.
I knew a designer once who loved little black allen head cap screws as details on aluminum lamps he made. He used them as accents in various patterns, providing both pleasing form and effective function. Taking pride in executing any task well is far superior than pride in following trends in my view.
I have built two decks here in the last 15 years. The first one was built using cedar with SS screws. The second one done about 5 years ago on another porch I used ipe and SS screws. In my opinion ipe is far superior to cedar. At the time, 5 years ago, they were essentially the same price. Don't know the currant pricing of any of the decking materials. I bought the ipe from a company in Texas and had it shipped in. I bought the screws both times from McFeeleys. I recommend countersinking SS screws.
I have been reasonable happy with a Cabot stain around here, The most exhaustive testing on deck stains that I am aware of was done by Consumer Reports over several years. I assume that there is a public library over there somewhere that would have the back issues to find the test results. Cabot came out reasonable high as I recall. In my opinion the currant Thompson products are about as useless as you can find.
Is there still a Foxworth store in Payson? If so I would recommend talking to them. At least around here they are much more knowledgeable than anyone I can find at either of the Home Depot stores.
To use ipe, cedar, or any other more expensive materials would first of all, be putting a silk dress on a beggar. The rest of this house simply cannot aesthetically support it.
Second, the additional cost doesn't fit in my budget at all. I am presented with removing the deck entirely, or replacing it with PT wood. It was originally built with untreated 2x6's that lasted ~12-13 years.
Using PT ought to at least extend that some. And, frankly, I won't be in this house anywhere near that length of time.
Second, I wouldn't have wasted money on Thompson's 15 years ago. The old deck was painted.
Sadly, Foxworth in Payson closed some years ago. All we have left is a HD, though there is an independent trying to make a go of it.
My brother is building a new house. His burned to the ground last year. He has given the new guy a shot at every bid for material, willing to wait to have him ship it in. HD has beat him out at every turn and the quality of materials that HD has delivered has been better than what is on the shelf.
He will be ordering my deck materials because of the pro discount he gets.
I still would like to hear about the 'invisible' fasteners. I'd rather not have screws driven through the surface, even properly pre-drilled and countersunk. However, their cost may also exceed my budget. McFeely's has other options. I need to know what those mysterious fasteners are called so I can investigate them.
I'll go with the Sikken's product applied on all surfaces. It gets used around here a lot.
All that said, and if you are still with me, the earlier failure came primarily from the dry rotting of the girders.
So I still would like to hear opinions about capping them with aluminum flashing and gluing the wood down with PL4000. The aluminum could not be pierced and perhaps the girders would last longer.
There are a number of "invisible" fastener systems out there. Kreg makes a jig that aids in accurate toe-screwing of the deck boards (the screw goes in the leading edge of the board as you lay them). If you have access to the bottom of the deck, you could also consider pocket screws from underneath. Simpson makes one, then there's TigerClaw and EBTY as well. I'm sure there are many more.
I used Tiger Claws on my front deck when I resurfaced it with composite decking. The fasteners have worked well, but were a pain to put in. They give you a plastic block to set the fastener into the side of the first board. It does a good job. Then you are supposed to pound the next board into the fasteners you placed in the first board. On long boards if you get one end pounded in, as you work to the other end the first end will pop out. I ended up using pipe clamps to hold the boards in place while I worked the middle and other end into place. It took lots of time and messing with clamps. I also ended up drilling holes for the prongs in the boards to make the job go faster.
I will admit that after five years of summer heat and winter snow & ice that the fasteners have done their job well.
When I redid our rear deck, I purchased decking with slots in the side and used a clip in fastener system. It went better than the tiger claws and looks just as good.
Note that all the hidden fasteners are going to cost more than screws or nails.
If you do a Google search for "hidden deck fasteners" you will find lots of info.
We flash ledger beams here, but nothing else. If you want your joists to last longer, give them 2 coats of Cuprinol (the "Green Stuff") boatbuilders use. When I put in our front walk/decking, even PT wood (other than the top decking) got painted with the stuff.
Looks a whole lot greener around your place, Mark! Lovely.
But I am in mountain desert. Very dry. And at 6200 feet. Obviously the moisture stayed between the deck boards and the girders too long. The flashing was intended to keep moisture from hanging around. No flashing certainly would be easier and less expensive.
I am not sure Cuprinol is advisable in the desert. I think better drainage is my answer. FWIW, my girders are 3-4 feet off the ground.
An earlier post suggested cutting a vee on top of the girders and resting the deck boards on it. That would drain more quickly. Seems though that fastening becomes a problem with that idea. I considered rounding the top edge to hasten run off though.
I will spend some later looking at fasteners. Time to get to work.
I stand corrected. I live in the south with a climate that is brutal in its own fashion, but not with the UV that you would have at that altitude. This area may be the termite capital of the east coast. If you were to "plot" termite activity you would find it most intense in the deep south and progressively less until you got to Canada. Except for the Richmond VA area. Apparently they love us here. Perhaps its the "Rivah".
I think it is true that no clear coating will offer the UV protection of a good paint. My understanding is that a clear coating simply can not match an opaque one at blocking UV. I personally don't like painted decks, so I would not consider it, but I don't live at altitude either.
Again, from my understanding is there is no such thing as dry rot. Rot fungi is a living organism and it must have four things, oxygen, warmth, food (wood) and moisture. I was given the explanation that what you see as dry rot is wood that rotted while wet enough and then you see it in the dry state. My experience looking at beams under houses that rot is that they absorb humidity, get wet enough to decay, but they decay from the center out. I suspect your beams were several layers of "2 by (?) and that water soaked down from top and wet them. Being shaded by the rest of the deck retarded drying and they rotted.
I agree or can at least visualize that wood in your climate will generally be destroyed by heat and UV and will fall apart before it rots. Unless you set up conditions like those above that protect it from UV and retard the drying.
Generally wood that drys faster than it gets wet, or to put it another way, has a tendency to dry quickly and stay dry most of the time resists rotting. (How do old barn boards survive in your climate? Some of them last a hundred years around here.)
Locally, we have lots of trouble with the band board of houses rotting where decks are attached. For years builders simply removed the siding, exposing the band, nailed on a treated board as a ledger for the deck and then put hangers on the ledger and hung the deck joists in them. Water would find its way behind the treated ledger and rot the band of the house. (I've seen it a thousand times. literally.) There have been many attempts to correct the technique. Bolts instead of nails, Aluminum flashing, non-metallic flashing, and building the deck not attached to the house. (I could go on for hours about this, as a home inspector I have made my living off this for 25 years.) The point is that I wanted to tell you that I have seen two decks where they removed the siding, Installed the joist hangers directly on the band board of the house and built the deck. The band board held up well in spite of being not treated because it was largely protected from the weather and kept reasonably dry.
So, Back to your deck. If you cap the top of your beam with something like butyl rubber Tape it should help keep water out form between the laminations. Lowes and HD have such tape in the window department as flashing tape to go around windows. The advantage to it over metal flashing is that it is gooey rubber and it tends to seal around the screws or nails. (I am assuming here that the area under your deck sets up conditions that are conducive to rot. So if you modify the situation, you should be able to give the lumber a push in the right direction and have it live longer in a sound condition. So, use treated wood, cover the top of it and use fasteners that will survive. (Butyl Rubber Tape is subject to UV degradation so you might want to use two layers or cover it with aluminum or black plastic or something that will keep the UV off the butyl. You may be able to find it foil backed for the purpose.)
If the deck lasted ten or twelve years and was built out of untreated lumber, then improving the beam and switching to treated wood should give you an extended life. I am skeptical of gluing the boards to the joists, but others hear say they have done it. I have used glues made by the same company for gluing subfloor to joists indoors and nothing but good things to say. So, I might try using PL500 (?) and a single blind screw from below to pull the boards into the glue.
Lately I have been using a single screw from the top in deck boards. I alternate them left and right and I like it. My opinion is that if the board is going to warp two crews won't hold it. One screw does not trap wood between the fasteners and cause splitting and it puts fewer penetrations into the joists. (I have seen countless deck joists that appeared to have been split by having as row of fasteners driven into the top edge.)
One more thought on the beam. If you were to use posts such as 6x6's or 4x6's you could notch both sides and install the beam as two single pieces with an air space in between. The would be far less prone to decay. You could also make up a beam with spacer blocks in between to allow for air circulation. Such a beam could bear directly on top of the posts.
I will look into the tape mindful of UV protection.
The posts of the deck are currently 4x4's and in good condition. The girders were bolted through them. I'll know more next week when it all comes down (except for the posts).
I am liking the idea of glue and a screw from below to pull the deck boards down. No penetration from the top side. I can use the double dipped galvanized deck screws for this. I will use Sikkens on the deck and paint on the rails.
I think I have a plan here. Thanks, everyone.
I'll be back if more problems are exposed after the demo.
As you can see, here at 900 ft. I need a whole lot more drainage than you do in the high desert, and my unflashed PT joists and girders etm. have done just fine [except for the damn carpenter bees ]. Just make sure you leave at least 1/8-1/4" between your decking boards for air and drainage. (I use a screw in every other joist)
If you don't mind working from beneath, there is a system involving a stainless strip that is screwed to the joists, and then the decking is fixed with screws from the underside for the "no screws" look. McFeeley's used to carry it, don't know about now.
Carol, you are welcome. You can see why I been accused of being verbose. Someone said that if you asked me for the time, I would tell you how to build a clock.
Locally, I would check the posts at the bottom for rot. Here, the soil keeps the wood wet near the surface and it rots. Deep in the soil it lasts better because it is either too wet or deprived of oxygen. So, Probe the posts just below ground level to see if they are sound.
You can rest the beam directly on them or you can notch them about an inch deep on each side and bolt the beam on the two sides. An inch of bearing should be more than adequate. Use Galvanized bolts.
One other thought. Treated lumber locally is almost always completely saturated and swollen from have been pressure treated. A 2x12 might shrink close to an inch in width as it dries. this problem hits you several different ways. If you bolt the beam to the post and the beam shrinks, the lumber may shrink enough that the bottom edge no longer bears on the surface of the notch and the deck is completely supported by the bolts. (Put the bolts low, near the notch.) The other concern is with the deck boards. Two problems. If you put them down with a nice space between them, they will shrink enough to leave a large gap, perhaps a half inch wider than you thought. This is why I like the single screw. If you put two screws with them near the edges of the boards, the shrinkage may cause the boards to split at the screws. The second problem could be that if the boards shrink enough they will pull themselves loose from the glue. It is a cross grain connection. So, if they pull themselves loose, the glue is completely worthless. (I really like the construction adhesive, but I remain skeptical for this application. Wetting/drying, freezing/thawing and UV are tough on glue.)
If you can find anyone selling PT that is ADAT (Air Dried After Treatment) or KDAT (Kiln Dried After Treatment) use that. They dry it after treating it so that it has already shrunk when you get it. If its not available buy your lumber in advance and let it dry. Even a month or two would help.
When you lay the deck boards put them down snug and they will shrink enough to give you cracks.