Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

The Biiiig Fill

Posts

The Biiiig Fill

#1

The Biiiig Fill

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

OK, Here's the scenario:

Assume a slab at least 8/4 thick that has holes (large, small, bug trails or galleries, rotted out limbs and bark inclusions)

Assume that some will be left as "working voids" while other will be filled solid all the way through the slab.

It was suggested to me to use sun-dried used coffee grounds and Titebond III instead of epoxy. The reasoning was that as the wood swells with seasonal change, the glue mix will do likewise and remain level whereas the epoxy, being rigid , will wind up either above or below the surrounding wood.

Let us keep in mind, now, the we're talking 2" thick fills, and if it's a big hole, we're looking at pouring a pint of resin at a time which will take special hardeners and a slow cool cure to control.

So, what say ye, gurus? Titebond? Epoxy? Coffee? Wood flour and sawdust?

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#2

"dry" time

Bill Tindall

put some glue in a cup and let it sit. Count the days while it hardens. Hint, you won't live long enough to see it hard.

Why? The transport rate of water through cured poly(vinyl acetate) polymer is extraordinarily slow. The stuff will acquire a cured film and that rate of the remaining water diffusion will become nearly zero.

Epoxy does not rely on something leaving to cure so it can cure in a large mass.

I don't know what to use but glue isn't it. A professional shop that does tables out of wormy maple uses Bondo for hole filling.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#3

Re: The Biiiig Fill

john b

How about using an flexible architectural epoxy, Advanced Repair Technology, mixed with coffee grounds. I have not used ART but have used other epoxy and coffee grounds, fresh grounds not used. There was more grounds in the mix than epoxy, it looked really good in Walnut. I used the fresh coffee, generic brand, because i did not want to wait for sun dried. Happy filling john b.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#4

Re: "dry" time

FredD

Bondo to fill voids in wood is a good way to go either exterior or interior.

Having learned the hard way , be sure to keep the build close to the surface , a cheese grater plane works and let it cure which is fast.

The reason you don't want a very high protrusion above the wood surface will become apparent when you go to sand it. It sands slowly and if your not careful, you will sand the surrounding wood lower then the Bondo..

FredD

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#5

Even if it dries...

John in NM

My feeling is you'd have problems with adhesion, so even if the plug moved with the wood it would pop out in a couple years.

I worked a couple years for a shop that did lots and lots of mesquite work. If the void was really big, we'd usually place some scraps in it to help avoid the shrink/swell problems you're anticipating. The trick was to make them look like they were supposed to be there. Sometimes I'd split or whittle pieces of similar color to lay in parallel to the grain. Since the large voids were often old branch centers, the boss's favorite was to find a scrap from the center of a trunk and cut it to fit in the void. He was pretty good at that, though I don't remember getting the hang of it myself.

I don't remember the problem coming up often either, we usually tried to work around large voids, we'd only take this much trouble if it was in the middle of a gorgeous book matched top.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#6

Ellis Walentine

A pint of resin?

Ellis Walentine

That is a b-i-g hole. I don't know that I would try to fill something that large with just filler. For one thing, consider the finished appearance. If we ever had a void that big to deal with, we'd usually cut a Dutchman of some kind to go into it. If it was a knot that was missing, we'd find another similarly shaped knot and cut it to fit the void. Then the epoxy would only be bridging the voids between the patch and the slab. We used duct tape to dam up the bottom surface so the epoxy wouldn't drain right through.

Our go-to product for patching was always West System epoxy. I'd use slow hardener for big patches. For filler, I made my own fine sawdust on the spindle sander, using a large diameter drum and a piece of newspaper on the sander table with a hole in it for the spindle to catch the dust.

Ellis

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#7

Re: A pint of resin?

matt overton

It depends on what look you want to achieve. When I put down a wormy oak floor in my dining room, I filled the empty knot holes with fiberglass resin and ti worked great for the last 7 years.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#8

Thanks All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I thought the Titebond suggestion was kind of off. Perhaps he thought I'd be filling small holes where the wood would such the water out as well.

I rather think that I'll leave the voids as they are with possibly inlaying a few butterflies. Been waiting to use some of the pre-embargo rosewood I have hoarded, so this may be the time

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#9

Clint Searl

Re: A pint of resin?

Clint Searl

I'm partial to using ammonites to fill big holes.

Clint

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#10

Clint Searl

Re: A pint of resin?

Clint Searl


Re: The Biiiig Fill

#11

Some Context

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

This is the slab I'm working with. 63" by 34" wide by 8/4.

The object of my main inquiry is in the upper left. Detail is here

I'm also considering what to do with this "depression" at the lower right of the big picture

Suggestion and thoughts are welcome.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: The Biiiig Fill

Moses Yoder

On big holes like that you are much better off leaving them open and natural. I don't think any fill will last over time. A 1" hole maybe fill, a 2" hole I wouldn't fill. Leave it as a natural feature. Splits can be butterflied on both sides of the board to keep them from growing.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Some Context

Moses Yoder

The upper left has a lot of bark inclusion, which I would remove, then put a butterfly key across the narrow lower portion of the split. The bottom right in the pic looks like a solid knot; I would take some chisels and remove the flaky stuff then take my air sander and 60 or 80 grit sandpaper to smooth it, forming a depression, then sand it up to the same grit as the top and finish it natural. Here you could also take a router and route the knot flat about 1/4" or 3/8" deep then fill with a clear epoxy to bring it up flush to the same level as the top.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#14

Re: Some Context

Todd Nebel

Remove the bark and sand out the nature lines and then maybe a series of butterfly keys decreasing in size (Large left, smaller middle, smallest right) in the upper left. I've seen a few tables with nature objects like small river rocks set into tables, maybe do something like that in the bottom right after dishing out the knot.

Re: The Biiiig Fill

#15

Re: Ideas

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The large gap feature upper left has no bark but is the sound wood growth surface the formed around an inclusion that was removed. I had considered filling it to make usable surface but have decided to "ladder" it with a series of thin butterflies; how many and when I'll play with.

The section in the lower right is not a knot, but rather a "dish" that was at the bottom of a void formed by an inclusion that rotted and fell out (the next boards up in the flitch had the hole, but way less of the crotch grain). That one I'm seriously considering filling with clear epoxy as it's about a inch deep and has great textural interest. I'll have to "dam" the outside edge, and put the epoxy mix under vacuum to get all the mix-air out before I pour it, but that's the easy. 1" is a doable pour with a slow hardener. Memsahib may, however, nix my fill and use it as a nut dish instead (in which case it will have to be finished for cleaning purposes) or direct that it just be left alone.

Thanks again, guys. Good input. Undercarriage is presenting some unique issues as I don't want to be doing a complete Nakashima rip-off :D