Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

Posts

Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#1

Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

kellyanderson72

It is a "solid brass" hinge from Lowes. I guess it is solid brass because it aged pretty well but the screws just turned silver after the ammonia.

I soaked them in lacquer thinner to clean off the clear coat then to speed up the process I soaked them in the ammonia instead of just fuming it.

I installed them on the project, an aquarium canopy it is just a flat plywood lit banded in solid wood attached to more solid wood. I installed the stay and when I lifted the lid to try it out the hinges just broke. At first I thought the screws had pulled out but when I looked this is what I found.

Could it have been the soak in the ammonia that did it? Or just bad hinges?

I bought 2 more pair at the same time and did everything the same to them but they installed with no problem. Any ideas?


Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#2

Seriously Defective Metal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Little ammonia's not doing that. You have stress fractures shown. Looks strangle like the piece was held together by its coating that rinsed off in the chemical.

Weird. Take'em back for a refund.

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#3

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

John McGaw

No, I've never seen that. I used to age steel hinges by soaking in muriatic acid to take off the plating and then treating them with gun bluing solution. I discovered that some steel hinges aren't really all steel -- some of them had an aluminum (or was it zinc?) pin. Whatever it was, without a pin a hinge is just two oddly-shaped bits of metal. What you have there is certainly a severely compromised piece of metal.

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#4

How long did you soak?

John in NM

The copper in the alloy is soluble in ammonia, but I would have guessed that several days were required to weaken the metal that much with household ammonia. I don't suppose you were using some reagent ammonia, or the 28% stuff from a diazo machine? :D

I've used a solution called "Brass Black" on brass screws. Doesn't seem to cause any problems.

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#5

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

brad patch

Yes, happened to me! I evidently left the brass hinge in the ammonia fumes too long. The fumes, not the solution, will darken an uncoated brass hinge pretty quick. After keeping an eye on the progress, no further problems. FYI I was using a janitorial grade ammonia available at the big box stores.

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#6

Re: How long did you soak?

kellyanderson72

They soaked for a day or so. The weird part is that I bought 2 other sets of the same hinges and did everything the same at the same time together and these 2 are the only ones to do this.

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#7

Different alloys maybe...

John in NM

Or even just different states of annealing perhaps?

What ever the cause, I think you'll have better luck with either an engineered solution or a quick fuming. The screws probably turned silver due to being brass plated steel - soaking in ammonia took the brass right off. Might not even have been brass, they're doing all sorts of color coatings these days.

I was once helping a friend turn some cheap steel hinges black, we dunked them in muriatic acid to remove the zinc and were then going to heat and drop in used motor oil. Only trouble is the hinges were really cheap, and I left them in the acid too long (it was still fizzing, see, I figured they weren't "done") - darn hinge pins were zinc too! :D I thought it hilarious, but he was kinda mad.... but that just made it funnier :D

Re: Has anyone had a hinge do this before?

#8

Your hinges were not defective

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Brass is susceptible to stress corrosion cracking, especially from ammonia or substances containing or releasing ammonia. The fact that you soaked your hinges in ammonia is the cause of the failure, nit defective material. Even exposure to ammonia vapors can cause brass to become brittle.

Lee