Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Finishing

Posts

Finishing

#1

Finishing

Ken

I am building a bookcase for my daughter, first flatwork piece ever, and have a question about finishing. Applying finish by brush will be awkward with all of the corners inside the piece. Would it make sense to finish all of the boards before final assembly? With the exception of the side boards that will have plugs in the screw holes. If I leave the ends of the shelves and matching dadoes without finish I can still get good adhesion with the glue at final assembly.

Thanks for any input/suggestions,

Ken

Re: Finishing

#2

Ellis Walentine

Excellent plan

Ellis Walentine

Prefinishing is an often-overlooked and underappreciated strategy. You've described perfectly how to go about it. The other unspoken advantage is that you can finish everything in horizontal mode and avoid runs and sags that are often a problem when finishing vertical surfaces.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Finishing

#3

Re: Finishing

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I've pre-finished pieces that would be difficult to finish after assembly. I usually mask the glue areas to insure that I get a good bond during assembly. Just be sure you know what areas will be completely hidden in the joints.

Lee

Re: Finishing

#4

Re: Finishing

Jesse Cloud

Quick question, just in case... is your bookcase made of plywood? If so, no problem. If the shelves or sides are hardwood, don't glue the shelves into the dadoes, as they will move with humidity change.

Re: Finishing

#5

Re: Finishing

jsamsen

Wow, what a timely question. I just returned from the garage and finished masking all of the ends of horizontal pieces that will go into dadoes.

I am doing a large built-in out of Cherry and Cherry Ply and I have learned to stain/dye and finish before assembly. Actually for the bookcase portion I am doing the finish sanding, pre-stain block control, and gel stain before assembly. Really hard to apply stain like you say to inside corners and get an even color. Since I apply wipe on oil / varnish (General Finishes Oil/Urethane wipe on) I will finish after assembly but before the back goes on.

I used to be eager to complete the woodworking part but then regretted not slowing down and doing the prefinishing or finishing work before assembly.

Re: Finishing

#6

Probably the hardest thing

David Yoho

You're exactly right about slowing down the build process to include your finishing plan at the right moments. I think this is one sign of what sets the real craftsmen apart from the rest.

I recently started thinking about finishing a project before starting the build. I learned this from a friend of mine that has been a professional for about 30 years. It's still new to me but I'm getting much better at it each time I plan a new project. A good example is my current commissioned project. I knew exactly what I was going to use and how it would be applied before I ever went to the lumber yard. Prefinishing really makes a difference in the end result that is noticeable.

Probably the hardest thing is changing old habits and ways of thinking. Once you do, it's amazing what a difference it makes. It's certainly one method to take your work to another level.

Re: Finishing

#7

Re: Finishing

Steve Schoene

I'm confused. Bookcases with shelves glued into dados work just fine with solid wood. The sides, and the shelves meet with the grain running the same direction. Wood movement is the same for both side and shelf so no relative change in width, and no problem with gluing.

Re: Finishing

#8

Re: Probably the hardest thing

Ken

Thanks for all the input, it is appreciated.

Ken

Re: Finishing

#9

Re: Finishing

Ken

So I am almost ready to start finishing. Is there a consensus on whether to glue the shelves or not? If so I need to start taping.

Thanks Again,

Ken

Re: Finishing

#10

Re: Finishing

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Unless there is something very unusual about your shelf construction I would certainly glue the shelves in as the grain direction is the same on the sides as the shelf. I have glued shelves in for the last 55 years and haven't seen any problems.

My son has a cedar bookcase I constructed in shop class in about 1956 - still looks very good - finish is slightly amber. I used Sherwin Williams "Beautylock" - recommended by my shop teacher. Finish has held up well except for the slight yellowing. I have a greatly overloaded bookshelf (with woodworking magazines) in my living room that I made about 25 years ago - with glued shelves no problems with it as of yet! I have made several others but can't recall where all have ended up, haven't received any complaints though.

Re: Finishing

#11

Ellis Walentine

Re: Finishing

Ellis Walentine

>Gluing is not a problem if both the shelves and sides are solid wood, only if one or the other is, because one will move and one won't, although the amount of movement probably wouldn't cause the bookcase to fall apart, but it would want to break the glueline. You could even get around this by just gluing a few inches of the joint and letting the remainder float.

Ellis

Re: Finishing

#12

Re: Finishing

Jesse Cloud

I agree with Ellis, the only time you need to worry is if you are mixing hardwood with plywood, e.g. hardwood carcass and plywood shelves. You are probably ok with all hardwood, if the shelves and the carcass move the same distance, but lots of things can affect that (thickness of stock differences, mechanical fasteners, etc).

In any case, gluing the end of a shelf into a dado is not going to get you much in the way of strength as the glue area on that shelf is end grain, which makes only a weak glue joint. And you will have to clean up any squeeze out off your finish. So why bother?

Best way to build this in hardwood is to use dovetails to connect the shelves to the carcass and let them float.

My two cents worth, lots of different ways to skin a cat.