Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Shop heating

Posts

Shop heating

#1

Shop heating

Dave in Bryn Mawr PA

We down-sized from a house to an apartment. There is no room for my table saw and all the rest in the apartment bedroom (my wife told me that). Shop is now in my son's barn. Very satisfactory except there's no heat. Won't need it till fall, but would like your comments. Shop about 15x25'. What is the best heat source for this space?

Thanks!

Re: Shop heating

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Shop heating

Clint Searl

Insulation and an electric heat/AC pump = year round comfort.

Clint

Re: Shop heating

#3

Re: Shop heating

Joseph Mulherin

I agree with the insulation...do this till it hurts...but you will feel it in the winter. As far as the heating....electric is sooo expensive for this, so I am suggesting a water heater heated with gas and the water flowing into an overhead fan/coil unit. And maybe use a swamp cooler for the cooling...if the humidity will allow. OR install just a furnace in a side closet and duct the heat thru the shop from overhead thru grills spaced out for comfort.

Re: Shop heating

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Shop heating

Clint Searl

My shop/studio is 2400 sqft, kept at a winter temperature of 65 by a heat pump. For the very cold months of Jan and Feb the bills were $150 and $160. It's also quite comfortable working at 75 degrees and dry when the ambient 1s 95 and 90% humidity.

Clint

Re: Shop heating

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Heat Pump

Moses Yoder

Doesn't the heat pump cost about $10,000 installed? It seems like you would have to factor in that initial cost, because maintenance is also expensive.

Re: Shop heating

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Shop heating

Moses Yoder

If you use the shop part time in the evenings and weekends like most people here, it seems to me you would want something to heat it fairly quickly. If it is in a barn then you probably don't have natural gas nearby. I would put a medium size LP tank behind the barn and get a small ceiling mounted LP furnace to heat your shop. Simple, relatively inexpensive, and gives instant heat that can be easily controlled. Mounting it on the cieling keeps it out of finish fumes. You can easily turn it down to about 40� at night, just high enough to keep stuff from freezing.

Re: Shop heating

#8

Re: Heat Pump

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I installed a new water source geothermal heat pump 3 years ago and the cost was $9300 installed. This unit heats and cools the entire house for $130 per month. I have no other utility bills as the house is total electric.

Lee

Re: Shop heating

#9

Re: Shop heating

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I heat my 20x20 shop in Michigan using a ceiling-mounted, two element quartz infrared heater from Lee Valley. It uses about a dollar's worth of electricity per day. I keep it set on one element over night and crank up the second element in the morning if I'm going to work in the shop that day. All I need is the $60 heater and a 120 volt outlet; no fuel, fumes, tanks, or flues.

Re: Shop heating

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Heat Pump

Clint Searl

Mine's an air-to-air multi-stage unit including duct work for two floors that cost about $3500 five years ago. It also has a fully programmable thermostat that I set for 24/7 constant temperature. No maintenance other than washing the return filter since installation. Worth every penny, especially in hot humid weather. It only costs a little more to go first class.

Clint

Re: Shop heating

#11

Re: Shop heating

mdclor

Dave,

You didn't say, but many barns have a concrete floor that holds the cold and when you turn the heat on, moisture will condense on the cold floor and cold tools. This is most likely if you don't keep the heat on 24/7, in the spring or if you use propane as your heat source.

If your son has a working farm with lots of machinery, you might consider a used motor oil burning heater that suspends from the ceiling or mounts to a wall. They are very economical if you have a sufficient supply of used oil.

HTH,

Merle

Re: Shop heating

#12

Re: Shop heating

Mark Stone

I use a heat pump in my house and I find that they are great in the summer months for air conditioning, but are quite inefficient for actual heating. My findings indicate that they are better utilized in warmer climates where cooling is the main function and the winters are not as cold as here in PA. My two cents... :-)

Re: Shop heating

#13

Clint Searl

I'm in east-central PA

Clint Searl