Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Remotes & Glass

Posts

Remotes & Glass

#1

Remotes & Glass

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'm doing a AV console that is to have the components [cable box, etm.] behind clear glass doors. Has anyone here had a problem with remote controls in this configuration? I know that smoked glass will interfere, but wonder if clear glass doors present the same kind of problem. Don't want to have to have the doors standing open when in use.

TIA

M

Re: Remotes & Glass

#2

Re: Remotes & Glass

del schisler

my remote's work thro the clear glass no problum here. Remote's wont work thro wood.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#3

Re: Remotes & Glass

Paul Leuba

Mark, just to be on the safe side before investing your valuable time and materials, why not run a simple test by placing a piece of the glass you intend to use in front of the equipment and exercise the remotes throught a series of functions to see what happens?

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Remotes & Glass

#4

Re: Remotes & Glass

John McGaw

Your typical AV remote operates via pulse-coded infrared light and your typical 'window' glass passes this sort of light quite nicely. Unless you are investing in some sort of special coated glass such as low-E you should be fine.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#5

Re: Remotes & Glass

John Lucas

I put smoked plexiglass in my Stereo cabinet and have never had a problem with a remote. I have 3 different components all that use a different remote and they all work. Don't know about smoked glass.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#6

A.J. Hamler

Some do...

A.J. Hamler

Some do. Depends on the kind of remote. If it's an infrared remote (which most audio/video remotes are) you're right -- it has to be clear for the light beam to go through.

However, RF remotes -- those that use a radio frequency -- go through anything. Car key fobs and garage-door openers are usually RF remotes.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#7

Thanks All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Re: Remotes & Glass

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Hmmm...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wish I had some smoked glass laying around to test the theory. I would think it should pass enough infrared to make remotes usable.

On a side note, I discovered (online) a solution to an annoying problem I was having. I have a Motorola DVR (from Comcast) that was incredibly unresponsive to the remote control at times (no glass in front, BTW). It turns out that LCD TVs can put out a fair amount of infrared noise that interferes with some remote controls. The solution? Put white masking tape over the sensor on the DVR, in my case, two layers did the trick. Now it works quite well.

Jason

Re: Remotes & Glass

#9

Clarify Please?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hi Jason,

We have the same funky Comcast DVR and a large LCD. You saying you blocked the IR sensor on the box but it still works? What tape? A picture please, maybe?

You using the Comcast remote or another? When I put the system back together, we'll be using a Logitech universal which controls the TV, cable, receiver, CD and DVD.

Thanks

Re: Remotes & Glass

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not blocked...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...that's the fix. The white masking tape covers the IR sensor on the DVR, but does not block the IR signal from the remote (I have the "Colts" version of the standard Comcast remote control). Apparently the masking tape filters the noisy IR being emitted from the LCD, while still allowing the remote signal to penetrate.

Our Comcast DVR is one of the newer, all-black models (Motorola DCX3400 series), so it's tricky to find the IR sensor, but if you shine a flashlight on it, you would find it to the upper right, about 2" from the right.

I haven't bothered to do anything to improve the "form" of the solution, so right now, it's only function--two layers of ugly, white masking tape stuck over the IR sensor on the DVR. To clean it up, I would probably cut the tape down to roughly the size of the sensor, then color it black with a Sharpie.

Jason

Re: Remotes & Glass

#11

White?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

By "white" you're referring to the old-type, somewhat yellow, tape as for masking and freezer wraps or is it something else? I have some white Tyvek plastic tape, but I'll have to hunt up some other white tape.

Thanks again, Jason. This may be the solution to a problem SWMBO's been having with the Comcast box[es] for months, so I'd like to get it right.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Yes.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Just the plain-old masking tape. It is a little off-white. It worked, so I haven't (yet?) experimented with other materials, or, like I said, attempting to color it black, rendering it less noticeable.

Jason

Re: Remotes & Glass

#13

Gotit

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Re: Remotes & Glass

#14

Neat

John in NM

Gotta remember that one, betcha it'll come up again :D

Re: Remotes & Glass

#15

Remote option *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Mark,

This won't help with your IR issues, but if you haven't bought the Logitech remote, which I'm guessing is their Harmony remote, take a look at the NSTINCT remote from X10. I bought one for $30 and with a few other very affordable X10 modules, it can turn on the TV, DVD, receiver and dim the lights with one push of a button. It's probably the best built remote I've ever owned. It's BOTH an IR and an RF remote.

The only downside I have seen to it is that since I bought it, I get at least 2 emails a day from X10 about new specials they are running for home security systems and everything else.

It's probably a good site to look for signal repeaters if you want to feed your remote signals through the furniture without any glass.

-Craig


X10 - Remotes, sensors, security, etc.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#16

Re: Remote

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Had the Harmony for a while, but haven't used it because the system was taken down for remodeling the room. No doubt it will need a software update when we're ready.

Thanks for the link, However. I like buttons.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#17

How Much?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Just got a wake-up call when I called for estimates on the two glass doors I need. $95 each for 19-1/4 x 20-1/4 with three holes drilled! Yikes!!

After running down tech support on the question of Acrylite and the remote's IR signals, I've switched the doors to 1/4" acrylic at $30 in materials for the whole job.

I'm wondering if these guys "saw me coming".

Re: Remotes & Glass

#18

Re: How Much?

Craig Daymon

My brother wanted to replace the mirror in his bedroom dresser with a one way mirror and put his flat screen behind it. He shopped around quite a bit, with most prices upwards of $1000. He finally found a local glass shop that did it for about $200, I think. (I could get firm numbers if interested on the mirror if interested.)

Especially when looking for something like one way mirrors, it's a very good idea NOT to let the seller know what you want it for. I think media centers really put stars in the eyes or sellers and dollars on the prices.

Re: Remotes & Glass

#19

Remote signal thru solid door ! it works !

Tom

Are clear doors required ? I used solid wood for a VERY hidden look. All those wires/lights etc. are out of sight. I have a Harmony One and it controls everything. You need on of these gadgets. http://www.amazon.com/Cmple-Extender-Infrared-Repeater-Emitters/dp/B00255NVVS/ If not this one, google "IR repeater".

I also have a Sony PS3 inside the cabinet. As you know that is bluetooth controlled (as opposed to typical IR or RF signals). Logitech sells a device for $50 that converts the Harmony One controller to manage the PS3.

I have 1 remote and no visible wires/lights.

Tom.