Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Posts

Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#1

Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Thomas Norton

Well today my wife an I replaced out '99 Honda Accord with 217,000+ miles on it with a "11 Ford Fusion. The finance person "offered" the extended warranty plan. So my question is with all the complexities of new cars does it make sense to consider buying the extra coverage? It is about $1200 and would extend the basis coverage by 3 years and an additional 64,000 miles.

Thanks!

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#2

Don't think so. *LINK*

Hoa in Alameda

I'd put that $1,200 is some sort of investment fund that matures when the (no-cost) manufacturer's warranty runs out. Then I'd take all the money and put it in a saving account.

When you need money for repairs that would be covered by the extended warranty, withdraw from that saving account.

I guarantee (haha, pun very much intended) you'll be ahead.

If you do want to buy extended warranty, (1) buy warranty only from the car manufacturer (in this case, Ford), do not buy warranty from third party (warranties sold by dealers are not necessarily from car manufacturers), and (2) don't buy it now, you still have some time (typically 1 year after buying a new car) to decide, then shop around for the best price. It's the same warranty from Ford, but dealer's mark-up varies from dealer to dealer.

-- Hoa (who just saved his boss $500 using #2 above)


This discussion has some useful data.

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#3

Extended warranties are very lucrative for sellers

Scott in Montana

I purchased an extended warranty for one of our work vans. It seemed to make sense since many employees would be driving this vehicle. $1500 down the drain.

The first shock was the $100 diagnostic fee which was not covered by warranty. Next, it was almost a challenge to find something that actually was covered by the warranty. Most everything was dismissed as normal wear and therefore not covered. The gas pedal fell off the vehicle and we were told that it was considered abuse. Oh, and we were charged the $100 diagnostic fee.

I know that Sears disciplines their salespeople when their sales of extended warranties doesn't make up a high enough percentage of their overall sales. Extended warranties are very lucrative profit center for retailers!

I quickly back away from anyone suggesting an extended warranty.

Scott in Montana

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#4

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Robert R. Clough

I bought one once, about 14 years ago. When I needed to use it, it turned out to be worthless. That was an expensive piece of paper.

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#5

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Howard Norman

Consumer Reports in previous years has had articles about extended warranties in their annual (April) car issue. As I recall their analysis showed that it depended on the car maker. Might be worthwhile to go to the local library and check out CR on the subject.

BTW, I don't think that I would buy one on a Honda. A Chrysler: probable.

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#6

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Barry Irby

I would be very skeptical. I seriously doubt you can get it to pay off.

Years ago I was buying a car and they offered me the warranty at something like $1200 and I instantly turned it down. A few minutes later they offered it at about $700 and I turned it down. They went back and talked to the "manager" and offered it to me at $400. Not only did I turn it down I was offended.

My neighbor had one that went bankrupt. Took him about a year to get about half the money back. Then he wanted to buy another one. Huh?????? Slow learner.

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#7

Another point of view...

Stuart Hough

I would only buy an extended warranty if I was reasonably certain I was going to"drive out" the warranty before the vehicle was paid for. I bought an '88 Isuzu pickup with the maufacturer's warranty for 36,000 miles back in '88, and bought the extended warranty coverage for an additional 64,000. The only reason I did this is because at the time I was driving 96 miles each day round trip, and at that rate I would "drive out" the waranty in 2 years. While I never actually needed any warranty work, I did have peace of mind that the truck was covered until the bank relinquished it's claim on the truck ( I got the title).

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#8

Re: Extended warranties are very lucrative for sel

Bill Howatt

You make an excellent point - know what is really covered and know what you will be expected to pay even if the "repair" is covered.

On my 2005 Dodge Grand Caravan the repairs to date such as plugs, injector service, front brake pads, rear brake service would have all been normal wear and tear. The broken air dam would have been abuse - I ran it into some hard snow and ice. Might have covered a $100 repair on some sway bar bushings.

Bill

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#9

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Randy

Wait until you get 23000 mikes on car as long as it before the original date then ask for added 5-6 yrs and 72000 miles. Goes in effect that date for 5-6 more yrs and 72k to the 23k. That way you get 95k and 3-6 yrs. They only add the on to the date you pay for it to begin.(GM works that way, check with Ford)

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

#10

Re: Ot-New Car Extended Warranty

Tony - Memphis

We bougth a Nissan 350Z a few years ago. We usually buy cars and drive them until they are worth nothing and are too much to maintain (~10 years or so). The Z is a pretty complicated vehicle and service costs these days are very high. we paid around $1100 for the extd. warranty and it has more than paid for itself. Wish we had one on the Chrysler Sebring we used to own. It would have paid for itself. I have a 2001 S10 that it owuld not have helped with. All of its issues started outside the warranty and beyond what the ext warranty would have covered. So, I'm not sold either way. The Nissan coverage was surprisingly good though. I was surprised at all of the things it covered. Too bad it doesn't cover tops and clutches and tires! Oh well. We may be in the market for a new ride soon too (the S10 is getting old and I don't trust it anymore). Not sure what we will do. Thinking about a hybrid and that would make me look long and hard at an extd. Oh, Nissan gave us a year to make the decision. That wasn't made obvious by the sales people, but the financial lady at the dealer told us that. It cost a little more to wait.

Enjoy the new ride! I understand those are really good cars.

Tony