Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Help with cross joint between newel posts

Posts

Help with cross joint between newel posts

#1

Help with cross joint between newel posts

OneDayJD

I'm working on a kitchen island / butcher block table. For the legs I used round, tapered newel posts. In hindsight, I should have probably use regular square posts, but it's done now. Anyway, up under the table top, I am putting a cross-joint (brace?) between the two legs on each end so I can run boards from one side to the other cut out as a wine rack. I am having trouble deciding the best way to mount the cross brace. I've already cut them out, and I had to put a slight angle on them since the newel posts get skinnier from top to bottom. I've made a crude illustration of what I am talking about here...

http://img860.imageshack.us/i/picforforum.jpg/

The best idea I have yet is to sink some holes on the ends of the brace, glue in some pegs, then sink holes on the newel posts, join the pegs into the newel posts and glue. Anyone got any other ideas? I hope I have explained this well enough. The finished table will look similar to this...

http://img228.imageshack.us/i/pw3626l.jpg/

Thanks so much for any help!

-TB

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#2

Ellis Walentine

What you need....

Ellis Walentine

.... is a joint that will stabilize the table while providing the structure you want for your wine rack. Dowels amount to tenons, but they aren't as good as actual tenons, whether fixed or loose. And mortise-and-tenon joints -- including dowel joints -- rely on shoulders to provide stability. Making shoulders on a butt/dowel joint on round tapered legs isn't impossible, but it's not too easy either. And, even if you get it just right, the dowels won't add too much strength to the assembly unless they're unless the M&T joint is large and deep enough.

What I like to do when joining rails to curved stiles is to create a nice square, flat shoulder on the curved parts, with a mortise in the middle. This involves jigging up to rout a flat recess in the side of the leg, parallel to the axis of the leg. A plywood box clamped to the leg, with a slot in it for a template bushing, is a relatively quick way to do this. You can use the same slot to plunge a mortise for a loose tenon with a smaller bit.

Say, for example that your rails are 3/4" thick x 2 1/2" tall. Rout the shallow sockets in the legs to that exact size. Then, rout a 1/2" by 2" long slot mortise in the center of each of these sockets, and a mating mortise on the ends of your rails to form a loose-tenon joint. This way, your rails can be cut off with square ends that will bear on the edges of the recess you routed in the legs.

I hope this makes sense.

Ellis


Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#3

Re: What you need....

OneDayJD

Thanks so much, Ellis. I think I'm following you, but I have a couple more questions. If I was able to do that, what would be the best way to anchor the cross brace in the notches? Or would they just sit in there? Also, my main problem with this is that I don't have a router. I should have clarified that. I'm pretty new to woodworking so my tools are limited. I basically have a drill, miter (chop) saw, jigsaw, and skill saw. Is there any possible way to do this with the tools I have, or is there a cheap workaround? I have a contractor friend who was going to let me come over and use his drill press to cut out the wine rack, so I know he has the tools, but I just hate to have to bother with figuring out a time I can go over to his place, etc. Thanks so much for your help!

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#4

Hand tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One inexpensive solution* is a chisel or two. Decent entry brands (new) are Two Cherries, Lee Valley's plastic-handled chisels, and the Narex they offer (all these are secondhand reports). Used - any good flea market, and look for old wood-handled chisels.

1/4", 1/2", and 3/4" or 1" will be enough to start out.

A piece of thick glass or a marble tile from your big boxy store, and grits of wet-or-dry sandpaper will get you started on sharpening (which is critical).

Experiment with scrap before you apply your new skills to the table legs.

*At least in initial cost. If you get hooked on the hand tool approach, you can find the contents of your wallet evaporating like the dew on a sunny morning.

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#5

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

FredD

Since you sound like this is a area you haven't been to in woodworking JD, I think a socket to in the post to receive the rail if cut close to size would not a need a flat area planed on the post. That should be easy enough for you to do on a drill press for instance and then square the mortise ends with a Chisel.

Then to keep the connection tight over the years use a foxed joint which in your case would be a slot cut into the end of each rail about a inch or so deep , then cut a wedge that will protrude about a 1/4" from the slot before it is fully seated, then insert the sedge with glue and tap the rail into the mortise in the post until the wedge spreads the slot tight.

Cutting the slot is as simple as running the rail end centered over the Table saw blade set to the depth you will use. Use both hands and pay attention when you do this.

This probably will work best if you do a trial run or two with scrap.

If the post was square then the approach could be a simple wood pin or two, but the tight curvature of the post you have would mean cutting a really deep to get a purchase for a pin and would present problems that the wedged joint does not have.

FredD

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#6

Ellis Walentine

Mortise and tenon

Ellis Walentine

There's no way to make a mortise and tenon joint with just the tools you've listed. If you don't have a router, you could drill out the mortises with a drill press and borrow a chisel to square them out, then make the rails with integral tenons on the end to fit the mortises.

I'm only trying to help you make something that is well-made and substantial enough to stand up to normal wear and tear. That's the essence of design: make the thing functional first. If you want a simple way to get something relatively functional without tools or joinery, you could butt the rails to the legs and run bolts , or a pair of long screws, in from the other sides of the legs to hold the rails in place. But, if you want the better woodworking solution, learn about mortise and tenon joints, and tool up to make them.

Let us know what you decide.

Ellis

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#7

A comment and some more thoughts *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Bringing a rail/apron into a curved post is a tough joinery project. I get the impression that, like many of us (my hand rises, in spite of my attempts to keep it down to avoid embarrassment), you've chosen something tougher than your current skill level. That's OK - you can't learn if you don't challenge yourself.

Look at classical architectural details, like porch posts - they tended to avoid bringing rails into turned posts, instead squaring off the portion where the rail joined. On the other hand, the "candlestand" table (link below for one of many examples) brings legs into a turned post.

There are two ways to address the shoulder in a situation like that: angle/curve the shoulders or make a flat spot for a regular shoulder to butt against. You can choose which one is less work, but either one will be more work than bringing a rail to a square/flat surface.


http://pages.antiquesandarts.com/5002/PictPage/1923136623.html

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#8

Re: A comment and some more thoughts

FredD

A third way and one I would consider is just insert the apron or the rail which ever it is, directly into the turned leg.

No flat areas or curved ends required, nor any loose tenons or other hard to fit items, just the rail and the post and patience in cutting a mortise and end slot in the rail for a wedged joint.

FredD

Re: Help with cross joint between newel posts

#9

Ellis Walentine

Probably the best

Ellis Walentine

It might not be the prettiest, and without shoulders, it wouldn't have quite the rack resistance, but it would be strong and it sure would be less complicated.

Ellis