Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

Posts

SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#1

SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've given up on buying SealCoat shellac. First can I had was made and dated in October '09, 11 months later it was useless due to ester development. I bought another can last November when I did my daughter's kitchen table. Checked it [the shellac] today and it dries to the consistency of well used Beeman's. While there is a lot number on the can, there is no born-on date any more.

I'm going back to mixing my own fresh as I use it.

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#2

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I haven't had trouble with SealCoat, but the lack of a production date discourages me. I did notice a lot of outdated stuff last time I bought some and picked up some '09 stuff that was good as of this fall. I'll be sure to test it before I use it, probably next week.

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#3

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

Jim Dillon

Mark,

I now mix my own as well. Several years ago I purchased some Sealcoat from Highland Hardware. It arrived with one month left on the expire date (one or two years IIRC). I didn't want to risk using it, so I called Highland to complain and, in essence, they said that as long as it wasn't expired, I had no complaint - end-of-story. Since that was not the first time I have had an issue with Highland and treated in an equally unsatisfactory manner IMO, I no longer do business with them.

Jim

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#4

Ellis Walentine

Looking into it

Ellis Walentine

Michael Dresdner is checking into this, Mark. He'll post here if/when he has something to report.

Ellis

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#5

Re: Looking into it

Jesse Cloud

My finishing instructor at the local community college told us that Zinnser has a proprietary formulation for seal coat that gives it a shelf life of 3 years. I am skeptical. Could Mr Dresdner comment on that?

Thanks!

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#6

Re: Looking into it

Jon

I've had cans of Zinsser shelac last years past the expiration date. I just test them prior to using. I don't know about Sealcoat....I can never find it around here...but I think like most engineering specifications the expiration date incorporates a safety factor. Three years is guaranteed, but it could still be OK way past that.

To illustrate: I have a can of amber shellac from Zinsser that I almost threw out when I looked at a date from 2002. Another can of the clear was dated 2007. By all rights they should have been summarily thrown-out, but amazingly a test proved that they were both just fine! It might be a miracle... and to think it happened in my basement!

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#7

Dresdner said...

David Yoho

In a much earlier thread here, Michael responded to a very similar question. Following is a quoted copy of part of his response.

Shellac degrade:


As soon as shellac comes in contact with alcohol, which is its solvent, it begins a degradation process called esterification in which the shellac resins convert to shellac esters. The more esters are created, the slower the shellac dries and the softer and more prone to water spotting the final film is. This process occurs whether the can has been opened or not. Applying a fast drying finish that shrinks substantially over soft undercoats, including over esterified shellac, will cause cracking. In fact, old shellac is sometimes used this way in the motion picture and theater applications to mimic old finishes and paints.

How long is it good?:


There is no absolute number, but several factors affect shellac aging. First is the cut. The thicker the shellac is, the slower esterification takes place. Therefore, a five pound cut of shellac will have a much longer shelf life than a two pound cut. How much longer? Depending on other conditions, about eight or nine times longer. In other words, adding alcohol to a can of shellac shortens its shelf life. Now, about those other conditions; heat, sunlight and moisture are enemies of shellac, even in flake form. Store in a cool, dry place away from sunlight. When shellac resin arrives at the Zinsser factory it is stored on shelves in a huge room that is actually a gigantic refrigerator. The bad news is that when you buy a can of shellac from the store, you may know how old it is by the date on the can, but you have no way of knowing whether it was properly stored during its travels, its stay at the warehouse, or its life on the shelf. Hence, shelf life remains a moving target and is not an absolute science, at least as far as we consumers are concerned.

What is SealCoat and how is it different?:


About six years ago a patent was awarded for a long shelf life shellac resin that substantially retards the esterification process. SealCoat is made from that resin, meaning it has a much longer shelf life than other shellac AT THAT POUND CUT. That's important, since the cut still matters. One big difference is that SealCoat is sold in a much thinner, lower pound cut formula, which is possible only because of the extended shelf life resin. Of course, storage conditions still matter also, as it will degrade, only more slowly.

Is five year old SealCoat still good?:

For most applications, if it was stored perfectly, probably yes. I tested some of the original lab samples five years out and they were fine, but to be fair, my storage conditions are ideal all year around. With different storage conditions, the answer may be different.


Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#8

The Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

David,

For those of us who use shellac as sealer and/or tie coat in prep for top coating with quality waterbornes, the freshness issue is of paramount importance. When SealCoat came out, it promised a big gain in convenience to dewaxed shellac users, especially those of us who've had cold checking and cracks develop, as Michael mentioned. Figuring the problem had to be with the new-fangled finish, I got in the owner's face at Target Coatings, only to be informed that it was the shellac causing the problem. He specifically told me not to use SealCoat that was more than 6 months old, or shop-mixed product more than 2 months old under his or anyone else's waterborne finishes because of the cracking issue.

Of course, I know how old my shop-mixed shellac is because I date the mix. SealCoat started out putting "born-on" dates right on the cans so I could tell if I "should", in a given instance, be able to use what was in the can for my purpose. That vital piece of information now appears to have been replaced with a lot code which is of no use to me at all when I'm standing at the display in the store.

I'll take my can of SealCoat back to Lowe's for a refund under the 2-year guaranty on the can. Since I can't tell the age or how the product was handled before it got to the store shelf, I'll just have to return to those thrilling days of yesteryear and mix my own shellac from flakes as I need it. I need performance, not reasons for failure.

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#9

Re: The Problem

Stuart Johnson

I saw this on another site:

The batch code on the shellac should always be a 6- or 7 digit number, beginning with a letter. For example: S01231D

The first number after the letter will be the last digit in the year of manufacture

The second number will correspond to the month

The third and fourth numbers will relate to the actual day of the month.

In this case a batch code reading S01231D will have been made in the year 2010, in the month of January, on the 23rd day.

another example:

Zinsser

Date code:

So for S0O258D

the codes is after the S

Y

M OND for Oct, Nov, Dec

## Day of Month

Batch number 8D

0 for 2010

O for october

25 for the 25th

and it is batch 8D

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#10

Re: SealCoat

paul in AZ

About to start some finishing I pulled out an old can of SealCoat that has maybe 2 inches left in it.

The date is stamped on the lid. It is hard to read because it runs over the black Zinsser logo but says "MANUF 10 29 08". That must make it 2 1/2 years old.

A quick swab on some wood and it dries normally.

FWIW.

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#11

Must Be The Desert Atmosphere

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Maybe I'll just not buy Zinsser stuff at Lowes. Weird, as I'm 12 miles from their plant. Go Figure :\

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#12

EVERYTHING dries fast here

paul in AZ

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#13

Ellis Walentine

The word from the manufacturer

Ellis Walentine

Mark, Michael booted your complaint all the way to the senior product support representative for Rustoleum, the manufacturer of SealCoat. Here's his reply. If you send me the product code(s) from the affected can(s) of shellac, I will forward it/them to the appropriate people.



Hello Michael

I am not sure what might be causing this customers problems with the shellac finishes. The shelf life of both the shellac and the SealCoat are three years, and if the product is sealed and stored properly it should keep for the three years. If the shellac is drying slowly is usually points to either old product, or from the product being applied too heavily.

This is certainly not an issue that we have been having with our product, so would be interested in getting the lot codes from the can if possible. We would also happily replace the cans for him.

Thank You

Jason Kral

Sr. Product Support Representative


Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#14

At least he responded...

paul in AZ

...even though it was a generic non-response.

As I mentioned earlier my old can had a date on it. A date, not a code. I will always test it before using anyway but the difficulty comes in buying a new can. As Mark said, with all of the alphanumeric things in our lives today I should remember how to interpret codes on cans?? For their internal purposes a date and a code are equally useful numbers. Going to codes now is simply a way to make it hard for a consumer to know how old the product on the store shelf is or how old my can at home is. A little corporate obfuscation in play here. Irritating.

Can you ask why they won't be straight up about the manufacture date?

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#15

Re: At least he responded...

FredD

Fred,

There's a batch code stamped on the can that can be used to determine the

date of manufacture. Unfortunately the code doesn't contain the date and

would have to be called in to the manufacturer to get the date. If you have

a number you want researched you can send it in to me and I'll get the

information for you. The batch code is stamped on the lid on quart cans and

I'm not sure where you'll find it on gallon containers. It may be stamped

over existing text on the cans so you'll have to look carefully to find the

code.

Thank you,

Phillip Pritchard

Mohawk Technical Service Representative

800.545.0047 ext. 1907

From: <fredd@tctelco.net>

To: <ppritchard@rpmwfg.com>

Date: 03/29/2011 04:40 PM

Question.....: Where is the expiration date on a can of SealCoat ?

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#16

Re: At least he responded...

paul in AZ

Not a lot of help if I'm standing in a store trying to guess if what I'm looking at is outdated or not.

Whats wrong with being consumer helpful and putting a real date on it?

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#17

the one I love....

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I am always looking for the date of manufacture on things like furnaces. Many brands have the date coded into the serial number. One of them has printed on the label "The date of manufacture is the first four digits of the serial number". What's the point of having a code if you are going to explain it? And, would have been cheaper to print "Date Manf: YY/MM"? At least it would have taken up less space and used less ink.

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#18

Re: the one I love....

FredD

Well there you go again Barry, like Paul your trying to introduce Logic and common sense into a manufacturing process. frustrating to say the least.

FredD

Re: SealCoat - Personna Non Grata

#19

Re: At least he responded...

paul in AZ

Some young squirt probably got promoted to 8th assistant VP for suggesting the change from something as logical as dates to codes. If so he has a real future in industry.