Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Hardwood floor installation

Posts

Hardwood floor installation

#1

Hardwood floor installation

Joey, NC Ct.

I have an old (1900) small wide planked floor sitting on grade. There's really no crawl space except for woodchucks. I've insulated the walls but the floor is cold. My question. Would I gain any warmth if I lay down some sort of membrane or simply plastic sheathing and a hardwood floor? I have considered ripping up the old floor to insulate or use radiant, but that might be very expensive, no?

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Clint Searl

If the current floor is sound and a two inch increase in height is acceptable, one approach would be: (1) Heavy poly vapor barrier (2) Run 5/4 x 6 decking 24" OC (3) 1" polyisocyanurate foil faced insulation between the decking runs (4) 4 x 8 T&G OSB (Advantech) screwed to the 5/4 x 6 runners (5) Finish with a T&G floating floor.

Clint

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#3

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Barry Irby

What Clint suggests would certainly work if you can afford the thickness. OTOH laying a vapor barrier over an existing floor always makes me a little nervous. Your floor system is already close to the grade and as a Home Inspector my observations over the years indicates there are lots of problems with them. The closer they are to the ground the more inclined they are to have rot and termite issues. By covering it with a vapor barrier and insulating it you might be changing the conditions just enough to induce rot. (The vapor barrier would not allow moisture to escape tot eh top and the insulation would reduce the warmth for the top side.) It would be better if you could lay a vapor barrier over the surface of the grade and suppress the dampness into the soil and keep it out of the air. any chance you could poke and prod plastic into the space?

Another thought would be to have a contractor spray foam onto the bottom side of the floor. This appears to be a coming idea. Again, I am slightly skeptical. As an Inspector I prefer to be able to Inspect, but in your case, apparently you can't get under there to inspect anyway. Foam contractors probably have long wands they can use to spray the underside from eh perimeter through small holes. I would be inclined to have the lumber soaked with an effective fungicide/termiticide such as BoraCare before insulating. The foam on the bottom of the floor leaves you with a floor that is insulated and sealed against air infiltration and some of the foams are vapor barriers as well. This would require no additional height and leave the top surface alone. Or you could lay hardwood or laminate flooring.

The easiest solution to your problem might be to lay carpet over what you have. Carpet with pad is a pretty good insulator and can be a vapor barrier, and infiltration barrier and is warm underfoot.

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Clint Searl

If it ain't rotted now, it ain't gonna; but eliminate the vapor barrier if it gives you the vapors. :\

Clint

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#5

Re: Hardwood floor installation

George Koch

Joey, I believe, to answer your question you need to give more information. First, where is NC Ct. Is it North Carolina or Connecticut? What is this small wide planked area used for? Is it a living area, one room or a whole house, or a detached building where the temperature will vary greatly? Type and location of heating system, and also is the existing floor only one thickness now? Please supply more info. George

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#6

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Barry Irby

Pretty sure you are right, just don't want to give it a push in the wrong direction. sometimes, when you change one thing, you change everything. And If he changed the environment just enough to induce rot, it might take him years to realize what had happened.

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#7

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Joey, New Canaan, Ct.

Sorry to take all day to respond, but I had to work this Saturday in NYC. There's one door where an old cess pool resides and you can see that the joist meets the ground and is not rotting there, but could be someplace else. I like the foam injection. If I'm going to put a new floor over the old one, couldn't the foam guy drill holes to inject? Is the foam good touching

the ground?

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#8

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Barry Irby

Joey, I don't know if they can spray it in from the top and onto the under side of the floor. It will depend on the equipment they have available.

You would not want the foam to touch the dirt and the wood if it will wick ANY water, and they can answer that or you.

If you are willing to "damage" the existing floor it might be cheaper to cut it loose around the perimeter and pull it up, Inspect, and insulate the floor from the top side, slap it back into place and install the new flooring from the top.

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#9

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Joey, New Canaan, Ct.

Barry; You didn't mention knee pads. I have them and will probably need to rip up the old floor, to do it right. I'm afraid of what I may find, eg. rotten joists, cess pool, another dead fox, mold. I did this in the opposite corner, to the bathroom and replaced a few joists. If I go through all the effort of ripping up the floor, any suggestions on preventing subsequent damage to the new install ? Would I need to dig the dirt away from the joist and lay down a vapor barrier on the soil? Off to church, thanks, Barry

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#10

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Barry Irby

BTDT. Worked on a house for my cousin that we started to call the Dead Zoo. We found seven different dead animals including a black snake that was under the foot of the steps and remarkably well preserved. Very neatly coiled and completely dehydrated. Wish the show Oddities had been on then. I would have sold them the dried up snake. It was probably over five feet long. We left it closed up under the steps for future generations to rediscover. This could explain why we would often find its living descendant waiting for us in the house when we arrived to work.

I would remove enough dirt to create clearance below the joists. Preferably 6" or more. Don't dig out the inside much below the level of the exterior soil or you might create a pool. Cover the surface of the grade with polyethylene as a vapor barrier. Make your repairs with treated lumber. Use fasteners rated for the treated wood. Insulated and carry on. You might want to spray any untreated wood you leave in place with BoraCare.

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#11

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Joey, New Canaan, Ct.

Hi George; My location is Conneticut. The floor in question is a small addition on a small house, previously a shed, but now wants to be renovated as living. Since it was never intended for this purpose it has a floor built on the ground. The heat is propane and the stove is in the adjacent room. The floor is 5/4X6 pine. I've recently renovated the large room in the cottage with new insulation and as an afterthought insulated and sheet rocked this small room 10X16. It has electrical outlets but now needs heat, (maybe a small propane wall unit). Heat loss is my incentive to do the floor right, since this is the only area with no insulation. Thanks for listening, Joe

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#12

Re: Hardwood floor installation

Joey, New Canaan, Ct.

Thanks again Barry. We'll see what's up under the floor, Joe

Re: Hardwood floor installation

#13

Re: Hardwood floor installation

George Koch

Joey, seeing that you're up here in our northeast, I think you will need a minimum of R24 insulation between your unheated crawl space and your living area. Being one room, and one floor thickness, with no interior walls, I concur with Barrys advice above, to remove floorboards complete and correct the situation before proceeding with a new floor. If you don't you'll probably regret it latter. George