Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Posts

Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#1

Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Link Van Cleave

Has anyone done a comparison n of these two styles. The General head has 2 sided knives and less of them while the Byrd has the 4 sided ones. I am wondering about performace, cost to operate, etc. They are fairly close in initial cost.

Thanks

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#2

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

FredD

Why would you go for less of a planing head wiht fewer cutters and half of the sharp edges, for nearly the same cost as a proven one?

Never heard of the General.

FredD

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#3

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Steve Schoene

General is almost certainly the Canadian woodwork machine company which has long made tools fully equivalent to Powermatic and Delta. The now also have an import division to stay competitive. Not really an unknown company.

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#4

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Link Van Cleave

One reason is because I have a General planer. So it is not very hard to imagine using a General cutter head for a general planer. They come on the planers as a option. When I bought my planer that option wasn't available. I don't know what you mean by less of a planing head ? Anyway I am more interested in performance. I did cost comparison for the knives and it seems as if the byrd would be 1/2 the cost for knife changes. The cost comparison for the two as far as the cutter head is only $100 difference.

Ease or lack of it for installation between the two, performance and any other thoughts is what I am looking for.

Thanks

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I have a General 130 and a 490 with Shelix Heads

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Link,

I have the General 130 and swapped out the knife styles head with a Shelix about 4-5 years ago. I purchased the Shelix through Federated Tools in London Ontario, about 2 hours from my home. I thought about doing the replacement alone in my shop, but David E at Federated had done several, so I asked if he'd do mine. We loaded the 130 on the van, drove to London and David was able to do it in a morning, about 100 times faster than I would have taken, it was planning wood that afternoon.

I also replaced my General 490 planner head with a Shelix, it was a simple process, and between the two I will say I am so happy I chose the Shelix cutters, they are clean, quiet and my wood surfaces are almost mirrored when they come off the cutter.

I would never go back to knives.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#6

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

FredD

"Has anyone done a comparison n of these two styles. The General head has 2 sided knives and less of them while the Byrd has the 4 sided ones. I am wondering about performance, cost to operate, etc. They are fairly close in initial cost. "

By less of a planer head you only need to look at your original post.

The Byrd Shellix head on my Delta Jointer gives flawless surfaces, I would expect the same from their planer head.

That should answer the performance question.

The cost to operate would not be more and in the case of the lesser knives on the General head would be 1/2 the sharpening of them.

Unless your mechanically inclined which your original post didn't inspire confidence in that department , then I would let the tool dealer install the head, if he breaks it , it's on him , if you break it, it's on...............

About General wood working machinery , I have always thought it the best of the Delta knockoffs.

FredD

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#7

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Link Van Cleave

"By less of a planer head you only need to look at your original post."

"Unless your mechanically inclined which your original post didn't inspire confidence in that department "

Wow, that is what is called passive aggressive. My first post in many years and I get this crap. I don't know how you could infer from what I said what my level of mechanical ability is. I won't comment on your writing. I will resist the temptation to pull rank, lay out my pedigree and piss on a fire hydrant.

"The cost to operate would not be more and in the case of the lesser knives on the General head would be 1/2 the sharpening of them."

What I found out was that the cost of operating the General is actually twice as much as the Byrd as far as knife changes go and assuming all things are close to equal.

"About General wood working machinery , I have always thought it the best of the Delta knockoffs."

Uh, what Delta machine is the Canadian made model 130 a knock off of ???? This is a rhetorical question by the way. It reminds me of a Parks but they have been making this design for at least 50 years.

Anyway Fred, thanks for your helpful information.

Link

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#8

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

FredD

"By less of a planer head you only need to look at your original post."

"Unless your mechanically inclined which your original post didn't inspire confidence in that department "

And the reason I got that feeling is simply, a Mechanic comparing the two Helical heads would automatically gain the conclusion that the Head with fewer Knives, half as many edges per knife and fairly close in price would be lesser in quality and more costly to operate.

Why you didn't come to that conclusion , in my opinion reflects on your particular inability to separate the seed from the chaff in a manner of speaking,but I could be wrong, it happens.

I am myself not a mechanic in the true sense of the word , but I can readily access whether A or B is the best choice and whether I would feel competent in installation or maybe it would be best left to those who like to work on Iron , rather then wood.

My view is the General head is not as efficient or as well designed based on your description of the General product compared to what I already know about the Byrd from personal experience.

About knockoffs , Delta has been in the forefront of wood working machinery since the thirties and if a competitors product looks exactly like it's Delta counterpart , weighs approximately the same , I feel it is not a happy coincidence. but rather a knockoff.

Enjoy which ever way you jump.

FredD

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#9

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

Link Van Cleave

"And the reason I got that feeling is simply, a Mechanic comparing the two Helical heads would automatically gain the conclusion that the Head with fewer Knives, half as many edges per knife and fairly close in price would be lesser in quality and more costly to operate."

What ?? You are not making any sense. That would be pure speculation. All that is available is a small grainy picture of the General head. Any good mechanic would not speculate about a large monetary purchase and try to find real word examples and others experience.

How many knives a head has , has nothing to do with how well it is machined, balanced, and engineered. The retail price can't tell you that either.

All I wanted was to find out some information, not get a load of arrogant, condescending rhetoric.

And again I ask you what Delta machine is the same weight, etc. as the General. From your comments I sense you have no familiarity with the Canadian General machines. In fact you said you had never heard of them and yet now you are a expert and claiming there are just knock offs of Deltas. Again, not making sense.

And for the record, I have worked as a metal fabricator. That means I run mills, lathes, tig weld, etc. I have also made a lot of tools and done my own heat treating and tempering. I have also run wood shops and been responsible for the up keep of all the machinery.

You want my woodworking experience. 35 years total in a professional capacity. As a finish carpenter, cabinet maker, furniture builder, boat builder, guitar maker, bamboo flyrod maker. I was a 2 year student at the College of the Redwoods fine woodworking program. I have taught classes in woodworking, worked on TV shows (Wood works ) and showed my pieces in plenty of places.

I think I am fairly mechanically inclined.

But even if I was a complete neophyte I would expect a little more respect and courtesy than you have displayed.

Later

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

#10

Re: Byrd helical head or General head for 130

FredD

Gee Link,

given your lengthy list of experience, I don't believe you would have had any difficulty in choosing which planer head to go with, but like you say , could be just speculation on my part.

Please don't put words in my mouth about General , when I said I hadn't heard of it , I was specifically referring to what you said, "a General Head" not General Machines.

Any woodworker who has been around , has noticed the remarkable resemblance between General's machines and their Delta counterparts. Call it what you will.

Please accept apology for not understanding your unstated until now depth of experience and let's put this to rest.

By the way I worked for a short time on the College of the Redwoods with several Journeyman Carpenters from the Union shop in Eureka , I specifically remember hand nailing off shear panel on both sides of every wall in the Laboratory on four inch centers and two of the walls had glass DWV plumbing in them which was expensive ,even that long ago.

FredD