We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I never use it since all finishes are self "sealing" and my usual finish is solvent lacquer; and I have an unopened can of super blond flakes that I think I purchased from Garret-Wade around 1982. One rationale for using it under waterborne top coats is that it eliminates grain raising that would otherwise occur. Given its shelf-life issues and inconvenience of mixing from flake, why wouldn't solvent lacquer in an equivalent two-pound-cut serve the same purpose?
Thinned solvent laquer or any other varnish works to.
The advantage of the shellac sanding sealer is that it does raise the grain some, and is very quick drying, does not smell too bad and is relatively cheap. Brushes clean up easily in alcohol and rags do not self-combust.
If you use it often, brushes stay sof and useable in a jamjar with a little alcohol and wiping rags stay useable in a plastic bag.
In addition to the reasons Jesper just mentioned, I thought one of the advantages of shellac (dewaxed) is the universal compatibility - that is you can put any other varnish on top without issues. That seems like a great characteristic for a sealer.
I don't know much about laquer since I hate the stuff, but shellac will go over anything. If you spill some oil on the wood you can wipe it off and put shellac right over it.
"Thinned SOLVENT LACQUER or any other varnish works to.
The advantage of the LACQUER sanding sealer is that it does raise the grain some, and is very quick drying, does not smell too bad and is relatively cheap. Brushes clean up easily in ACETONE and rags do not self-combust.
If you use it often, brushes stay sof and useable in a jamjar with a little ACETONE and wiping rags stay useable in a plastic bag."
And, if the top coat is self "sealing", which all are, what's the point of putting it on top of something else that serves a redundent and unnecessary function?
Shellac used as a sealer is handy for two purposes:
1. Partially sealing 'difficult' wood such as pine that absorbs finish differently in different parts of the board - e.g. prevent blotching. BUT, a diluted coat of just about any finish, or even glue, will do the same thing.
2. As a barrier coat when building 'layers' of color. Sometimes I will spray lacquer, then seal with shellac, then apply a glaze to make a certain color effect, then seal with shellac, then finish with lacquer. I have found that applying that glaze on top of lacquer that is dried, but not fully cured, will allow the glaze to seep into the lacquer coat and come out 'muddy' looking, while keeping them separated makes a crisper look.
If lacquer is your only finish, then there is probably no good reason to use a shellac sealer.
>>>> why wouldn't solvent lacquer in an equivalent two-pound-cut serve the same purpose?
It would. There is rarely a need for a shellac "sealer" unless you are dealing with a oily wood or as a barrier coat to separate two incompatible finishes.
>>>> And, if the top coat is self "sealing", which all are, what's the point of putting it on top of something else that serves a redundent and unnecessary function?
Excellent question. However, there are advantages with certain woods, most notably oily woods.
Here is some additional info about sanding sealers.
It is my opinion that using a sanding sealer sacrifices quality for expediency. Sanding sealer is used simply because it builds and dries fast and is easy to sand. Most contains a zinc stearate soap that sands like a jewel. Most are lacquer based so it dries fast and they can get to that final sanding sooner. However, adding the stearate to the sealer coat provides a very weak base and the stearates cause the product to have little or no resistance to water or water vapor. While one could use the finest finish ever made as the final finish it will never be better than the base it is on. One thing it does not do is "seal the wood" to any greater extent than any other finish.
Never use a lacquer based sanding sealer under an oil or water based poly. There are standard tests for and you could easily see the decreased adherence associated with sanding sealer containing stearates. This was very pronounced when using polyurethane varnish which has low adherence anyway so never use a stearate based sanding sealer under poly varnish. Things get even worse with multiple coats of sanding sealer. Now you have a very soft finish underneath a hard surface. This will cause cracking and crazing when the surface is dinged.
Lacquer based sanding sealers are primarily used by high production furniture finishers where time is money. They do not experience adhesion problems as they use lacquer finishes, not polyurethane varnishes.
Sanding sealers must be matched to the top coat. There are specific types of sanding sealer for two part lacquer finishes and for polyurethane oil based finishes.
This brings us to shellac as a sanding sealer. It is only in the past few years that shellac has recieved any mention as a sanding sealer. This is mostly due to Zinsser looking for a new market niche for their shellac products. They re-labled a 2# cut of shellac as a "sanding sealer" for use under oil based poly and waterborne finishes. As a initial coat between sanded, virgin wood and any other top coat, shellac offers no benefit. There is an exception with using an oil based or waterborne finish over an tropical, oily wood. Shellac works fine as a barrier coat improving adhesion. Most woods do not need any barrior coat for maximum adhesion and a thinned coat of the top coat works as well as shellac. It just takes longer to dry.
If the finishing product requires a sealer coat (sealer is different than a sanding sealer) it will call for it in the directions. Generally, the sealer is a thinned coat of the final finish. Sanding sealer is just not needed.
Your experience layering toning and glazing justifies shellac's use as a barrier, but I can't think of another example where that characteristic warrants its use. Shellac as a necessary barrier coat on oily woods seems spurious to me; I know absolutely that NC and acrylic solvent lacquers adhere and dry just fine directly on cocobolo and padauk. If a different finish won't properly cure without a shellac base, then that just means that that finish was the wrong choice to begin with. Some things are not meant to be.