Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Does anyone know about motor oil?

Posts

Does anyone know about motor oil?

#1

Does anyone know about motor oil?

Bill Tindall

I recently bought a Ford Excape 2.4 L. The manual calls for motor oil that meets the following Ford Specifications: XO-5W20-QSP or .... -QFS. The tech service reps for various oil purveyors were clueless as to whether their oil met this specification and the web sites were similarly without such information. Does anyone know where to find out whether this or that oil meets this specification. I suppose there is an "oil forum" somewhere.

The specification is important because some "brain" in the damn thing is going to tell me when to change the oil, so it assumes oil of some particular specification which is unknown to me. (This brain does numerous other annoying things that I would rather do my self, but it drives nice.)

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#2

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

Brian From Monument

What model year is it?

If it is brand new perhaps taking to the dealer is good if not expensive and perhaps inconvenient.

The CSR could tell you what oil is best.

They of course will tell you that their oil is best.

This is the great oil incestral problems.

The car companies have been in bed with the oil companies for decades.

The root cause behind our never getting fuel economy.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#3

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

John McGaw

By some extraordinary coincidence, both of the oils you reference are labeled and sold only by Motorcraft (read that as Ford). Guess they really want to keep the money in the family since neither seems to be anything special. The first one is a blend of regular + synthetic oil while the other is straight synthetic. It can be bought from various sources including Amazon.com and the prices vary quite a bit.

In the past I've always been a believer in changing oil at 3k intervals and at that rate the oil is probably less important than it would be at long intervals. Fleet operators (police, taxis, etc) seem to get away with changing much less frequently and their vehicles seem to run forever (and many taxis smell like they already have). I now change oil and filter at 5k using a good grade of regular oil of the proper viscosity and have found no downside. The key is probably what you need to do to keep your warranty in force and that depends on how duplicitous Ford might be in this area.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#4

Actually

Dan Donaldson

You would not believe the money and effort spent by the auto companies to gain fuel economy. I have been involved in many of these efforts over the years.

Addy protocol: I worked for one of the big 3 for 30 years until I retired.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#5

Still skeptical

John in NM

I've had a Saturn that gets 40+ highway since 1995. Most cars in the same time period barely managed low 30's. Automakers have been pushing in-efficient cars and horrible SUV's for too many years for me to believe it when they talk about wanting to produce efficient cars. The Euros and Japanese produce some wonderful diesels, but VW is the only one who imports them here. I find it very frustrating - this from the guy who bought the 40 mpg model when gas was $1.25 per gallon.

I'm about to replace the Saturn, and so far I've found one, that's 1, car with a sticker mpg to match it - and it's not a car I want.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

Jesper, Denmark

The oil companies usually list the approvals from different manufacturers on the can. Check the local displays and read the small print on the back.

I drive a mini-SUV with a VW 2.0 litre turbocharged diesel with particulate filter. It requires a VW 507 spec oil, which is both expensive and difficult to find. I soolved it by buying oil by the case from an industrial supplier of lubricants.

If you cannot find it by reading the cans, try the search function o different oil company web sites. They will usually translate the Ford spec. to one of their products that meet it.

The spec does matter, as the diesel is set up for long life oil and only needs changing every 20,000 miles.The particulate filter is sensitive to non-combustible particles, so the oil is fully synthetic and extremely low ash.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#7

Re: Still skeptical

Dan Donaldson

They push what people will buy. Many times if you take a survey, people will say that they want x y and z, but when it comes to getting out the checkbook, they don't buy them. During my career, there was a particular model that was a pain and would have been discontinued except that the market for it was just too high. It was not one of the fuel efficient models and hurt the CAFE, which was part of the reason for wanting to get rid of it. There have been several times in the past that some of the European versions of care were imported, but the market did not support continuing. There were some European cars that I drove over there that I would love to have ween imported here. The problem was that, in many cases, the cost here in the US was too high to generate a sufficient market. The competition in Europe was the big Mercedes and BMW's where they did well, but were priced accordingly. The SUV's and larger cars do generate more profit, but that is only because they are what people want. No company can "push" something on the buying population that they do not want to buy and if the market goes away, the models will disappear very quickly. One thing to remember is that the older cars you reference had significantly higher emissions than the newer ones. In some cases, (even though it seems counterintuitive) getting the emissions down will hurt the mileage. There are things that you can do about that to some extent, but it costs a lot of money which the buyers (no matter what they say to pollsters) have shown they are not willing to pay.

The climate changed a lot over the 30 years I worked in the industry and many of the practices you are alluding to no longer exist. A good part of my performance reviews depended on supporting mileage and emissions requirements and my pay directly depended on those reviews. There is no conspiracy with the oil companies to keep fuel prices or usage up. These days, if a company could develop a cost effective 50 mpg vehicle with good room and performance, they could almost write their own ticket. If you think about it for a minute, the conspiracy theories really make little business sense.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#8

Not conspiracy, just stupidity...

John in NM

As I said, there have been popular 40 mpg cars on the road, but they are hard to find now - why? Because they sell to cheapskates like me who drive them into the ground - not enough profit in that.

Half the problem is indeed that most consumers want something that drives like a Porsche and looks like a Hummer. The other half is that the auto makers don't want to make money, they want to make a ton of money.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#9

which auto makers are making a ton of money?

Bill Tindall

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#11

Never said they were succeeding at it...

John in NM

And any kind of explanation is going to head off into the political territory of bail outs and unionization.

I have no problem with their supplying Hummers to every dingbat who wants one. I think the manufacturers would be wise to also supply efficient cars to those who want them as well. My beef is that they are unable or unwilling to do so.

You don't have to make a hybrid to get 40 mpg, yet they are almost the only option, and many of them do not even come up to the sticker rating on my old, worn, and cheap Saturn (I still have the sticker somewhere). Ahhh, but hybrids are currently "sexy" so that is what is pushed.

But we stray OT here, I'm content to leave it alone.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#12

Use 5W-20 weight.  Sold everywhere.

Nat robison

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Use 5W-20 weight.  Sold everywhere.

Moses Yoder

I would never use 5W-20. I don't know of any engine manufacturer who would recommend it either. 20 weight oil is just not heavy enough to prevent engine wear. My cars have to last about 300,000 miles.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#14

Not an oil weight expert but..

Nat robison

this is the weight suggested by Ford for almost all of their cars and it's in the part # quoted in the original post. People with more knowledge can debate its merits but it's been recommended by Ford, Honda, etc. for many years now.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#15

And it used to be 10W40

Jon

Then 5W30, and depending on the engine design now it COULD be 5W20.

The times they are a-changing.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#16

Found a couple more...

John in NM

Though at the end of a night shift I'm having trouble sorting out just what Ford did to inch one of the many foci (focuses?) up to 40 mpg. Seems Chevy has added an overdrive to their manual trans that gets the car up to 40.

Sorry about the grouchiness, nothing like a week of night work, even with the luxury of the internet :D

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#17

Toyota

George, Oxford, NC

Bought a 2010 Camry and the recommended oil is 0W/20 synthetic. In fact the manual says that you can use 5W/20 if you need oil and can't find the 0W/20, BUT, you should change back to the 0W/20 as soon as possible.

Tighter engine tolerances allow this and it helps mileage also.

George

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#18

Moses Yoder

Re: Toyota

Moses Yoder

I suppose it would also help get the car off the road faster so you need a new one sooner.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#19

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

Jon

As long as it meets with Ford's spec, but I suspect any name brand 5W20 will do.

Here's a discussion link:

http://www.fordfusionforum.com/index.php?/topic/1503-conventional-vs-synthetic/

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#20

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

Howard Acheson

Have you checked with your Ford dealer? I believe that that spec is for a high quality synthetic oil. In my Cadillac, it calls for the same type of oil. I have one of the new systems where the car calculates when oil changes are due. If I don't use an oil meeting the spec, I void my 100K warranty.

All the major oil refiners make an oil that meets the GM spec.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#21

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Good afternoon Bill.

We have an 08 Escape 4 banger. I took it in for its annual state inspection and oil change. Customer service rep told me that the Ford label oil they use is a combination synthetic and regular oil.

In my previous Mercedes C280 I used Amsoil European service synthetic 10W40 made in Superior Wisconsin. I highly recommend it. once my warranty expires, I will return to the Amsoil oil.

My current MB E320 CDI uses Mobil One as supplied by the dealer. To refute the comments above about no diesel imports, My current 07 Benz is a 210 hp diesel with a modest 390 pound-feet of torque and top end governed at 150 mph. It is emissions are legal in 48 states Newer models are approved in all 50 states. I get around 35 mpg on the highway. This is a full size 5 seat sedan.

I will also point out that the Bavarian Manure wagon Company also imports a straight 6cyl diesel in their 3 series.

That is my story, and I am sticking to it, :b ,

Ken

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#22

Just curious

Dan Donaldson

What does a car like that cost there? (in US dollars for us currency challenged) ;)

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#23

that link unlocked the mystery

Bill Tindall

The link provided the "decoder ring" to go to API standard. Much thanks.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#24

for a technical discussion of why see this link

Bill Tindall

http://www.bobistheoilguy.com

For a mind numbing discussion of oil viscosity and why new engines now run on 5-20. It would appear the 0-20 will be the coming standard for modern engines.

Re: Does anyone know about motor oil?

#25

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Just curious

Jesper, Denmark

Curiosity killed the cat 8) .

Denmark is the country with the highest esxcise taxes on cars in the world, so generally, figure that they would cost twice of the equivalent vehicle in the USA, Germany or Sweden.


Skoda yeti Ambition, Haldex permanent 4WD, 2.0 Turbo diesel, 170 HP, Columbus navigation, 0-60 mph 8.4 sec. average fuel consumption around 40 mpg, New price in 2009 (please stay seated!!) $80,000 at current exchange rates to DKK.