Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Posts

OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#1

JL

OT -Desktop versus Laptop

JL

My old desktop is well - old. I just recently replaced the power supply. The 3 1/2" disk drive hasn't worked for some time. The "E" key is quite worn. The size of the hard drive is small compared to today's models. The RAM is small compared to today's models. It is at a desk though. It also has a nice LARGE monitor as opposed to my laptop - and the cat can sit in my lap when I'm working at the desktop.

So - should I consider a new desktop or a new laptop as my next computer? I was reading the article on Yahoo the other day and I figured I'd ask ya'll what you though.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#2

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Well its a good question. I have a desktop (I assemble all my computers) since I am retired I have no need to have a mobile computer. I did buy my wife a Gateway laptop as she likes to play games in the living room while watching TV.

A desktop has several advantages in my opinion, I can use any keyboard I like (and I have trouble fitting my fat fingers on a laptop board), I can use any monitor I want - I currently am using a 22" flat screen and you can have far better audio speakers etc (I have a 6 speaker surround sound with sub-woofer). If you purchase a custom desktop from a local vendor, it is quite easy to add or change Hard drives, DVD players/recorders etc. Normally a laptop does not have quite as fast of a Processor as a comparably priced desktop. Usually desk tops have many more connections for auxiliary equipment such as scanners, printers audio equipment, network capability etc.

IMHO the only real advantage to a laptop is the portability and ease of storage, I had to add a wireless mouse to SHMBO's laptop so she could play the games the way she wanted. It does have internal speakers but the audio doesn't come close to my system and I certainly can view my monitor much easier than her 17" screen. If I feel the need I can certainly replace my monitor with a larger one.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#3

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Barry Irby

How old are you? (don't answer that!) If you are on the younger end of the spectrum a laptop will appeal to you. Otherwise you will like a desk top. (I have a desktop. I suspect that buried somewhere inside my brain is the thought that I should go to the computer and do whatever. Its just not "right" to drag it around with me. Guess which side of thirty I am on. I also think you should watch the TV show when it comes on as an event and not record it and then watch when you want to. Takes some of the fun out of it.)

I think you will find that desktops are bigger in every sense. More memory, bigger hard drive, bigger screen, Faster processor and cheaper. You can get very powerful lap tops, but bite for bite, they will be more expensive.

It always seems that the new computer is huge and extremely powerful and very fast. You assume you will never need anything bigger or more powerful. How in the world could you? Well, we never seem to stop thinking or new ways to use computers and more stuff for them to do and new and monstrously bigger programs and more megapixels and on and on.

I have bought a number of computers over the years and though you would have to pay about $2500 to get a fairly powerful middle of the road computer. Tech one I am using now cost about half that and is many times bigger and more powerful than the one it replaced. I have a 25" monitor. I can put two pages up side by side, pretty much full size. I find it interesting that I run almost everything in about page size. I wear bifocals and its annoying to have to scan left and right to see it all or read. Not sure the big monitor is much of an advantage to me.

My son (under thirty) bought a laptop and a big monitor (monitor envy) and a regular keyboard and basically uses the laptop as a cpu. So you could go that way. OTOH, the laptops seem to have a fairly short life because the batteries crap out after a couple of years.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#4

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Bill Howatt

The only thing a laptop has going for it is portabilty and if this is important to you then you should get a laptop because a desktop just isn't portable.

(A few) years ago, if you wanted good horsepower you automatically went for a desktop but there are many laptops with good power and graphics available now. However, they tend to be pricier than an equivalent desktop.

Desktops tend to be easier and cheaper to upgrade. You can easily have multiple hard-drives in a desktop, put in a more powerful graphics card, likely have more options on how much RAM you can install. Laptops have batteries and sooner or later it will need replacing.

I have a desktop and my wife has a portable. My desktop is in an office in the basement. I often find myself using her laptop in front of the TV or in the living room checking email or reading this and other forums. OTOH, if somebody said throw out your desktop and just have a portable I'd be reluctant to do it. To be fair, I see my computers as a bit of a hobby rather than just a tool to use so I likely don't have the same view as other people.

If you want a large monitor (larger than you can get in a laptop screen) then go for a desktop. Yes, you can plug one in but then the portability is greatly reduced although not eliminated.

Bill

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#5

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Nat Robison

I have both but don't have a huge need on a daily basis to use the laptop. I would echo most of what Larry said........if you don't have the need to do work on the go, I wouldn't buy a laptop. If your desktop is more than 5-6 years old, you could probably buy any of the Dells or HP's out there for about $800 and it would be 100 times the machine you currently have. I don't think you need to spend a fortune if all you're really doing is web browsing, email, etc.

If you do go with a laptop, make sure to ask a lot of questions. Before we got ours, I assumed they were all loaded with software for the advertised price, which is usually not the case. That alone can add another $150 or so to the price.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#6

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Alan S

I've had many desktop and laptop computers over the years. If you need mobility or storage space, the laptop has advantages. In all other regards, primarily price and durability, the desktop wins. My desktop computers have almost all survived to become obsolete and be donated. My laptop computers have almost all broken so they no longer worked.

Actually, if you like to read in bed, for some tasks the laptop is helpful. You can work in bed with papers strewn about you within reach.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#7

Clint Searl

What's the cat say?

Clint Searl

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#8

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

John McGaw

You left out something very important: what do you do with your computer?

I have a laptop but I'd never think of using it for everyday stuff as it is just too cramped and slow compared to the desktop machines I build for myself. While you can get laptops which are nearly as fast as a desktop and offer nearly as much storage you will never get to the point where the screen will be as big or the keyboard as comfortable and it will still cost you two or three times as much to even come close. No, my slow small laptop will always be a traveling companion but never anything more than that.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#9

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Dave Paine

Desktop's do not have to be large.

I purchased a Dell ZINO to place at my TV to use for streaming internet radio and video.

This is a brick sized unit, low power consumption, and if all you need is for e.g., surfing and not gaming, this is sufficient power.

I like the monitor to be separate. Larger than the laptop and easier to read. These days LCD monitors are not expensive.

I have a full size desktop case, same for my wife, but I do like the small footprint of the ZINO.

I purchased a wireless keyboard and mouse for the ZINO so I can use from the settee. Good move.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#10

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have seen several versions of the compact desktop and do see a place in the market for them. However as I build my own systems I see issues with them. They are much like a laptop as they cannot easily be modified - IE: adding additional memory, HD storage, DVD players/recorders (and unknown new technology). Most of todays' laptops allow you to add/use external monitors, external speakers, (not sure about keyboards except some docking stations do allow that) The compacts I have seen in Best Buy and HH Gregg share many of the laptop issues (fixed storage /memory slower speed, smaller monitors for the dollar than conventional desktops). If the user wants to purchase a system and use it for a limited time with no upgrades during that time, and has somewhat limited space they may be ok, but I see very little if any advantage over a conventional desktop.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#11

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Jim Dillon

JL,

Another thought in addition to the excellent views of others. Do you currently have access to broadband internet on your old desktop or just dial-up? If only dial-up, having a wireless-enabled portable makes it easy to take it to a local coffee shop or whatever that has WiFi to download large files such as software upgrades etc. I had to do this a number of times when building my desktop and only had access at home to dial-up. So, I took my fairly new laptop to the local grocery store 18 miles away to download some needed stuff.

With my aging eyes (and clumsy fingers), there is no question that the desktop with a larger monitor and keyboard is FAR better for me than my 15-inch laptop. I've had good luck with Dell, and they have a huge collection of refurbished desktops and laptops to also consider. All-in-all, I vote for a desktop. You will be amazed at what you can get for the money nowadays compared to your old computer. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#12

JL

Desktop it is...

JL

I have a Compaq laptop that is ~2 years old. It works.

The next time the desktop has problems - out the door it goes and a new one comes in.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#13

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

Barry

It depends on where you intend to use the computer. Desktops do most everything better than laptops, except travel with you. Generally, speaking, desktops are cheaper to repair, easier to add RAM, have nicer keyboards and larger monitors. Also, hard drives are larger and so is RAM.

I have never liked the keyboards on laptops. Or, the smaller monitors. Or the little touchpad that tries to substitute for a mouse. With that said, laptops are indispensible if you need to take a computer with you when you travel or when you are away from your home office. You can configure a laptop to do almost anything a desktop can do, but it's gonna cost you.

My choice; a good desktop for use as a primary computer with a laptop for travel.

Re: OT -Desktop versus Laptop

#14

Re: OT - The real question should be:

North of the Border

Do you need the same set of data with you anywhere you like?

If you do, the laptop is the most efficient, economical, and convenient solution.

I used to have desktop and a laptop which I used away home. But I couldn't retrieve or access what I had in the desktop and from both business and personal points of view, that was frustrating. I ended up buying the best laptop (in terms of RAM and harddisk) I could afford -- that meant the money I could afford for both a desktop AND a laptop -- and have since enjoyed my computing at home and on trips.

As for the inconvenience of the keyboard on the laptop, there're millions and millions of users of iPhones, Blackberries, etc. who fare worse (or better, depending on what one looks for).