Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Table Top Split

Posts

Table Top Split

#1

Table Top Split

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

I made my daughter a drop-leaf Shaker table with a 3/4" solid cherry top finished with many coats of Tried & True. I believe her constantly leaving her laptop computer on the table with nothing between the two has allowed the heat build-up to cause the joint between two boards that make up the top to partially fail. So, now I need to seperate the two boards, clean the joints and reglue. The failure, though only partial, is right down the glue line. I have not tried to see if there is total joint failure. If there is not, any ideas on how I can get the top apart without having to make a new one? The glue used during initial construction was yellow glue.

By the way, she now uses one of those "stands" that have a built in fan to put her laptop on.

Re: Table Top Split

#2

Re: Table Top Split

John Veerkamp

If you can, the best way I know is to take top and using a thin kerf high quality blade in your table saw, just rip down the center of the failed joint and you're ready to re-glue.

Re: Table Top Split

#3

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Saw the glue line, joint both faces, and reglue. No getting out of this one "cheap."

Re: Table Top Split

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Table Top Split

Moses Yoder

The warmth from a laptop is not the most likely culprit. I don't know of any laptops that would get hot enough to soften a glue line. When we disassemble yellow glue with a heat gun, the wood gets so hot it comes close to leaving burn marks. How is the top attached to the aprons and legs? Is there some room for the top to expand and contract? The second most likely culprit is that the wood was relatively wet, and is now shrinking and pulling away from the glue joint a little. 3rd, the glue may have been on the wood too long before clamping, making an insufficient bond. If #1 is the culprit and you just glue it back together it is bound to happen again.

Re: Table Top Split

#5

Re: Table Top Split

FredD

I tend to agree with Moses about the boards shrinking and opening the joint, doesn't take much , if the boards were in the 10 to 15 % MC range when they were assembled and are now close to 6% that would do it.

Ripping joint open on the tablesaw is the fastest least damaging way to clean up the joint for gluing.

One other thought comes to mind , if you had a poorly fitted joint and forced it closed with clamp pressure , the spring back won the contest.

FredD

Re: Table Top Split

#6

Have to side with Moses on this one...

doug f, san clemente, ca

I have used a laptop for almost 5 years on an oak table that I made about 15 years ago. Also put some pretty hot plates on the table any number of times; no problems whatsoever.

I would look carefully at the way the top is fastened to the apron and legs. Is there sufficient accommodation for wood movement? When you have the top apart, my guess would be that will find the split very near, but not at the glue line. The heat from a laptop, unless it caught on fire, just isn't enough to soften the glue.

Good luck with your project.

Doug

Re: Table Top Split

#7

Piling on...

Jesse Cloud

Yup, I think Moses is probably right. If you haven't already done it, 'figure 8' fasteners are cheap and easy to retrofit to an existing table and would take care of the movement. Just attach them to the table aprons that run across the top boards.

I feel your pain. Before I bought a real jointer, I believed the marketing for those 'glue line rip' saw blades. Most everything I built with that is showing glue line issues now... Looks like I'm gonna be ripping and jointing and regluing, too.

Re: Table Top Split

#8

Re: Ditto the Ditto

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: Table Top Split

#9

Yeah

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

But I dittoed firrrrst :b

Nice to see you back George. Was getting a bit worried.

:D

Re: Table Top Split

#11

Re: Table Top Split

Jim Dillon

Doug,

While I have never had a joint fail (knock-on-wood), sometimes I try to be too frugal/cheap with the glue in order to avoid too much squeeze out. Make sure you use enough glue to just get a bit of squeeze out during clamping. Also, if I think of it, I try to slide each board back and forth an inch or so to distribute the glue even more. I think your daughter is off the hook as I can't imagine a laptop doing that. Others have covered the impact of how you fasten your table top which can also be critical. Good luck!

Jim

And a BIG welcome back George!!