Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Aniline Dye issue

Posts

Aniline Dye issue

#1

Aniline Dye issue

Paul Kierstead

Wood: Hard Maple

Dye: "Aniline" Dye from Lee Valley dissolved in water. Doing quite dark, trying to match some flooring (it is for newel post/rail).

My process:

1) Sand wood.

2) Raise grain, re-sand

3) Do "wash" coat of diluted stain.

4) Lightly sand

5) Full coat of stain. Allow to dry, ~12 hrs. Seems dry enough. Rubbed on with a cloth.

6) Apply some finish. Have dried a variety; T&T Varnish oil, Deft Danish, Defthane Poly (non WB), LV Gel Finish. All rubbed on; will be on complex items, cannot be sprayed (will be done in place) and brush is unlikely to work well.

It is #6 that is problematic; the finish is bringing up quite a bit of dye. This lightens the dye a little, but that can be offset in #5 (and is). The bigger problem is that there is some dye sitting on top of the finish, both making it very dull and allowing it to be wiped off. Of course, I suspect if I do *enough* coats, it'll eventually be ok, but I think it will be a lot.

Secondary issue: Insufficient absorption on some grain lines. This is not a killer problem, but it would be nice to sort out. But I can live with it.

I suspect that the answer to my problem is a seal coat, maybe a light coat of 1 lb or lighter dewaxed shellac, but I think that will also pick up some dye. Should I just wipe it down hard when the shellac dries to remove the top surface of dye?

Where am I going wrong here?

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#2

Shellac?  Often recommended as a barrier coat

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Shellac?  Often recommended as a barrier coat

Bart Goldberg

I agree with Bill. Whenever I'm using aniline dyes, I apply a sealer coat of shellac over the dye coat. Most times I use Zinzer premixed shellac product called Seal Coat. I then scuff sand after that if needed, but the Sealcoat will keep the dye from getting removed by the finish coats.

Regards

Bart

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Aniline Dye issue

Clint Searl

It sounds like the carrier/solvents in the finishes are pulling the stain, which might also be the case with shellac. My inclination would be to wash of as much of the dye with water that's possible, then restain with a pigmented oil stain like ZAR, let it cure and proceed with an oil based varnish or poly. A water borne poly would also work over a cured oil stain.

Clint

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#5

Interesting

Tony - Memphis

I have ben using the same dye for years and have never had that experience. Maybe it is in the application? When I apply the dye, I wipe it off. So there is nothing left on the surface. I almost always use a wipe on poly or oil/varnish blend on all of my work. I do get a bit of color on the wiping rag, but it is very minor. I've done the same on many types of wood. The only time I use shellac as a barrier is when I am glazing. The shellac keeps the glaze from soaking in and allows me to work it however I want (more or less left on the surface for whatever affect I am after).

Tony

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Aniline Dye issue

Moses Yoder

I have never seen an article so complex that it couldn't be sprayed. In fact, normally the more complex the article is, the better it looks when the finish is sprayed. The dye stain is supposed to soak into the wood to color it. Since this is hard maple, a fairly close grained wood, the dye is not soaking in much but is setting on the surface. You can seal it with whatever you want to, shellac wiped on, then perhaps use a glaze to darken it, then top coat 1 or 2 coats or if it's wiped 3 or 4 coats, over the glaze. I hope you are practicing on scrap pieces. Normally on maple we would spray on a dye, then a stain sprayed on and wiped off, then sealer and perhaps glaze then a top coat. This is very easy to do when everything is sprayed then either wiped off or for the finish just left to dry.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#7

Re: Aniline Dye issue

Paul Kierstead

My apologies, I wasn't clear. It can't be sprayed because it is being finished in place (and I'd prefer the rest of the house remain unstained/finished). It is too complex to brush.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#8

Re: Interesting

Paul Kierstead

How long do you wait before wiping it off? I could be just laying it on too heavy. I suppose I could lay down a lighter coat, and then glaze afterwords; this would actually get me closer to the desired look (the floor is kind of two layers, a tann-ish under and a dark brown top, it is stained bamboo). I was trying to avoid glazing due to lack of experience. I guess two applications of stain would be different then one heavy one, also.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#9

Re: Aniline Dye issue

Steve Schoene

First a couple of questions. How fine are you sanding? Up to about 220 should be OK, finer than that can burnish the surface.

The grain raising step is not very necessary, nor is sanding the dye. Best time to sand off raised grain is after first topcoat has stiffened the fibers.

I don't understand the two step dye process. Typically it can be done in a single application. Though I don't see how your method can have adverse effects. The best method with water soluble powdered dye is to use a sponge for application and really wet the wood, which helps get an even color and assures penetration. Use the same sponge, wrung out, to wipe off any puddles. Make sure dye is dry--does it feel any cooler than other objects in the same area? If so it isn't quite dry yet.

Wiping on a finish is most likely to lift dye because of the greater mechanical action compared to brushing or especially spraying. A gentle touch for the first coat would be best--you may expect a small bleed into the finish, but not enough to lighten the results. I understand not wanting to spray heavy finishes, but you might find that using aerosol shellac from Zinnser to seal the dye won't stray too far a field.

As far as an oil stain, you will never get maple to a dark color with pigment, short of sanding coarsely so lots of pigment stickes in the scratches. A very muddy, grain obscuring way of proceeding.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#10

Re: Aniline Dye issue

Paul Kierstead

Thanks, Steve. I've been sanding to 150 (this is architectural). I've been doing the two step process as that is what the instructions call for. However, I did try it without the two step process and it didn't seem to make a difference, to be honest, so I'm not sure why they call for that.

Aersol-can shellac ... now that is an interesting idea. It would indeed have fairly minimal bounce-back/overspray (I don't think I could turn down my HVLP system that low successfully), and would stop distrubing the dye. I'll have to give that a try.

Yes, I tried an pigment-based oil stain first. It would barely colour the wood, as you indicated.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#11

Re: Shellac Spray

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You want to be careful about spray-can shellac to be sure that it's a) fresh and b) dewaxed (like SealCoat). Otherwise you can run into adhesion problems with your topcoats.

One answer to your problem may be found at the art supply store. A can of Krylon spray Fixative, either workable or final, will seal your dye nicely. Since you're working "in place", a cheap drop cloth will protect the surrounding surfaces from the gentle spray.

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#12

Re: Shellac Spray

Steve Schoene

Spray can shellac is dewaxed--actually has been a long time, even before SealCoat hit the market. Fresh is harder, but easy enough to test whether it dries on a hard surface very quickly and fully hard. (Only Zinsser makes spray shellac.)

Re: Aniline Dye issue

#13

Sooner or Later

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Ester's gonna getcha ;)

Krylon Fixatif is the better option here. I use it on turnings; simple and easy.